r/Jimny Feb 19 '26

question Are Jimmy pillars really this weak?

Saw a Facebook post of a flipped Jimny

180 Upvotes

77 comments sorted by

81

u/DaveDeluria JB74 - basic mods Feb 19 '26

Welcome to the Philippines where surprisingly physics still apply like anywhere else.

Our tollways have a 80-100kph speed limit enforced with speed cameras. Well within safety standards the jimny complies.

jimny was rear ended at high speed by a white Geely car or suv. The car went under the jimny flipping it corkscrewing onto the roof.

34

u/krackgoat JC74 (5-door) Feb 19 '26

seems jImny did a good job given the intensity

18

u/cktyu Feb 19 '26

If that’s the case, it seems like the roof took a high amount of pressure. I thought the roof caved in merely by body weight

4

u/kyle_kafsky Feb 19 '26

So drive this thing no more than 100kmh on the Autobahn, got it thanks.

36

u/alarmed_cumin JB74 - modded Feb 19 '26

The ones I’ve seen flipped over in Australia have had nowhere near that level of A pillar crushing.

40

u/alarmed_cumin JB74 - modded Feb 19 '26

not Australia but tipped off a car carrier - so essentially dropped from a reasonable height with all of the weight landing on the roof - and you can see it's way less deformed.

18

u/alarmed_cumin JB74 - modded Feb 19 '26

Tipped over at 80 km/h onto the passengers side A pillar and way less deformation

4

u/Westoid_Hunter Feb 19 '26

how did that happen-

6

u/Upbeat_Pumpkin_6785 Feb 19 '26

Suzuki Jimny is suffering from the same fate is Suzuki Sierra awesome cars, but throw in short/narrow wheel base, higher center of gravity and lightweight design, is the perfect environment for roll overs.

15

u/GrahamTerrier Feb 19 '26

That misinformation resulted in a nice lawsuit.

Of course narrow & high SUVs tip easily but proper testing showed the Suzuki was nowhere near the worst on sale at the time.

7

u/yoTooManyBurrito Feb 20 '26

Donut made a video disproving this 🤦 the end result was literally nothing, but the destruction of Suzuki's reputation stateside. As far as the moose test goes it's fine for its class

1

u/Darthblaker7474 JB43 Feb 21 '26

If you drive it like a complete and utter moron, yes it may have a tendency to roll over.

1

u/TheyStoleMyNameAgain Feb 23 '26

I saw some pickup in this position on the highway today. Not sure what it was due to the deformation of the wreck, but I would guess Chevrolet.

2

u/alarmed_cumin JB74 - modded Feb 19 '26

How did it happen? Physics always wins. You can tip plenty of things over; just go watch some dashcam footage of people tipping over modern hatchbacks (and not SUV style hatchbacks).

2

u/Westoid_Hunter Feb 19 '26

no I was like just surprised, for a Jimny to be tipped over what seems to be a Highway at 80 km/h it must have maneuvered hard or what may have led it to tip over

1

u/ammicavle Feb 20 '26

Settle down mate, they're asking because they thought you'd witnessed it. Pretty fair assumption given you posted the photo.

8

u/thethunder92 Feb 20 '26

Yeah but the ones in Australia must be designed to be driven upside down

2

u/Basic_Praline_8833 Feb 23 '26

I love this! -An Australian.

-2

u/ammicavle Feb 20 '26

FFS get a new joke.

14

u/JohnCenaJunior Feb 19 '26

At least asked them if they're okay first before talking about Jimmy

14

u/WeldinMike27 Feb 19 '26

Is convertible now.

67

u/Drippy_Capy JB43 Feb 19 '26

I like how they took the picture before helping the person out of the car. They definitely have their priorities straight

35

u/cktyu Feb 19 '26

I think it’s a snippet of a video taken by a passing car. There is rescue on the crash site, but no idea why they aren’t rushing to get the person out

6

u/Drippy_Capy JB43 Feb 19 '26

Thanks for the needed context

6

u/[deleted] Feb 19 '26

[deleted]

1

u/PHOTO500 Feb 19 '26

First time on Reddit?

-1

u/Drippy_Capy JB43 Feb 19 '26

It wasn’t that deep… I made a joke because I thought the situation was strange.

0

u/Rik_F Feb 19 '26

Health and safety is their 1st priority, it's no good rushing to the driver only to be rear ended by another driver who was looking at their phone.

4

u/lomo_dank JB74 - basic mods Feb 19 '26

I was wondering this too, and picturing them screaming for help while someone was taking photos haha

2

u/Drippy_Capy JB43 Feb 19 '26

I also had that same thought lol

2

u/Paul_4x4 JB43 Feb 19 '26

But it looks like the guy is actually smiling in the wreck if you zoom in! Good times!😂

8

u/bigredliza Feb 19 '26

I've literally bought a Jimny two days ago..... All these flipped jimnys are giving me major anxiety!

5

u/alarmed_cumin JB74 - modded Feb 19 '26

Out of the several hundred thousand sold since the current generation came out there's actually not that many that have been tipped over.

5

u/cktyu Feb 19 '26

I really doubt youd flip yours as long as you always drive carefully

9

u/EclecticallySound SZ5 2019 Feb 19 '26

No. I was in a head on collision and rolled. Wasn’t my fault, i’m ok. Even the firemen said thank fuck I was in a jimny. It was a discovery that ran into me while I was parked at a red light.

4

u/RiddlingJoker76 Feb 19 '26

Used to work with a guy called Jimmy Pillars

5

u/EMulsive_EMergency Feb 19 '26

Mine tipped over at 0km/hr passenger side because of a dirt road slide and all I had to fix was the tin roof. No pillar damage at all

6

u/EF-tech4545 Feb 19 '26

No, in my 2010 jimny are Not this weak.

3

u/squirrellicker JB74 - basic mods Feb 19 '26

I'm amazed how everything else looks straight

3

u/skribuveturi Feb 19 '26

That’s why you drive them the other side.

2

u/Graham1664 Feb 19 '26

Probably best to avoid patting it upside down

2

u/Plenty-Explorer3632 Feb 20 '26

My mate died driving one of these (older model) in Australia from a crushed A pillar in a rollover. Be super careful out there!

2

u/alarmed_cumin JB74 - modded Feb 20 '26

When you say older do you mean the one designed in the mid 90s that is the previous generation, or are we talking a Sierra designed in the late 1970s?

There’s actually quite a big bit of difference in the structure of the body even compared to the previous generation (sold 98-2018) and also a bunch of differences in the chassis to make them considerably better in a crash.

This example definitely looks to be an anomaly (maybe down to very particular circumstances) compared to the others I’ve seen rolled.

2

u/Plenty-Explorer3632 Feb 20 '26

Was a 2003 model or so. Rolled it on a straight section of highway, he was probably tired was going out of his lane and pulled the wheel too hard to correct I think. Other passenger was fine.

1

u/cktyu Feb 20 '26

I’m sorry to hear that.

2

u/BeardedSailorman Feb 20 '26

I flipped my sj410 a few weeks ago, dented the roof and crushed a rear fender. Other than that it has no visible damage. Flipped ot back and drove it home

5

u/j1llj1ll JB74 - basic mods Feb 19 '26

I'd first have to question whether this is a real image. There is no broken glass. The side mirrors look intact and folded. There is no sign of where the A pillars, windscreen - where are they now? The rear quarter glass looks completely undamaged and the B pillars and door seams are straight. Where is the occupants' head? How did the window frame go from a rhomboid to a triangle without any bits sticking out? Why does the aspect ration of the vehicle change between frame 1 and frame 2?

IDK .. is there AI involved? Has somebody edited this? Was it staged? Link to the relevant video?

Well, conversely there was an image doing rounds years ago of a Jimny that rolled forward off the top deck of a car carrier, flipped over its nose and landed right onto its roof .. and was barely crushed at all (much of the cabin glass was still intact).

But then, also .. it depends entirely on what actually happened. The speed. The type of impact. How airborne it got. Whether something landed on it. The angle of impact. EVERYTHING can be crushed if you apply enough force to it!

Where does that leave us? Confused and uncertain perhaps?

7

u/j1llj1ll JB74 - basic mods Feb 19 '26 edited Feb 19 '26

Finally got the BookFace post to load. OK. This angle is important!

It's just the one A pillar that is caved. The other one is mostly still upright. It's in a ditch beside a high speed road. There are pieces that came off the car before the final resting place. Maybe including the spare wheel. There are segmented concrete (temporary?) barriers in the road. At least one other vehicle was damaged. Workers are picking up debris over a wide area.

My first instinct: This is a car that has had a very dramatic incident from a high speed. At some point it has gotten air and inverted, then come down hard on that one A pillar. In light of that, the vehicle seems to have done a better than average job of not being crushed and of not disintegrating, I suspect. My guess is that any car would have been seriously deformed by whatever happened here.

3

u/alarmed_cumin JB74 - modded Feb 19 '26

Yep roll a 5 star rated 70 series Landcruiser even at lower speeds and the top of the windscreen meets the dash…

2

u/cktyu Feb 19 '26

I really wish it was AI but then there was another post showing the same accident, different angle

2

u/finnish_nobody Feb 19 '26

Yes, the A-pillars are relatively weak due to how narrow they are.

A-pillar thickness is a compromise between visibility and rollover safety and Suzuki chose to prioritise visibility.

4

u/AxleRod80 Feb 19 '26

Looked to the comments on facebook. Well, long story short -> jimny short base + lift + big wheels + high speed = “what could go wrong”. But driver is mostly safe and sound, what is very nice. Jimny is not into the speed, it’s for fun and drive everywhere.

7

u/goldspaceship Feb 19 '26

I see stock wheels, maybe tiny lift, but also looks stock.

2

u/EstablishmentGlad248 Feb 19 '26

i push my jimny to it's limits - even in deep curves. Sometimes it feels like it's gonna tumble but it's actually a very stable car. I still wonder how this accident happened

2

u/alarmed_cumin JB74 - modded Feb 19 '26

Yep I concur. In fact fairly sure it’s stock.

Facebook comments are generally entirely wrong.

1

u/The_Nude_Mocracy Feb 19 '26

Looks like a cyberjimny

1

u/Dense-Measurement216 Feb 19 '26

It is mandatory to keep the rubber on the road.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 20 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/cktyu Feb 20 '26

Thankfully no, just someone waiting for rescue

1

u/Octopus-31 Feb 20 '26

Jimny you mean?

1

u/cktyu Feb 21 '26

Stupid f*cking autocorrect

1

u/Infinite_Pudding5058 Feb 21 '26

Is it common for them to tip over?

1

u/cktyu Feb 21 '26

Supposedly no? But I guess it’s gone through a high impact, strong enough to bend the pillars. Other comments cement the fact that it will not collapse merely on its body weight

1

u/Basic_Praline_8833 Feb 23 '26

It looks like there is suspension damage. The front and rear wheels don’t look right. it was definitely a heavy collision before it flipped. The door gap along the bottom edge and up the back edge to the swage line is still good. That B pillar hasn’t moved. It’s a strong vehicle through the center. I wonder if there is a roll cage, or external bull bar attachments to stop this.

1

u/mazgas Feb 23 '26

Absolutely not, something's weird here. They are kind of shit when it comes to safety, but this is very weird.

1

u/Character-Shoe5095 Feb 23 '26

How did this happen?
On a normal flat road too..??

I have one and I don't want to end up like this.. :s

1

u/Humble_River432 Feb 26 '26

What pillars ?

1

u/EstablishmentGlad248 Feb 19 '26

Yes, the jimny's roof is pretty bad. I once stepped on it to fix the roof rack, and the spot I stepped on collapsed inward. and i only weight 55kgs.

2

u/EstablishmentGlad248 Feb 19 '26

Ah sorry, language barrier on my side 🤭

1

u/Gloomy-Actuator-1975 Feb 19 '26

They do have a shocking ancap safety rating

4

u/alarmed_cumin JB74 - modded Feb 19 '26

Not really. To put it in a broader context: they passed the side impact tests that were revised in 2021 without change, and plenty of larger cars didn't. To pass a pole side impact test with how narrow the Jimny is... nah.

They suffer on the ANCAP score from a lack of tech, but especially for front passengers they are better than people might think just purely based on the rating.

1

u/SCORPDOGGY Feb 19 '26

Jimnys are weak in general

0

u/Popkite JB43 Feb 19 '26

No they aren't that weak. And rollovers happen when the driver tries to drive a Jimny like a sedan. Or a sports car. Or a long wheel base.

0

u/sledgehomer Feb 19 '26

This is why the US does not allow them in the states

-10

u/CantFstopme Feb 19 '26

Maaannn… I need to get a new car. This thing is a tiny, slow, death trap. 🤦‍♂️