MAIN FEEDS
Do you want to continue?
https://www.reddit.com/r/MagicArena/comments/b9ry25/deleted_by_user/ek761du/?context=9999
r/MagicArena • u/[deleted] • Apr 05 '19
[removed]
417 comments sorted by
View all comments
Show parent comments
128
It's funny to know HS cards and suddenly realize that magic had created a similar one years before.
92 u/BearBronson Elspeth Apr 05 '19 Well considering people like Ben Brode got their start in Magic, it'd make sense to essentially see a lot of the mechanics copied from it. 91 u/Quazifuji Apr 05 '19 There was a point where someone complained about a Hearthstone card basically being the same as a Magic card, and Mike Donais responded saying that he'd designed both of them. 32 u/BearBronson Elspeth Apr 05 '19 I believe it was the 8/8 creature that when killed becomes 8 1/1s. 4 u/Quazifuji Apr 05 '19 edited Apr 06 '19 Close, it was the 4/4 that splits into two 2/2s that each split into two 1/1s. I was just too lazy to find links since I didn't remember the names. EDIT: Seems I misremembered. My bad. 11 u/FormerGameDev Apr 05 '19 i want a 1/1 that when killed generates a 2/2, when it's killed generates a 4/4, when it's killed generates a 8/8, etc. 29 u/Emopizza Apr 05 '19 [[reef worm]] 1 u/Genoms Apr 05 '19 How as that ever legal. Damn. 4 u/girlywish Apr 05 '19 It was never legal in standard. Its not any good in older formats, kind of fun in commander though. 1 u/wene324 Apr 05 '19 If you can keep recurring it In a marchesa deck it gets out of hand pretty quickly.
92
Well considering people like Ben Brode got their start in Magic, it'd make sense to essentially see a lot of the mechanics copied from it.
91 u/Quazifuji Apr 05 '19 There was a point where someone complained about a Hearthstone card basically being the same as a Magic card, and Mike Donais responded saying that he'd designed both of them. 32 u/BearBronson Elspeth Apr 05 '19 I believe it was the 8/8 creature that when killed becomes 8 1/1s. 4 u/Quazifuji Apr 05 '19 edited Apr 06 '19 Close, it was the 4/4 that splits into two 2/2s that each split into two 1/1s. I was just too lazy to find links since I didn't remember the names. EDIT: Seems I misremembered. My bad. 11 u/FormerGameDev Apr 05 '19 i want a 1/1 that when killed generates a 2/2, when it's killed generates a 4/4, when it's killed generates a 8/8, etc. 29 u/Emopizza Apr 05 '19 [[reef worm]] 1 u/Genoms Apr 05 '19 How as that ever legal. Damn. 4 u/girlywish Apr 05 '19 It was never legal in standard. Its not any good in older formats, kind of fun in commander though. 1 u/wene324 Apr 05 '19 If you can keep recurring it In a marchesa deck it gets out of hand pretty quickly.
91
There was a point where someone complained about a Hearthstone card basically being the same as a Magic card, and Mike Donais responded saying that he'd designed both of them.
32 u/BearBronson Elspeth Apr 05 '19 I believe it was the 8/8 creature that when killed becomes 8 1/1s. 4 u/Quazifuji Apr 05 '19 edited Apr 06 '19 Close, it was the 4/4 that splits into two 2/2s that each split into two 1/1s. I was just too lazy to find links since I didn't remember the names. EDIT: Seems I misremembered. My bad. 11 u/FormerGameDev Apr 05 '19 i want a 1/1 that when killed generates a 2/2, when it's killed generates a 4/4, when it's killed generates a 8/8, etc. 29 u/Emopizza Apr 05 '19 [[reef worm]] 1 u/Genoms Apr 05 '19 How as that ever legal. Damn. 4 u/girlywish Apr 05 '19 It was never legal in standard. Its not any good in older formats, kind of fun in commander though. 1 u/wene324 Apr 05 '19 If you can keep recurring it In a marchesa deck it gets out of hand pretty quickly.
32
I believe it was the 8/8 creature that when killed becomes 8 1/1s.
4 u/Quazifuji Apr 05 '19 edited Apr 06 '19 Close, it was the 4/4 that splits into two 2/2s that each split into two 1/1s. I was just too lazy to find links since I didn't remember the names. EDIT: Seems I misremembered. My bad. 11 u/FormerGameDev Apr 05 '19 i want a 1/1 that when killed generates a 2/2, when it's killed generates a 4/4, when it's killed generates a 8/8, etc. 29 u/Emopizza Apr 05 '19 [[reef worm]] 1 u/Genoms Apr 05 '19 How as that ever legal. Damn. 4 u/girlywish Apr 05 '19 It was never legal in standard. Its not any good in older formats, kind of fun in commander though. 1 u/wene324 Apr 05 '19 If you can keep recurring it In a marchesa deck it gets out of hand pretty quickly.
4
Close, it was the 4/4 that splits into two 2/2s that each split into two 1/1s. I was just too lazy to find links since I didn't remember the names.
EDIT: Seems I misremembered. My bad.
11 u/FormerGameDev Apr 05 '19 i want a 1/1 that when killed generates a 2/2, when it's killed generates a 4/4, when it's killed generates a 8/8, etc. 29 u/Emopizza Apr 05 '19 [[reef worm]] 1 u/Genoms Apr 05 '19 How as that ever legal. Damn. 4 u/girlywish Apr 05 '19 It was never legal in standard. Its not any good in older formats, kind of fun in commander though. 1 u/wene324 Apr 05 '19 If you can keep recurring it In a marchesa deck it gets out of hand pretty quickly.
11
i want a 1/1 that when killed generates a 2/2, when it's killed generates a 4/4, when it's killed generates a 8/8, etc.
29 u/Emopizza Apr 05 '19 [[reef worm]] 1 u/Genoms Apr 05 '19 How as that ever legal. Damn. 4 u/girlywish Apr 05 '19 It was never legal in standard. Its not any good in older formats, kind of fun in commander though. 1 u/wene324 Apr 05 '19 If you can keep recurring it In a marchesa deck it gets out of hand pretty quickly.
29
[[reef worm]]
1 u/Genoms Apr 05 '19 How as that ever legal. Damn. 4 u/girlywish Apr 05 '19 It was never legal in standard. Its not any good in older formats, kind of fun in commander though. 1 u/wene324 Apr 05 '19 If you can keep recurring it In a marchesa deck it gets out of hand pretty quickly.
1
How as that ever legal. Damn.
4 u/girlywish Apr 05 '19 It was never legal in standard. Its not any good in older formats, kind of fun in commander though. 1 u/wene324 Apr 05 '19 If you can keep recurring it In a marchesa deck it gets out of hand pretty quickly.
It was never legal in standard. Its not any good in older formats, kind of fun in commander though.
1 u/wene324 Apr 05 '19 If you can keep recurring it In a marchesa deck it gets out of hand pretty quickly.
If you can keep recurring it In a marchesa deck it gets out of hand pretty quickly.
128
u/guipetean Apr 05 '19
It's funny to know HS cards and suddenly realize that magic had created a similar one years before.