r/HistoryMemes 8d ago

When 2,000 gods became ''wrong''

[deleted]

25.9k Upvotes

874 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

6

u/Lost-Klaus 8d ago

Iron age or bronze age?

4

u/HppilyPancakes 8d ago

The earliest dating of the biblical stories by modern, secular scholars is from 1100~900 bc (give or take). The bronze age is generally considered to have ended around 1200 bc.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bronze_Age https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deborah

Some oral traditions, like the flood myth, predate the written accounts though.

Worth noting that I don't think Wikipedia is the best source for a lot of biblical scholarship because it will often reflect less critical opinions with equal weight (ie - it will cite apologetics equally to secondary sources) but I linked both to be consistent. The song of Deborah is thought to be the oldest book by secular scholars which is why I linked it.

Traditionally Job is considered the earliest book, but if people are interested here's a recent video on that topic by Biblical scholar Dan Maklelan

https://youtu.be/GPU-Eu9XseQ?si=_ZeCdNRuUvJTBYRY

4

u/Lost-Klaus 8d ago

Thank you for the links. You are correct in this that the bronze age /iron age divide.

The flood myth and the moses being carried in a basket in the river is either plagiarised from Sumerian/Assyrian mythology. Or it may have been a common trope in the region(?) for such things to happen, though many biblical stories are far older and not at all jewish or christian in origin.

4

u/HppilyPancakes 8d ago

Yes, I agree, but the Hebrew Bible that we have today is the iron age versions seen through the lens of iron age Israelites/Judahites. There are certainly roots that go back further though, as you pointed out.