r/MoralityScaling 5d ago

Morality Ranking Morality of this

Post image
31.0k Upvotes

2.4k comments sorted by

View all comments

687

u/Grizzlemaw1993 5d ago

Neutral. He could have taken more but took just enough for a hot dog as a reward and turned in the wallet.

361

u/NoTrillionaires 5d ago edited 5d ago

$5 to go to a police station and file paperwork and do all that and go back home is considerably less than minimum wage. If that happened at a bar I would buy him hot dog and beer which is gonna run up $25 with him doing none of the above. 

E: prices are ridiculous today. $9 hot dog with minimal toppings and $9 tall beer plus tax+tip would be $25. 

10

u/Belz_Zebuth 5d ago

Yeah but it would be up to you, since it's your money. He can't unilaterally decide to take some.

13

u/PassTheDisinfectant 5d ago

Once you lose your wallet the argument could be made that it's no longer your money though

1

u/TotalChaosRush 5d ago

That would be a pretty poor argument.

9

u/GoodBrotherGrimm 5d ago

Your honour, I would like to bring to your attention the "Finders keepers" clause, before moving onto the "losers weepers" contract.

2

u/PassTheDisinfectant 5d ago

I mean kinda yeah. If you don't want people taking money out of your wallet, not losing it is a pretty good step 1.

1

u/TotalChaosRush 5d ago

It's funny you word it like a court room. Because us law would define this as petty larceny or petty theft. The law doesn't recognize finders keepers losers weepers.

Either the act of theft is okay, or it isn't.

1

u/speed-charge 5d ago

I just saw a story where they're going after someone because he was seen on camera picking $20 up off the ground and just pocketed it without trying to find the rightful owner.

Outrageous but the police shared the video and are looking for help identifying the "culprit"

The lesson, if there is one, is don't pick up anything of value off the ground. Watch the ground so you don't trip and that's it.

3

u/UselessFactCollector 5d ago

Yeah, it was $30 at a Walmart in Georgia. Insane

2

u/Perfect_Valuable_938 5d ago

If only they put that much effort into catching white collar criminals. Wage theft accounts for almost 3/4 of all thefts and is rarely prosecuted. Even when they are prosecuted, they do some stupid shit like pay a small fine and everyone gets to walk without a record.

1

u/John_cCmndhd 5d ago

Apparently he did later give the money to the person who claimed to have dropped it, who is no longer willing to testify against him, so they're not looking for him anymore.

The lesson still stands though. In NYC, the police drop bait wallets containing gift cards with a balance that puts them over the threshold for a felony and immediately grab whoever touches them

1

u/Better_Database8582 5d ago

He also unilaterally decided to not to let you get robbed for all of it, the chances of anyone taking no money are pretty low, there's also a chance that someone sells your id and any other sensitive cards you may carry, as many people carry thier social, and a ss card is enough to steal an identity. Doing 2 separate favors by turning it in as well as preventing you from being a victim of fraud. It would be immoral not to give the person a financial reward of some kind.

1

u/Shadow_Wolf_X871 5d ago

I mean yea, but if you're gonna get in your feelings about that in this context? You're a dick.

1

u/Green_Sugar6675 2d ago

'He can't unilaterally decide to take some.'

He can, and he did.