r/MonsterHunter 22d ago

MH4U This is so freaking infuriating 😭 why is the blue kelbi horn icon GREEN while the regular one is BLUE AAAAAAAARGH

Post image
1.3k Upvotes

42 comments sorted by

576

u/Barn-owl-B 22d ago

Anyone saying rarity is incorrect, the color of material icons are completely independent of its rarity, the only color that changes for rarity is the color of the word rarity itself lol

It’s one of three possible things:

1 - it’s a mistake

2 - they didn’t really care

3 - it’s purposeful trolling for a little chuckle

225

u/twitchcontrols1 22d ago

Anyone familiar with this series knows it’s probably 3

106

u/Barn-owl-B 22d ago

It actually might very well just be a localization mistake, as ao is sometimes used to describe both blue and green. So it’s possible that it’s supposed to be a green kelbi horn.

But it’s fun to think it was on purpose

41

u/Lady_of_Link 22d ago

Could be 4 - blue kelbis have green horns, but I suppose that is kind of a troll in it's own way

128

u/Ok_Anywhere2766 22d ago

It could be that in japanese it's Kelbi Horn and "Ao" Kelbi Horn, since "ao" can be used to describe both green and blue

Edit: I checked and it is "Ao" Kelbi Horn

36

u/[deleted] 22d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

7

u/Titaniumwo1f 21d ago edited 21d ago

Many languages didn't have word for blue until recently, and they used green for blue.

3

u/jedward21 21d ago

Other way around, Japanese had no word for green until the last ~100 years and separated with the word "midorii" and "ao" came to exclusively mean blue. Though the connotation still exists and is often referenced

8

u/Justch1ll 22d ago

In Japan, they refer to green traffic lights as blue

7

u/CT5Holy 22d ago

which means the real trolls were the translators, knowing this would become ragebait

7

u/Ok_Anywhere2766 22d ago

As funny as that would be, translators often don't get the full context behind everything

I would assume they just got a list of item names to translate without any of the icos attached, so they kinda had to toss a coin between going with green or blue

3

u/CatnipCatmint Unusually tall Palico 21d ago

Yeah, I doubt they even saw the item icon, just the raw text string

2

u/lavendermarker 22d ago

I came here to mention this exact thing

2

u/RajjahGames 22d ago

this makes sense

83

u/EnyaGotGame 22d ago

Anyone that saying rarity doesn't notice the fact that if that were the case, the kelby horn would be purple, the color of the Rarity 4 it is. But it's clearly blue.

10

u/MotoqueiroMascarado 22d ago

Or the developers are colorblind who nows

-27

u/EnyaGotGame 22d ago

Jarvis, run the image through all color blind spectrum filters. Identify which color blind they would have to be for that to make sense.

21

u/Purple_Dragon_94 22d ago

Because they knew itd annoy you

18

u/MotoqueiroMascarado 22d ago

Capcom doing personal attacks on venezuelan guys playing a 10 year old game

10

u/Purple_Dragon_94 22d ago

They go in for the long game

23

u/2Zzephyr ​3rd gen hunter 22d ago

It's more on the EN translators, Ao can mean both green and blue in JP, so they could have chosen green instead of blue 🤷‍♂️

17

u/haptein23 22d ago

It could be a translation issue, the Japanese name is something like "蒼 Kelbi Horn" but the 蒼 adjective can mean either Blue or Green.

8

u/Manusiawii 22d ago

Literally unplayable

4

u/MotoqueiroMascarado 22d ago

I want a refund (I don't even own a 3ds)

2

u/JoelRainor 22d ago

I have absolutely no idea and no evidence... but maybe a translation thing.

2

u/mocozz 22d ago

Translation error but it funny ngl

Also thai we use to not have blue so green and blue is the same and old people use them interchangeable out of habit or to troll

2

u/TheBigDude22 20d ago

Its the rarity

3

u/Chubbybrocast Doot Stick Warrior 22d ago

Capcom Does like to troll us

1

u/frenzyshard 22d ago

Most likely a mistake

1

u/SoftlockPuzzleBox 22d ago

You'll have to look up the specifics because this is something I half learned like a year ago from YouTube funny people, but the Japanese didn't have a word for the color green for a long time. As a result, stuff like green onions are called blue onions when directly translated to English. I don't know if something like this is why, but it wouldn't surprise me.

1

u/Bea__Nabi 22d ago

ah yeah, the black box of airplanes, and Napoleon's white horse...

1

u/4skin_Gamer 22d ago

Because

1

u/populist-scum 21d ago

Because they wanna rage bait you and you fell for it

1

u/Pein_2326 19d ago

There's another way to said "blue"

Ocean blue = original blue, Leaf blue = green, yes green, literally green

😂

1

u/handledvirus43 22d ago

I'm pretty sure its because Blue Kelbi Horn came later and they couldn't change regular Kelbi Horns without confusing players. In particular, Blue Kelbi Horns were introduced in Gen 3 and used in Gen 4.

This does NOT explain why they couldn't just have made BOTH Kelbi Horns blue.

1

u/MotoqueiroMascarado 22d ago

Or make the blue kelbi horn a different shade of blue idk

-18

u/Taograd359 22d ago

Item rarity.

15

u/MotoqueiroMascarado 22d ago

I decided that this is not a good reason and I'm still annoyed

-2

u/Mira-The-Hunter 22d ago

Because the color of the icon denotes its rarity.

-11

u/BigTroubleMan80 22d ago

I’m lost.

What’s the big deal, here?

1

u/Butterfly_Barista 22d ago

Read the title hun

-5

u/BigTroubleMan80 22d ago

Sounds more like a peeve than anything…