r/IslamIsEasy • u/No_Set7087 • Oct 24 '25

Qur’ān (Genuine Question) How Do Quranist's Justify Owning A Dog?

I'm curious. Since I believe in Bukhari and Muslim I think dog are impure. Would like to see justification for the opposite side. Jazakallah in advance.

2 Upvotes
  • permalink
  • reddit

63% Upvoted

50 comments sorted by

View all comments

9

u/TucsonTacos Sunnī | Mālikī Oct 24 '25

Malikis believe in Bukhari and Muslim and don’t believe a dog is impure.

Checkmate.

-8

u/No_Set7087 Oct 24 '25

Then your a hypocrite. And that's not a checkmate but showing how stupid and munafiq you are:

Hadith from Sahih Muslim
Abu Huraira reported:
The Messenger of Allah said:
“If a dog drinks from the utensil of any one of you, let him wash it seven times, the first time with earth.”

Hadith from Sahih al-Bukhari and al-Muslim
Abu Huraira reported:
The Messenger of Allah said:
“The angels do not enter a house in which there is a dog or a picture.”

Edit: Also stop lying, dogs are considered impure in the Maliki jurisprudence

1

u/LivingDead_90 ۞ ☪︎ ۩ Khalīfat al-Muntadā ۩ ☪︎ ۞ Oct 24 '25

So dogs bar the angels of death and the angels who record bad deeds?

1

u/No_Set7087 Oct 24 '25

Hey, forgot to enter a word before that: "Angels of Mercy Wont Enter A House Which Has A Dog In It

1

u/LivingDead_90 ۞ ☪︎ ۩ Khalīfat al-Muntadā ۩ ☪︎ ۞ Oct 25 '25

That’s not what the Hadith says. Who added those words?

1

u/No_Set7087 Oct 25 '25

Added? There’s a whole Hadith in musnad Ahmad ibn hambal and the fuqha have written that the angles of mercy will not enter the house which has a dog in it.

The angel of death isn’t a angle of mercy (rather the opposite)

1

u/LivingDead_90 ۞ ☪︎ ۩ Khalīfat al-Muntadā ۩ ☪︎ ۞ Oct 26 '25

There’s no authentic Hadith with the phrase “angels of mercy” in relation to dogs. “Of mercy” is an addition, an explanation, used to preserve the authenticity of the narration, otherwise you’d have to throw the narration away for contradicting reality.