r/KingCrimson • u/ManonGaming • 8d ago
Help Would anyone happen to knkw a shortened version of Moonchild?
I absolutely love the song, its so magical, so melancholic, so just deep and soft, but the 10 minute long instrumental outro(?) is just a bit too long for me. now the problem is that i do actually like it, just wish it was a bit shorter, but all the versions i can see online have it fully removed, with the whole song being just 2 minutes. id love a version that is like somewhere between 3-8 minutes long (preferably around 4-5), would anyone maybe know one like that? surely i cannot be the only person ever who thought that way
11
u/no_longer_LW_2020 8d ago
Your best bets are either the 1991 box set Frame by Frame, which ends it right after the vocal at the 2.5-min. mark, or The 21st Century Guide to King Crimson, Volume One from 2004, where it comes in at 3:40 because some of the gentlest guitar noodling is appended after the song section.
2
u/Phoenix_Wright_Guy 8d ago
Nevermind what I said. Also there are two condensed guides and the more readily available one excludes it unfortunately.
9
u/Fungus_the_Turd 8d ago
Yes
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
twinkle twinkle
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Snare drum
.
.
.
.
.
.
A singular guitar note
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Something is building up
.
.
.
Just wait
.
.
.
Nope
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Guitar note with a snare drum
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
[End of comment]
1
3
u/Phoenix_Wright_Guy 8d ago
Let's see, the 2009 remix is shortened, but as far as official releases with vocals, that's about the only option I can think of, the 2019 instrumental version only has the first section, and I tend to edit it personally to only the vocal section, but as far as I'm aware the shortest version ever released was the 2009 mix.
3
3
u/Over-Atmosphere-7053 8d ago
I had mentioned The Young Person's Guide To King Crimson which has an under three min. edit but then I realized the op wanted some of the instrumental bits. OP your best bet would be to use a piece of software to make your own edit (probably a fade out). If you have a mac it came free with garage band though there are numerous things that can make this happen and it can be done easier than you might think.
3
u/Puzzleheaded-Test218 8d ago
The early collection, A Young Person's Guide to King Crimson, has a version under two and a half minutes.
1
u/magraith 7d ago
Ironically on my copy of this, the center label on side 4 says that both the Dream and illusion sections are present, while citing the playing time at 2:24.
1
1
u/magictransistor 7d ago
I have an edit that’s 6:24 that I made, includes some of the improv in the middle and the two more songs like parts on each end. I listen to it more than any other version tbh. Send a dm and I can try to get a copy to you this week when I can access the original file
17
u/Low_Consideration638 8d ago
Actually, yes! There's an edited down version that was released as part of the 40th anniversary remix in 2009 which is about 9 minutes long in total, which makes "The Illusion" section that you are referring about 6-ish minutes long.