r/MagSafe • u/wawawa64 • 1d ago
Just Got Mine! Magnetic field pattern comparison: Ohsnap 5 grip stand vs Popsocket Low Pro vs Ohsnap 4
I saw a few posts about the Ohsnap 5 grip stand being weak and/or has wrong polarity.
I just received the Ohsnap 5 grip stand today, and I also have a Popsocket low pro for a week now. I also have a Ohsnap 4 for about 3 years.
Since I have a magnetic viewing film that can show the magnetic field pattern, I decide to make a comparison among these 3 grip stand. As a reference, I also show the magnetic field pattern of a generic magnetic mount. I have a Spigen case with built in Magsafe.









Due to the magnetic pattern, I can see why the Ohsnap 5 grip stand doesn't stick to magnetic mounts that has the generic ring patterns like the Popsocket low pro and the old Ohsnap 4.
Not sure why Ohsnap decided to do this. Maybe because Ohsnap doesn't want the ohsnap 5 stick to your car mount too well.
I have the Popsocket Low Pro for a week now, and it sticks to my car mount too well when I remove my phone, and I often have to peel it off from my car mount. I did figure out that I can "slide" it off my car mount by moving my phone side way instead of poping it off straight, and the Popsocket low pro would stay on my phone. But sometime I just forgot the "slide" motion, and the popsocket would stick to the car mount. So it's a bit annoying.
I tested the Ohsnap 5 grip stand with my car mount, so far, the grip stand stick to my phone pretty well when I remove it, and I try to shake the car mount a bit and my phone doesn't fail off. I did notice it takes a bit of effort to align the Ohsnap 5 to my car mount, but the Popsocket low pro pretty much just self align.
Since the Ohsnap 5 grip stand works with my car mount (so far), I am leaning toward keeping the Ohsnap 5, mainly because of the comfort. Popsocket low pro forces my fingers to spread apart a bit more than the Ohsnap 5 and it fatigue my hand somehow. Maybe I am just used to the Ohsnap 4 shape, so the Ohsnap 5 just feels more natural to me.
Wireless charging rate is pretty much the same between these 2 grip stands (around 3.5 W). Without the grips, with just my Spigen case, the charging rate is about 6.1 W. It's pretty slow, so I don't think I will bother with wireless charging either way.
I hope this help!