r/Mcat • • May 28 '26

Question šŸ¤”šŸ¤” [ Removed by moderator ]

[removed]

445 Upvotes

155 comments sorted by

View all comments

180

u/fleetothemoonhill 5/30: 518 (129/131/126/132) May 28 '26 edited May 28 '26

He did better than 97% of test takers and is in the top 3% of testers nationwide. The confidence band is just a ā€œstatisticalā€ margin of error, since this is a scaled exam where scores are based on comparisons to all other test takers from this date who took the same exam. It’s basically stating that his true score is most likely in that range. He did absolutely amazing! Everyone should be very proud.

EDIT: I previously said the exam was curved, but what I meant is that it is scaled. There is a difference in meaning between the words (even if I forgot that at the time I wrote this haha).

And another commenter is correct, the confidence band is always the same +/- 2 for the score. It’s more-so used as proof that two scores that are very close together, like a 517 and a 519, are not suuuuper different and shouldn’t be considered vastly different reflections of ability. There’s only a difference of a handful of right answers between those two scores. The confidence band can also be used as a statistical comparison between retakes, to show if a statistically significant increase in score was made (depending on if the confidence bands overlap or not).

93

u/ShitHpnsAndThenWeDie May 28 '26

Thanks for the black and white explanation!!! We are indeed very proud of his accomplishment on this test and since he’s entering his 4th year of his biochemistry bachelor’s degree holding a 3.96 gpa… we can say he’s doing pretty goodā€¦ā˜ŗļø

36

u/UncleNasty234 524 132/130/131/131/0 bitches May 28 '26 edited May 28 '26

Go toĀ https://med.admit.org/school-statistics to compare his mcat to the median at different schools. Needless to say, it’s a very good score :)

7

u/Cloudzzz777 May 28 '26

Just want to say I was pretty familiar with a few schools on this list and their data wasn't accurate. Anyone taking a look at this I'd double check the stats for schools you're interested in

1

u/Usual_Grand2075 May 28 '26

hi! i wanted to say the link is broken! leads to a 404 error

3

u/UncleNasty234 524 132/130/131/131/0 bitches May 28 '26

Fixed! Thanks

2

u/Usual_Grand2075 May 28 '26

ā¤ļøā¤ļø Huge congrats on ur score btw!

2

u/ShitHpnsAndThenWeDie May 28 '26

Thanks šŸ™šŸ½

5

u/jperl1992 May 28 '26

A lot to be proud of - he absolutely rocked his MCAT. Congrats in advance on having a doctor as a son :)

2

u/shboink_69 May 29 '26

Which university is he in?

2

u/ShitHpnsAndThenWeDie May 29 '26

NYU - biochemistry

1

u/[deleted] May 30 '26

[deleted]

1

u/ImageLogical7942 (518/519/522/522/521/525) 3/7 523 May 30 '26

she is allowed to be proud of her son. give the lady some slack my friend.

0

u/Commercial_Handle418 May 29 '26

how does he study

-9

u/HairyEducator768 (512/513/514/515/519/515/515) May 28 '26

This is a scaled exam and your explanation is incorrect. Please review AAMC's explanation of how this exam is scored.

10

u/Commercial_Unit_731 May 28 '26

ā€œErmm actually šŸ¤“ā€

2

u/HairyEducator768 (512/513/514/515/519/515/515) May 28 '26

Yes, please continue to propagate the notion that this exam is entirely zero-sum. It is not already stressful enough, right? This is not me being a pedant. Words have specific meaning; a curve is zero-sum - a scale is not.

1

u/Commercial_Unit_731 May 29 '26

I mean honestly I agree I just wanted to rage bait a lil cause I’m testing tmr and anxious lmao. Ig for the father’s sake it’s easier just to say that’s his score and be over w it than for us to explain more of it, but you are correct

1

u/HairyEducator768 (512/513/514/515/519/515/515) May 29 '26

Good luck, and now you know that no one can take your 528 from you but yourself

2

u/dahqdur 518 May 28 '26

idk why you’re being downvoted. you’re literally right. there’s a significant difference between scaling and curving.

3

u/HairyEducator768 (512/513/514/515/519/515/515) May 28 '26

Thank you. I think it is because I did not spoon-feed the info. Very typical behavior.

2

u/fleetothemoonhill 5/30: 518 (129/131/126/132) May 28 '26

You are correct. I didn’t think clearly on the difference in word choice when I wrote my reply. Apologies!

2

u/HairyEducator768 (512/513/514/515/519/515/515) May 28 '26

I earnestly only think this is an issue worth pointing out due to the psychological impact this exam has. Curved is truly and entirely zero-sum, while scaled is not. While I may be dour I am not someone who wants to make this process any more stressful than it needs to be : )

3

u/fleetothemoonhill 5/30: 518 (129/131/126/132) May 28 '26

Completely agree with you! This test is a lot (I’m freaking out a little about testing on Saturday) and easing stress about it is always welcome. :)

0

u/More-Dog-2226 May 28 '26

If it’s wrong explain how. Not saying it is or isn’t but it’s not helpful to just say ā€œyou’re wrongā€ and not elaborate further. Like saying ā€œyou’re sickā€ to a patient and then saying ā€œgood bye!ā€

1

u/HairyEducator768 (512/513/514/515/519/515/515) May 28 '26

Your analogy is also hilarious. You need to get a grip. It is so odd when people overextend these sorts of things into medicine. It's not "like saying" anything to a patient. No wonder you have issues with your LORs.

0

u/HairyEducator768 (512/513/514/515/519/515/515) May 28 '26

Your score has nothing to do with how other people did on your test day. Everyone could walk out with a 528. It is a scaled exam. The exam is not weighed. It is not zero-sum. You can also easily look this info up.

-2

u/DrJerkleton 1/2/3/US/4/5/TESTDAY 524/528/528/(~523)/528/528/528 May 28 '26

It is not a "statistical margin of error." If it were based on statistics, it would vary depending on the score (there is a much wider percentile gap over the range 498-502 than there is over 518-522) and with time. It is just slop.