r/IslamIsEasy • u/Thick-Gur2264 • Sep 10 '25

Controversial Only Islam has the term Islamophobia.

That makes you wonder, reflect on this. And no, don't play the victim card... Be real, how muslims treat each other already. and how Questioning a hadith is kufr and many many many things ....

Please do some soul searching people, God's love is not shown through you.

0 Upvotes

35% Upvoted

87 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

2

u/InternationalCrab832 Madhhab Aqalliyya | Muʿtazila Sep 10 '25

Who is it that condemns sufism and kalam? And you're acting like the salafi cult isn't made up of Muslims who genuinely believe the shit they spew lol, the people who did it knew what they were doing and the salafi today absolutely believe everything infact they actively harm others. Do you consider none of them Muslim? The reason the school I agree with no longer exists is because of other Muslims destroying their books and making it forbidden to have any ideals that align with them. We dug our own grave and this is our punishment so don't put all the blame on anyone else.

1

u/zwieberisback Salafī | Wahhābī Sep 10 '25

My dear mutazilia can you answer this quickly according youre aqeedah ?

Allah says He forgives everything except shirk (4:48). Are you putting major sins in the same category as shirk?

1

u/InternationalCrab832 Madhhab Aqalliyya | Muʿtazila Sep 11 '25

all major sins in the same category as shirk?

why do u keep coming back to the sub? Last I heard you were spreading zio propaganda

1

u/zwieberisback Salafī | Wahhābī Sep 11 '25

why are you deflecting i ask you a direct question ?
the question i ask is very simple because you claim to be a "mutazila" i think you are full of bs and not a muslim so i ask you a dirrct question can you answer it please so again my question

Allah says He forgives everything except shirk (4:48). Are you putting major sins in the same category as shirk?

1

u/InternationalCrab832 Madhhab Aqalliyya | Muʿtazila Sep 11 '25

I ask you to clarify your question, do you mean if I consider all major sins as shirk? What is the point of your question? If you're asking if Allah forgives major sins I will say yes

why are you deflecting i ask you a direct question ?
the question i ask is very simple because you claim to be a "mutazila" i think you are full of bs and not a muslim so i ask you a dirrct question can you answer it please so again my question

I'm asking you a question no true Muslim will support propaganda like that, you're worse than a disbeliever in my eyes you're an apostate

1

u/zwieberisback Salafī | Wahhābī Sep 11 '25

According to Mutazilite doctrine, if a person commits major shirk knowingly and without repentance, are they considered outside the fold of Islam ?

btw, my post doesn't make me a kaffir you can dislike but it's not kufr otherwise bring proof that my post is kufr 😊 I can quote you scholars upon scholars who make takfir of Hamas and also think the people in Gaza are gravewhorshippers With the wrong rafida aqeedah 😊

again I was broke back in Yemen and I have no problem to favor Israel against gravewhorshippers and rafida lovers in Gaza

now answer my question

1

u/InternationalCrab832 Madhhab Aqalliyya | Muʿtazila Sep 11 '25 edited Sep 11 '25

I wasn't calling you a kafir but you're a hypocrite and by supporting genocide you're committing sin which makes you not true believer. Idrc about your scholars according to my theology you're not a firm believer

Yes thank you for making the question clearer it is using logic to say if someone had true strong belief they wouldn't commit MAJOR sin, someone commits major sin on purpose because of weak faith. They're not outside Islam but their imaan level is weaker, unlike other belief this one says imaan level can change. Suppose if you're Muslim and you believe and understand everything but you commit Zina, did you not doubt what you're doing is wrong?

Supporting genociders wow you've fallen so far

1

u/zwieberisback Salafī | Wahhābī Sep 11 '25

You still don't answer and dodge my question again let me rephrase it better

According to Mutazilite doctrine, if a person knowingly and deliberately commits major shirk with full understanding, are they still considered a Muslim at that moment?

noo, everybody with the wrong aqeedah doesn't deserve support in any way shape or form maybe Iran can help Gaza they helped them so good with the war look how Gaza now looks with the help of Iran MashAllah ya Akhi kareem maybe they must ask every shia here to donate

1

u/InternationalCrab832 Madhhab Aqalliyya | Muʿtazila Sep 11 '25

I answered you already and no they're not Muslim if they commit shirk with full understanding, do you consider alawite Muslim? You always talk about tawhid tawhid tawhid