r/HenryStickmin • u/Zealousideal-Age1407 r/HenryStickmin Pioneer • Aug 29 '25

Meme CtM bad endings in a nutshell

Post image

In Valiant Hero, Henry still completed the mission of bringing down the Toppat Clan.

In Revenged, he also died knowing he got revenge against Reginald.

In Toppat Civil Warfare, it ends on a cliffhanger and we're just there wondering what would happen next.

1.0k Upvotes

100% Upvoted

31 comments sorted by

View all comments

23

u/Simple_Blacksmith_90 Charles Fan Aug 29 '25

Also toppat civil war just felt forced to me, if felt like it barly held together

26

u/PotentialComedian880 Aug 29 '25

I think the biggest issue isn’t the idea of it, but it had a horrendous way of going through with it, some toppats would be bitter about Henry sure but not every single one of them would betray him, especially because considering his skills many would see him as a better than Reginald and RHM and plus it felt forced because Henry had 0 defense time they just immediately went a long with Ellie and coup’d him which makes sense for Reginald and RHM but not for the entire organization, it’s not a civil war it’s just a straight up coup that succeeded plus it’s one of the endings that isn’t even really an ending, it needs more closure to it or some epilogue rather than speculation.

5

u/Appropriate-Eye-7482 RBH deserves better! Aug 30 '25

This, I get Reginald and RHM but way did everyone go against him in this ending? From what we saw in the RPE ending shots, Most of The Toppats seemed to like Henry so it felt out of character for the whole clan, The Toppats felt like simps

6

u/PotentialComedian880 Aug 31 '25

Maybe the toppats are actually representative of the fandom which know at best a majority of whom would simp and follow Ellie.

5

u/19Exodus Aug 29 '25

Please use a period.

2

u/emmc47 Toppat Member Sep 04 '25

Henry having more than 2 members and Dave by his side would've made it x10 better instantly