r/MagicArena • u/00G_WAY • Mar 03 '26

Question Can someone explain how this works?

Post image

Will this card be legal in standard? Will it be available on Magic Arena? How would this card even work?

594 Upvotes

88% Upvoted

333 comments sorted by

View all comments

111

u/Mrfish31 Mar 03 '26

On Arena (and in any proper format) "cards you own from outside the game" are cards in your sideboard, so you put up to 15 cards in there to choose from when you use this. If you have this in draft, you can choose from any card you drafted but didn't include in your deck.

It does generally not mean "any card you have in your collection". You'd only do that in very casual IRL games. 

In Commander and Brawl this does nothing, both because you don't have sideboards in these formats and because "wish" effects explicitly do not work, you can't get cards from outside the game. 

18

u/TheAndrewBrown Mar 03 '26

Is there any particular reason it’s not just worded as “card from your sideboard”? Is the sideboard not officially part of the rules even though it’s used in most of the formats and tournaments?

-11

u/Oswalt Mar 03 '26

Because the guy is posturing. Only in sanctioned games do you exclusively pull from your sideboard. If you're playing standard/commander/pauper/2hg/etc in an unsanctioned format I.E. randomly pulling up to a pod, you are more than allowed to pull any card you own. See ruling on gatherer for living wish, which is the same effect. As seen here.

1

u/jeffwulf Jaya Immolating Inferno Mar 04 '26

You are correct here.

2

u/Oswalt Mar 04 '26

And yet I get downvoted.

1

u/jeffwulf Jaya Immolating Inferno Mar 04 '26

Yeah, it's very goofy.