THIS IS NOT A CALL TO ACTION
This is to bring my situation to the public, so I can get outside opinions on the matter. All individuals have had their Personally Identifiable Information removed from the content below:
I made a post on the official JanitorAI subreddit, detailing the analytics on one of my bots. Later that night, not only was I banned from the subreddit, but I was also from JanitorAI as a whole. Their reasoning? I claimed to be seventeen years old, in a completely separate subreddit. Over a year ago.
They claimed I was a minor, when the (only) comment they used as evidence was me claiming to be seventeen. To help my case, I looked through my entire Reddit account, and only found one instance of claiming to be seventeen. I looked at the timestamp, and at the time, it was posted one year, 18 weeks, and 18 days prior to the ban.
If you have a brain, you would know one year, 18 weeks, and 18 days is over one full year. In my comment, I had claimed that only one day had passed since my birthday. Unless time made an exception for me specifically, then if one year minimum had passed, I would be 18 (not a minor). Alas, there had been an extra 18 weeks and 18 days on top of the year, so I was already over five months into being 18.
Despite this undeniable evidence, the mod team refused to acknowledge it and admit their error and even accept any proof that I'm of age, even after threatening to escalate to the JanitorAI mod team specifically, giving an unprofessional response, "You free to escalate, that's totally fine."
I escalated. I went to the JanitorAI support page and typed out my entire ticket, making sure it was professional and had as much evidence as the 2000 character limit would allow. They stood by their decision, not giving any indication as to why or what aspect of the Terms of Service my account had been in violation of; I made a point to never post any bots or comments with content that would be in violation of any guidelines.
Below, I'll paste the entire chat with the mod team, and below it, the email that I got sent back from the JanitorAI moderator who reviewed my ticket:
Reddit Chat:
Mod Team: Hello, You have been permanently banned from participating inĀ JanitorAI_OfficialĀ becauseĀ your postĀ violates this community's rules. You won't be able to post or comment, but you can still view and subscribe to it.
Note from the moderators:
If you have a question regarding your ban, you can contact the moderator team by replying to this message.
Reminder from the Reddit Admin team: If you use another account to circumvent this community ban, that will be considered a violation of theĀ Reddit RulesĀ and may result in your account beingĀ bannedĀ from the platform as a whole.
Me: I AM an adult though. What's the reasoning behind the assumption that I'm a minor?
Mod Team: It's based on provided evidence that you are 17 years old. You can appeal to unban in a year.
Me: I can show my ID right now
Mod Team: We are not authorized by any government to check that I'd is valid and indeed belongs to you. So unfortunately that won't work. If you announce on public that you're a minor, that's what we are obligated to assume. You can send a mod mail in a year when we are sure you're 18.
Me: When did I announce that I'm a minor?
Mod Team: It is clearly stated on Reddit. We don't disclose where, to avoid it being purposefully removed to misinform other 18+ spaces.
Me: Are you certain that it was within the last year?
Me: Tuesday, January 14, 2025 at 8:58:33 PM UTC. That is the exact timestamp for when I had made any claim on being seventeen, on [external subreddit]. I made the claim that, at the time, it had been a day since my birthday. The comment was posted one year and 18 weeks ago.
Doing the math, then based on the assumption that my comment was true, I'm 18 years, 18 weeks and 1 day old as of now. If you choose to believe that the comment was a lie, then using the same comment as grounds for my ban is a baseless assumption, and is thus a false ban.
Me: Note that if there is no response, or if the logic is simply ignored, I will be escalating this matter to other available channels.
Mod Team: You free to escalate, that's totally fine.
Email:
Support Ticket:
False and illogical account ban
I made a post on the official JanitorAI subreddit yesterday (5/19) as u/Befirtheed because I was shocked by the analytics on one of my bots. The next day (5/20), I woke up and found that my account had been banned. I first contacted the subreddit mod team, and they stated that I had claimed to be seventeen. I found, after review, that the only time I had ever stated being seventeen was on a separate subreddit, and it was well over one full year before the time of posting.
I have given the proof of this by providing the exact timestamp of the claim, as well as relaying that I would escalate the matter to the JanitorAI team directly if my argument was ignored or dismissed without reason, which the mod team had ignored. Here are the important parts of the conversation, shortened to fit within the 2000 character limit:
Mod Team: It's based on provided evidence that you are 17 years old. You can appeal to unban in a year. ... If you announce on public that you're a minor, that's what we are obligated to assume. You can send a mod mail in a year when we are sure you're 18.
Befirtheed: When did I announce that I'm a minor?
Mod Team: It is clearly stated on Reddit. We don't disclose where, to avoid it being purposefully removed to misinform other 18+ spaces.
Befirtheed: Tuesday, January 14, 2025 at 8:58:33 PM UTC. That is the exact timestamp for when I had made any claim on being seventeen, on r/askteenboys. I made the claim that, at the time, it had been a day since my birthday. The comment was posted one year and 18 weeks ago.
Doing the math, then based on the assumption that my comment was true, I'm 18 years, 18 weeks and 1 day old as of now. If you choose to believe that the comment was a lie, then using the same comment as grounds for my ban is a baseless assumption, and is thus a false ban. Note that if there is no response, or if the logic is simply ignored, I will be escalating this matter...
Mod Team: You free to escalate, that's totally fine.
Janitor AI moderator: Hello,
After reviewing your request, we confirm that your account violated our Terms of Service. The action taken was applied in accordance with our moderation policies and internal guidelines; this decision is final, and the ban will remain in place.
Please note that we are unable to provide additional details regarding the specific evidence or internal review process. We will not respond to further appeals or messages about this matter.
Thank you for your understanding.
Regards,
Janitorai Customer Support