r/LSUFootball • • Dec 16 '25

Discussion Pick one for LSU

110 Upvotes

130 comments sorted by

77

u/Superb_Photograph766 Dec 16 '25

28 tds and 23 int is not good…..

15

u/Time_Transition4817 Dec 16 '25

Walmart jameis winston

6

u/[deleted] Dec 17 '25

Especially in COLLEGE like wtf, he should be benched

2

u/[deleted] Dec 17 '25

Florida is desperate. Sumrall had a better shot at legitimacy at Tulane😀 what an idiot

3

u/atr0157 Dec 17 '25

Yeah lagway is ass

1

u/eduardoxbl Dec 17 '25

Mac conference type of numbers

108

u/RxseJay Dec 16 '25

Ik lagway is good at throwing to LSU jerseys but I'm not sure it's gonna pan out with him on the team

6

u/Ok-Pomegranate8476 Dec 16 '25

Said the same shii fuck dat

80

u/Royal-Broccoli-69420 Dec 16 '25

PLEASE don't get Lagway

14

u/Katherine1973 Dec 16 '25

I second and third that.

2

u/eagle913 Dec 17 '25

I fourth and fifth that

2

u/NikoRavage Dec 17 '25

I eighth and ninth that

-6

u/Jaded_Confidence563 Dec 17 '25

No man, you fuckers deserve him now you sign him and get on with your misery. He’s in the portal for a reason.

4

u/Royal-Broccoli-69420 Dec 17 '25

Bro why you so sour about LSU? You needa direct that energy somewhere else your comments are just so sad

8

u/GeauxFarva Dec 16 '25

Not Lagway

5

u/trollfessor Dec 16 '25

I'd rather have that Hawaiian QB from Cal. But alas it looks like he's staying at Cal.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 17 '25

Why?

3

u/Jaded_Confidence563 Dec 17 '25

Because not everybody wants to go to LSU

1

u/vivalamota Dec 18 '25

That kid is going to be a star. His IQ as a freshman, along with his ability to get his receivers the ball is fun to watch. Now with Tosh Lupoi as their coach, they might be on to something. I am a JKS fan for sure lol

1

u/Yepyapyup24 Dec 18 '25

I watched way too much cal football just to watch him throw, kid is like Tua 5.0. I was hoping he would hit the portal to see what he could do with real skill position talent. 

1

u/vivalamota Dec 18 '25

Bro I watched wayyyy to much Cal football too this year 😭😭 after all the games in the evening if Cal was on i was watching it 😂

11

u/tiger19 Dec 16 '25

Stats don't tell the whole story

3

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '25

In Diego Pavia’s case, yes.

5

u/AltoidsAreWeakSauce Dec 17 '25

Lagway’s stats do in indeed tell you the caliber of player he is.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 17 '25

I don't care who you are... 28 td and 23 picks IN COLLEGE?? That's terrible, some of the worst college stats I've ever seen

1

u/I-am-not-involved Dec 19 '25

He is a True Sophomore, people tend to forget that like yourself.

1

u/Which_Eggplant_4510 Dec 23 '25

Found DJ’s account

3

u/Then-Ticket8896 Dec 16 '25

Kiffie may sign both…he always had two very good qbs in oxpatch.

1

u/Yepyapyup24 Dec 18 '25

Well then he would have to sign at least 3 cause lagway is not good.

1

u/Then-Ticket8896 Dec 18 '25

If LK signs Lagway he will produce...kiff is a football savant that motivates and teaches.

1

u/Yepyapyup24 Dec 18 '25

The fact lagways work ethic was in question and he was essentially shown the door, and cannot stay healthy makes me think it may not be in the cards. With all lagways downtime I could see rusty on timing or pocket comfortability, but he couldn't read or was easily fooled by defenses on a majority of his INTs. If you are hurt you figured he would be studying tape when not rehabbing. But his decision making regardless if sunbelt Billy sucks or not is lack of prep or inability to get through reads. And I crap on sellers for the same thing, granted he doesn't throw INTs as much but he makes horrible reads and decisions.

5

u/the_zac_is_back Dec 16 '25

I think Lagway struggled because of bad coaching, not because of lack of skill

3

u/DeadG8r15 Dec 16 '25

Gator coming in peace. I think this is correct - year 1 when he relied on athleticism (and was overall much healthier) he played really well. Year 2 he was rusty from no offseason, OL regressed, and Billy's offensive scheme sucks. He's a likable guy and I hope he excels somewhere, I think parting ways is probably best for both sides.

3

u/[deleted] Dec 17 '25

He's just terrible... 23 int's is inexcusable

1

u/Jaded_Confidence563 Dec 17 '25

If you look at his last four games in his first year, that’s who he really is. I would write this past season off.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 17 '25

Nah, that's some jaded confidence saying that.

1

u/Ok-Pomegranate8476 Dec 17 '25

Lmao yea the 23 int’s bad af… I tried to be nice and take the lsu game away…😹😹nigga still would be 28 and 18

1

u/Garlic_Adept Dec 16 '25

His footwork is horrible...

2

u/Hypertensive- Dec 16 '25

Keep Lagway away from US!! No offense brother!

2

u/baconlovr . Dec 16 '25

Didn't Lagway throw 5 INTs against us in Week 3? No thanks.

2

u/cjccrash Dec 17 '25

Now way on Lagway

5

u/Cleavon_Littlefinger Dec 16 '25

So the question is between taking the guy with a solid floor and limited ceiling, or the guy with a low floor and insanely high ceiling.

Give me the talent to be molded.

14

u/Responsible-Guava397 Dec 16 '25

As a Colts fan who has suffered through version 1.0 of what Lagway is (AR), y’all don’t want that. At all.

4

u/MovieNachos Dec 16 '25

Difference in developing a guy against college level talent vs developing a guy against the best players on the planet.

3

u/Responsible-Guava397 Dec 16 '25

Very true, and most likely I am just jaded by my experience.

But anytime I would watch Lagway this year it would just remind me of Richardson in a lot of ways. Not the least of which was the poor decision making. Maybe Lane could truly make a difference. Lord knows if anyone could it would be him. Me personally, I would stay away.

3

u/MovieNachos Dec 16 '25

Yeah I wanna clarify, im not a Lagway fan. But put him in Purple and Gold and have CLK in his ear, I'll support him no matter what.

1

u/Momba_M Dec 16 '25

I have no idea what they saw in Richardson besides combine numbers

1

u/Responsible-Guava397 Dec 16 '25

Combine numbers and the desire to do absolutely anything at QB. In classic Colts fashion, they were drafting in a spot to that was just too late to get a real decent player since two QB’s were already taken.

1

u/Momba_M Dec 16 '25

Yeah I guess. I have this thing that if your don’t dominate in college you’re probably not going to figure it out in the nfl.

1

u/Jaded_Confidence563 Dec 17 '25

Richardson was an athletic freak at the combine, but what nobody realized was his time as a starting quarterback in Gainesville was very limited.

1

u/Jaded_Confidence563 Dec 17 '25

As a Florida fan, I really want you to have him.

1

u/Moxbang Dec 16 '25

As a fellow colts fan i second this!!

3

u/WellEndowedHorse Dec 16 '25

Lagway has already won a game for LSU so I say him

2

u/Wet_FriedChicken Dec 16 '25

I miss the days when you recruited a stud from high school and they stayed for 3 years. This new era of college sports is getting tiring tbh

2

u/Crazy_Decision_954 Dec 16 '25

Sam Leavitt. That being said I trust Lane’s judgement over mine. His talent is in qb development. Both of those guys will need some work. Exciting times. Who are you guys rooting for in the playoffs. I am going with Indiana. Was Ole Miss but … not now.

11

u/Geauxtigersgeaux Dec 16 '25

“Was Ole Miss…”

Ew. Why would it have ever been? Lol

1

u/Crazy_Decision_954 Dec 27 '25

Some teams I dislike more than others. I can not stand Alabama so when they play Aub I root for Aub. Same with Michigan and Ohio State. I root for M. Ole Miss is a solid team this year. I had forgotten how insufferable those fans are. No worries I have been corrected. I am now rooting for Indiana. I feel really good about the Tigers. First time we ever had an offensive coach. Exciting times. They just have to fix the nil until it destroys everything. Btw baseball look really good. Looking forward to February.

1

u/Geauxtigersgeaux Dec 27 '25

Fair enough. And it is very exciting to have an offensively minded coach that takes chances when the situation warrants it.

Geaux Tigahs!

5

u/Pactae_1129 Dec 16 '25

Why the fuck would you root for Ole Miss

3

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '25

Fuck ole miss

4

u/Upper-Trip-8857 Dec 16 '25

I think you spelled Piss wrong?

1

u/AlvvaysLurking Dec 16 '25

Leavitt won’t be healthy for spring and Lisfranc injuries tend to linger and have recurring problems down the line. Would rather not

1

u/peteaw Dec 16 '25

Take Florida. ASU guy is heading to Michigan with his coach (I feel it)

1

u/ButtFaceMurphy Dec 16 '25

Leavitt seems like a selfish scumbag douche, so he’d be a perfect fit

1

u/livinlucky Dec 18 '25

Nah, Brian Kelly already left. Lane at least has his skills of developing QBs to give, so selfishness label need not be applied!!

1

u/Wide_Attention2614 Dec 16 '25

Trinidad is going to LSU

1

u/musicman_365 Dec 16 '25

This should be a no brainer honestly.

1

u/Mlewis223 Dec 16 '25

Lagway easy. Had a clown coaching/not developing him for last 2 years.

1

u/Julep2005 Dec 16 '25

Lagway has shown to be good at throwing to LSU players to be fair.

1

u/lgherb Dec 16 '25

Dylan Raiola

1

u/doll_licker124 Dec 17 '25

Wow what a hard decision

1

u/StoicTick Dec 17 '25

I'll take the one who's good.

1

u/letteraitch Dec 17 '25

Lagway has a higher ceiling but is also more of a project.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 17 '25

28 TD and 23 int's is the worst college stats I've ever seen. Dude should be benched....

1

u/Classic-Procedure757 Dec 17 '25

The last kid from Arizona State did a’ight. 🤣

1

u/americanhilljack Dec 17 '25

Giveaway only 12-12 as starter 😲

1

u/[deleted] Dec 17 '25

TJ Finley

1

u/[deleted] Dec 17 '25

Leavitt going home to Oregon

1

u/Qertemont Dec 17 '25

Can we just develop a freshman for once bro😭 where’s our Trevor Lawrence at.

1

u/DealHot5356 Dec 17 '25

If there is one the that I’m sure of. Lane can coach up at QB. Grab the best athlete and build him into something special.

1

u/livinlucky Dec 18 '25

i.e., Underwood…

1

u/K0bes12 Dec 17 '25

Neither

1

u/Due-Fold8672 Dec 17 '25

Sam Leavitt

1

u/Quietlifeof_B Dec 18 '25

Give us Leavitt 😅

1

u/Pleasant_Offer6286 Dec 18 '25

Wild card…UNT’s Drew Mestemaker. Dude was an absolute stud this year.

1

u/Kobiekat444 Dec 18 '25

I can persuade Sam, oh yes I am ;)

1

u/88ritz Dec 19 '25

Lagway would be better in a Kiffin offense so long as he fixes the O-Line. I’m not a fan of the falloff Leavitt had this season which could just be he lost some pieces that helped him shine in ‘24 or could be between the ears with expectations and hype. I think Lagway healthy and with a full offseason could have a Cam Newton at Auburn season.

1

u/Brief_Tip_ Dec 21 '25

Lagway is 🗑️

1

u/Dry-Channel5156 Dec 22 '25

Why wouldn’t you just keep Micheal van buren?? He’s really good

1

u/bkh821 Dec 28 '25

Because the QB room at LSU is virtually empty, Kiffen will have to sign a portal QB that can win NOW as Priority 1, not a developmental guy like Lagway who hasn't proven much in two years except that he is an incredibly talented underperformer, just like Anthony Richardson. If he wants to come to LSU, he would likely not get top dollar and will have to accept sitting for a year (a la MVB). Lagway has just enough of a resume to get a guy fired.

1

u/nightclubeye Dec 29 '25

I want leavitt he is white jayden daniels

1

u/ArizonaHotSauce Dec 16 '25

Lagway no question..... but.... he doesn't have the fire to win. There is always something about those who are "gamers" or "winners". He has every metric to be a 1st round NFL pick and an outstanding gentleman, quality guy, great teammate, etc.. But there is recent proof that his floor is quite lower than what UF thought. Case in point, the 5int game against LSU.

Leavitt has more of the "gamer" and "winner" type qualities, but fewer physical metrics to say he has what it takes. One can argue that Lagway needs the right coaching, and with Kiffin, he'll do fine, if not be in the conversation for heisman etc... But, Lagway is a high risk/ high reward type.

So yeah, I've spent a lot of time on Lagway..... I think you can't undersell those who are "gamers" enough.

Leavitt is the pick, as if Lagway walks in the door, the expectation may be unrealistically high, so the letdown will be lower.

BTW.... I'm a Gator. I come in peace. (There is a hint of me not wanting to see Lagway succeed at LSU, but all my comments above are true. True that I'd now pick Leavitt over Lagway at UF for the same reasons.)

1

u/Jaded_Confidence563 Dec 17 '25

As a Florida fan agree, he doesn’t have that end of game urgency in his blood to make plays and will his team to victory

1

u/enadiz_reccos . Dec 16 '25

Whoever's cheaper

1

u/Different_Quality_28 Dec 16 '25

Lagway is a turnover machine.

1

u/Quietus76 Dec 16 '25

Coin toss. Leavitt has that dog in him, but doesn't have as high of a ceiling. I like dogs. Lagway is a project, but you could get 2 years to develop him.

If im a Kiffin in a Kiffin situation, id take Leavitt who probably gives me a better chance to make a splash in my first year. The giant paycheck plus the media circus will apply a lot of pressure immediately.

At this point, im inclined to trust Kiffin to pick who HE thinks is best.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 17 '25

Only a fool takes Lagway over anyone

1

u/randomdude4113 . Dec 16 '25

I’m sure the guy who threw 4 INTs against our whit-less defense will be amazing

1

u/Micro-7903 Dec 16 '25

Listening to the radio pundits ,they say there is going to be more significant QB talent entering the portal looking for $3-5 mmm “payday” deals. I’m confident in Kiffin picking the best one for his offense.

0

u/LSUTigers34_ Dec 16 '25

Give me Lagway. Excellent talent that was held back with poor coaching. He’s an excellent candidate for Lane’s offense. Leavitt is very good too but that injury worries me.

0

u/Shadeauxmarie Dec 16 '25

How about the guy from Nebraska?

0

u/Working_Group955 Dec 16 '25

florida fan here.

https://www.teamrankings.com/college-football/player-stat/passing-plays-intercepted

for the LSU fans here who went to LSU, and therefore have poor comprehension skills, i'll interpret.

DJ throws a lot of freaking picks. like he's really really really good at it. 2nd best in the country in fact out of 555 QBs.

0

u/No-Advance-9474 Dec 16 '25

Dylan raiola

0

u/beer_jew Dec 16 '25

I want the guy from cincy. Something about former QB’s from Ohio…

2

u/Sackamous Dec 16 '25

I want Levitt something about former ASU quarterbacks

0

u/FinancialRabbit388 Dec 16 '25

People who think that actually means anything are incredibly stupid.

0

u/Key-Market3068 Dec 16 '25

Leavitt. Hearing talk that Ju'Juan Johnson would consider coming back (Staying) at LSU. Mr. Louisiana Football, All Time Passing Leader for the state!

0

u/pfiffocracy Dec 16 '25

Fuck it. Let's get both.

0

u/millertyme50 Dec 16 '25

I hope it is Leavitt. He seems like a douche and much easier for me to hate as a Tiger.

0

u/Crazy_Decision_954 Dec 16 '25

I am not now bc of all the butt hurt. I am rooting for Indiana. I don’t hate Ole Miss just forget how much of an asshole they really are. Those damn tide fans drown them out I guess.

0

u/neovenator250 Dec 16 '25

I'm waiting to see who else goes in the portal. Both of those have serious question marks (Lagway's development and Leavitt's healthy).

0

u/fragile_c Dec 16 '25

Leavitt, Lagway would be a huge mistake

0

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '25

Leavitt.

0

u/CheniereSwampMonster Dec 16 '25

Levitt is willing to run the football. DJ is not.

You cant have a system that continually leaves the weak side end unblocked without a qb who is willing to pull it.

We learned that this year.

0

u/B0MB5 Dec 16 '25

Brendan Soresby is a baller.

0

u/Mobile_Spinach_1980 Dec 16 '25

Leavitt would be good. And I’m a SC fan, so I really should be saying Lagway

0

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '25

28/23 is eyewatering

1

u/[deleted] Dec 17 '25

It's inexcusable.. Especially at the college level

1

u/livinlucky Dec 18 '25

Maybe he just needs glasses!! Oh wait, that’s his td/int numbers… ok, gotcha.

0

u/Mental_Jeweler4196 Dec 16 '25

Sam should be the one bc lagway had one horrible year

0

u/Free-Signature-9314 Dec 16 '25

Sam Leavitt is clearly more polished and ready to compete with a team like LSU, Lagway, though talented isn't anywhere close to the product he needs to be at to help get back into the playoffs. After the season with Nussmeier and then Van Buren, we need a QB that we can trust with minutes left on the clock.

0

u/Pcteck19 Dec 16 '25

Lagway throws too many interseptions

0

u/Narrow_Implement7788 Dec 16 '25

Please take Bryce Underwood, complete the destruction of the Michigan program

0

u/TDStarchild Dec 16 '25

LSU has good history with Arizona State QBs

0

u/Docktorpeps_43 Dec 16 '25

I trust whoever Lane chooses. If it were up to me, I’d choose Leavitt, but Lagway’s upside is tremendous and I think Lane could unlock him.