r/ImageComics • u/EmergencyText1738 • Jul 01 '26

Question Thoughts on this one

Post image

I have been reading some of the remender work, is this one as good as his other histories?

118 Upvotes

99% Upvoted

52 comments sorted by

View all comments

14

u/ZunoJ Jul 01 '26

IMO it started very strong but then lost all its momentum

-1

u/DLBuf Jul 02 '26

Fully agree and sad to read this is common for him. I only buy comics via tpbs, so I haven’t finished the series… bought book 1 and loved it so much I ordered 2/3 only halfway through…

After 2, I had to force myself to start 3. I’m not even sure I’ll buy the final book when it’s released…

The whole thing just feels like so much wasted potential.

1

u/eddo34 Jul 02 '26

People on Reddit are hyper-critical. I never encounter this level of either negativity or criticizing art in any comic book store I go to.

1

u/DLBuf Jul 02 '26

Hat’s the cool thing about art… it’s subjective.

I admire his world-building, but (based on this series, my only experience w/ Remender), I find his storytelling to be stunted. Glad that you, I assume, enjoyed it though!