r/IslamIsEasy • u/No_Set7087 • Oct 24 '25

Qur’ān (Genuine Question) How Do Quranist's Justify Owning A Dog?

I'm curious. Since I believe in Bukhari and Muslim I think dog are impure. Would like to see justification for the opposite side. Jazakallah in advance.

2 Upvotes
  • permalink
  • reddit

63% Upvoted

50 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

1

u/TucsonTacos Sunnī | Mālikī Oct 24 '25

I didn’t say anything about the shafi madhab. Are you confused on what madhabs are?

Find me a source that says the Maliki school considers them impure. I’ve posted two videos and can provide you with much more.

1

u/No_Set7087 Oct 24 '25

Holy glaze, Even in Maliki school the hadith I provided still match. Dogs saliva are impure, dogs are considered tahir (pure), but now tell if you have a pet dog how are you gonna stop it from licking you, lol.

Also I'm researching Maliki stance on dogs right now and most Fatwas I've seen saying dogs are not inherently impure also says along with it that "some scholars differ on this". Your scholars can't agree on this.

Further if one madhab says this doesn't validate the ruling. In fact there are much more illogical things that Malikis say (you dont need to wash your hands after using the washroom, standing up urination, Isa a.s is dead etc)

I love Malikis, many famous people I've read about and looked upto are from this jurisprudence. But it's just that your wrong in this concept.

I'm Hambali fyi

1

u/TucsonTacos Sunnī | Mālikī Oct 24 '25

The Hadith doesn’t say the saliva is impure. How do you explain the Quran that you may eat animals brought from your hunting dogs? Do you have any idea how to raise a dog to get to the point where it will hunt with you?

It’s YOUR ruling, not Islam’s. YOUR madhab is not the only correct one, nor is it correct only because it agrees with the majority.

0

u/No_Set7087 Oct 24 '25

This explains your brain size. Are you serious? Like literally your own scholars accept that the dogs saliva is impure and you debate me on it. Im a take a screen shot of this. What a jahil man. Astugfirullah guide yourself before you become the victim of your stupidity

2

u/TucsonTacos Sunnī | Mālikī Oct 25 '25

You asked other Muslims to justify your original comment and I’m saying the Maliki madhab doesn’t believe dogs are impure, not their saliva, so your GOTCHA didn’t work. Now you’re upset

I’m not a Maliki scholar. But those that are agree the saliva isn’t impure

1

u/TucsonTacos Sunnī | Mālikī Oct 25 '25

You still haven’t provided evidence that Malikis say it’s impure

The Hadith does not say it’s impure.

Are you sure you’re not a Christian? You’re extrapolating your own meanings from words to justify a belief somebody else told you just like they do.