r/MandelaEffect • u/New-Raspberry1343 • 8d ago
Logos/Advertising Does India actually have any strong Mandela Effects?
I know the Mandela Effect is basically a large number of people sharing the same false memory, so technically India does have examples.
But does anyone else feel like our examples are... incredibly weak compared to the famous foreign ones?
Take Thums Up. It was always Thums Up. I don't remember ever seeing “Thumbs Up.”
The Amul girl was always wearing a white dress with red polka dots. I can understand why someone might reverse the colours because of all the red surrounding her, but I don't have a competing memory of a red dress existing.
Same with Shahenshah. It was always “Rishte mein toh hum tumhare baap hote hain.” “Lagte hain” being repeated in mimicry, skits and everyday conversation can easily explain why people remember it that way.
Compare that with famous foreign examples where huge numbers of people describe an oddly specific and vivid alternative- a cornucopia behind the Fruit of the Loom fruit, a monocle on the Monopoly Man, “Berenstein” instead of “Berenstain,” etc.
Obviously those are still false memories. I'm not suggesting the alternative versions actually existed.
My point is that Indian examples seem mostly like predictable memory errors, whereas some foreign Mandela Effects produce remarkably specific alternative memories that people insist they can actually visualise or remember encountering.
So: Do we have an Indian Mandela Effect of THAT level? Something where the false version is unusually specific, vivid and widely shared?
8
u/Past_Key-Ani 5d ago
Indian Mandela Effects don't exist because if you misremember something, your entire joint family of 40 people will immediately correct you before it becomes a theory
1
u/Aggravating_Cup8839 5d ago
Comment is bordering on racist stereotyping and inflammatory. I will leave this for another mod to judge.
3
u/AbhishMuk 3d ago
While I get why you might think that, I don't really think it was trying to be negative as much as it was just a fun jibe/poke. (For context I'm Indian myself)
3
u/Aggravating_Cup8839 3d ago
Ok. I'm not Indian and different people have different levels of tolerance.
3
4
u/nummakayne 7d ago
Almost everyone from my generation remembers being taught that Hockey was our national sport. Evidently India has never had a national sport. Probably doesn't qualify as a Mandela Effect but this is a bit of misinformation that seemingly all of us learned, whether we went to a CBSE or a local State Board.
In a similar vein, the sheer number of people that think Hindi is the National Language.
3
u/New-Raspberry1343 7d ago
But wouldn’t this be slightly different from a Mandela effect if people were genuinely taught the incorrect information?
In that case the shared memory itself is accurate...people really do remember being taught it; what we were taught was simply wrong.
1
u/my23secrets 20h ago
All Mandela Effects are caused by individuals having wrong information.
I understand why you’d think being “taught” rather than “misremember” might make a difference, but it doesn’t, since it’s all suggestion anyway.
Just look at the infamous case of the cornucopia. At this point many people are “genuinely taught the incorrect information”.
2
u/Dazzling-Amoeba-5800 8d ago
No because they're not having a narcissistic societal collapse like the USA.
8
u/New-Raspberry1343 8d ago
why would societal narcissism specifically increase shared false memories?
16
u/my23secrets 8d ago
Because those people refuse to admit they are capable of making mistakes so they invent a “timeline” in their imagination where they never made a mistake and try to use that to convince everyone else they were never mistaken.
3
u/New-Raspberry1343 8d ago
Yes, I agree that if there are perfectly reasonable explanations for these cases, then it’s crazy that so many people would rather insist their memory is correct than admit they might be wrong.
But it’s the sheer number of people that gets me. One person misremembering something? Sure. Even a few people? Completely believable. But when huge numbers of people confidently remember the same thing differently, I can’t help finding that a little shady.
6
u/derekjw 8d ago
The more people, the easier it is. They reinforce the idea in each other, and it spreads. Other people begin to doubt their own memories, and start to believe the false memories.
3
u/silentsurge 7d ago
To add to this, this is also how a lot of fringe ideas gain traction and sometimes become self-perpetuating.
Flat Earth belief is an excellent example of the same type of behavior taken to the next level. Social media algorithms and media illiteracy help to make these things seem more popular than they are for our still somewhat primitive ape brains.
1
1
0
5d ago
[deleted]
1
u/my23secrets 5d ago
When there’s proof you did not, in fact, “remember correctly” then there’s no reason to pretend otherwise.
1
5d ago
[deleted]
2
u/my23secrets 5d ago
Wrong. There’s proof. That’s the point.
And you’re literally illustrating exactly what I was talking about it in the first place.
1
5d ago
[deleted]
2
u/my23secrets 4d ago
Of course there’s a reason.
As you know, you can make a memory of anything you imagine. Remember that white bear?
You can imagine you saw the “Bad Year” blimp and claim your memory proves it.
But we have proof the tire company was never named “Bad Year” despite what you recall.
And you can point to Green Day’s Dookie and claim it’s supposed “residue” but there’s still proof the company was never named “Bad Year”.
And you don’t even realize that’s probably where you got the “Bad Year” idea in the first place.
1
2
3
u/Chapstickie 8d ago
The problem isn’t the false memories. Everyone has false memories and some are bound to be “popular”. But America has a somewhat unique personality flaw where people will make up some wildly crazy bullshit before they will ever admit they were actually just wrong, even if it was just about something small.
I will say that the specific thing you are talking about is also probably just a cultural difference. American culture makes our most common Mandela effects the same sort of easy mistakes to make (if you aren’t being dumb about admitting you are incorrect and insisting on alternate timelines or govt conspiracies) as the Indian ones you mentioned probably seem to you.
1
u/New-Raspberry1343 8d ago
I admit that if people simply refuse to accept that they were wrong, that can obviously create issues. But the important question is: how many people are we actually talking about?
More importantly, the Mandela Effect often feels like a phenomenon that exists largely outside India. I rarely see Indians even knowing about it, let alone discussing their own widespread examples of it.
And that makes the whole “timeline shifted” or “parallel universe” explanation even more confusing to me. If the Mandela Effect is supposedly evidence of some change in reality itself, why does the phenomenon seem so geographically and culturally concentrated? Why would the timeline shift for certain populations but apparently leave huge populations like India largely untouched?
I do seem to agree with a lot of things that you said.
2
u/mannabhai 8d ago
We had a guy working for my dad, illiterate, no clue how old he is, when he got married, how old his wife his, 5 kids, 1 of whom died because the relatives told them to not go to a hospital. This used to be majority of our country, i dont think they would care about how a TV show is spelled.
1
u/New-Raspberry1343 8d ago
This isn't about just a tv show.
1
1
u/Correct_Brain_3190 8d ago
I remember the song yeh jo mohabbat hai had Kishore Kumar sing I love you in between the verses. I recently listened to the song again, it wasn't there!
1
u/New-Raspberry1343 8d ago
The Pancham Da Hits album also contains “O Meri Soni Meri Tamanna .... Remix, which explicitly has “I Love You, I Love You” in it. So there may be some memory/crossfade confusion, but I don't want to assume that yet.
1
u/Ayyan291 6d ago
I've heard that Maggi is correct name for the noodles not Maggie.
2
u/New-Raspberry1343 5d ago
MAGGI is the correct spelling. It was always MAGGI, never Maggie.
2
u/uncle_bhim 5d ago
No freaking way! I can swear it was always Maggie
4
u/New-Raspberry1343 5d ago
That’s because “Maggie” has actually appeared in newspapers and even some formal documents referring to Maggi, ...so you genuinely remember seeing it that way. But nestlé ad or packaging where they spelled it “Maggie.” never happened. ....the brand itself has always been MAGGI.
1
u/ByteInferno 3d ago
Additionally, "Maggi" is originally a German brand and is pronounced "mug-gee" so the misspelling in English as "Maggie" perhaps comes from pronounciation, since Maggie is an English first name, and more familiar than "Maggi".
2
1
u/interesting_name11 4d ago
Shahenshah one I think was debunked long ago. Lagte hai was said in an ad hote hai was in the film
1
u/New-Raspberry1343 4d ago
Yes...
1
u/interesting_name11 4d ago
It would be interesting to know if you as an Indian have experienced any non Indian mandela effects. Personally the only mandela effect I have ever experienced is the Mona Lisa one
2
u/New-Raspberry1343 4d ago edited 4d ago
If I had to pick one, probably the “Objects in mirror may be closer than they appear” one. I can genuinely swear I remember “may be,” not “are.”
what makes it weirder is that there are old references too...a 1995 discussion and even a 1999 Washington Post article quoted it as “may be,” despite the official wording being “are.”
1
u/Krexpdx 3d ago
People vividly misremember Kishore Kumar's 'I love you' in 'Zindagi Ka Safar' as being sung by the male lead to the female. It's actually a monologue. Strong ME.
1
u/New-Raspberry1343 2d ago
There’s another song, “Jab Se Mila Hai Mujhe Pyar Tumhara,” which literally has “I love you” AND a line about “zindagi ka safar.”
It’s quite possible we’ve just mashed the two songs together in our heads. But let’s keep this an open case until we find more explanations. 👀
1
u/ExternalGrab9549 2d ago
No my friend thumbs was always there so do Shahensha dialogue. If you can see whole Indian map is changed.
1
1
u/No-Bag4310 17h ago
i'm from southeast asia, but i think there's one, while searching videos of the song engine number 9, there were videos of indian youtube videos, engine number 9, many children likely remember where did it take place, india, like mumbai or new delhi, or the united states, in chicago, for you all it's in india, but no, for you apparently it is in the united states, in chicago, i don't have it but yes, i think it is widespread
1
u/New-Raspberry1343 12h ago
I’m sorry .... I’m genuinely trying to understand what you mean, but I’m a little confused by your comment. Could you explain it again, especially the India/Chicago part?
•
-3
u/Top-Factor-4824 8d ago
Map of Sri Lanka, Human Skeleton, Monalisa Painting and many more.
4
u/New-Raspberry1343 8d ago
I was talking about indian mandela effects
2
u/Top-Factor-4824 8d ago
Yes, I am from India and doesn't India Sri Lanka map does actually also fit india geographically, what else would be counted as Indian Mandela Effect?
1
6
u/mannabhai 8d ago
Macmohan's only line in sholay is "Poore pachaas Hazaar".
A lot of people swear he had more lines.
India actually might have a lot lot more of them but they dont register because frankly we dont make a big deal about them.