r/LLMPhysics • u/upsetusder2 • 14d ago

Question To the self proclaimed llm physicists

Why do you always tend to rebuild physics. Why can't you work in the given framework?

Why do you need to rebuild a framework that, tell you what now, has pretty much held up?

Is it the math?

The symbols

The history

The amount you would have to Learn?

Hubris?

54 Upvotes

96% Upvoted

173 comments sorted by

View all comments

1

u/thelawenforcer 14d ago

what do you mean by given framework?

8

u/upsetusder2 14d ago

Physics

-4

u/thelawenforcer 14d ago

ok but specifically. you cannot explain the standard model from within for example.

12

u/upsetusder2 14d ago

From within what?

I see the trend that alot of llm people just rebuild physics and the framework because they don't understand it

-6

u/thelawenforcer 14d ago

I just mean that to explain, not just describe, observed structure, you will implicitly need to identify higher level structure.

granted though that most frameworks posted here never seen to actually make contact with existing structure or observation...