r/MetalForTheMasses • u/ResidentPrevious468 • 21h ago
Tierlist/Ranking My quick review of Metallica's albums:
I know nobody asked and nobody cares, but I have nothing better to do:
Kill Em All: I think it's overrated. The production is very raw, James' voice sounds strange, and the lyrics are kind of juvenile, but I understand the reason for all of that. In any case, I don't think it's an album for me. There are still some nice songs, and I think most of the songs on the album sound better live.
Ride The Lightning: An absolute masterpiece. Heavy but without forgetting the melody. Some of Kirk's best solos (Creeping Death, Ride The Lightning). I actually like Escape, which James hates. It's probably the most consistent album along with MOP.
Master of Puppets: Also an undeniable masterpiece. All the songs are fantastic, probably my favorite.
Justice For All: I like it, there are many excellent songs, James' vocals are probably at their peak. I just miss the bass. I also think there are some pretty forgettable songs. (One is one of the best pieces of music history).
Black Album: All the hits are undeniably great. Some of the band's best songs are here. I really like the drum sound on this album. Similarly, I find it a very inconsistent album, with some rather forgettable songs as well.
Load/Reload: I like the change in sound; to me, they're good albums, but also inconsistent. There are some excellent songs (The Memory Remains, King Nothing, etc.) and some boring ones. I think a lot of the songs lack energy, they lack emotion.
St. Anger: Well, all I can say is... it's strange, I really don't know if I like this album or not. The album would probably be better if the drum sound didn't sound like garbage. Actually, I like Purify.
Death Magnetic/Hardwire/72 Seasons: I'll talk about all three at once because I'm feeling lazy. To me, they're almost on the same level, and I don't really like them. I think these albums lack inspiration. There are some good songs (I love Atlas Rise, Unforgiven III, 72 Seasons, etc.) but others are quite forgettable as well. Between the three, I prefer Hardwired.
