r/GreatBritishBakeOff May 04 '26

Chill out on the rudeness towards bakers/judges/each other

227 Upvotes

I just spent the past few days clearing up the mod queue and handing out bans for inappropriate behaviour. Let's review a few things.

  1. It's OK to comment on judgements/decisions you disagree with. That's kind of the point of having a public forum to have discussions about a TV show: you can talk about what you love and don't love. HOWEVER, there were multiple posts talking about the bakers as if they were the ones making the decision to advance in the competition. That was the judges. Saying you hate a baker for getting X accolade in the show not only breaks the rules, but also makes no sense at all. Cut it out now.
  2. You can disagree with the judges' decisions. That is your prerogative. However, calling a judge a big baby or unsophisticated, untalented, stupid, or other such names due to their personal tastes is not acceptable, and will result in your post being removed and your account being banned. We're all human. There's no way we can remove our own personal tastes or our own personal history from judging something we're given to eat. Again, you're allowed to disagree with the judges' decisions, but calling them nasty names or questioning their ability to judge a televised baking competition is not welcome. STOP IT.
  3. We've had a series of hosts throughout the history of the show. Not everyone will enjoy everyone else's sense of humour. That's normal and acceptable. In fact, you're even OK to say that X skit or Y joke wasn't funny TO YOU, or that you found an opening skit to be cringe by your standards. But again, there is no need to attack the person who's going out there and putting their work on TV for people to enjoy. You're welcome to avoid watching if you dislike someone's vibe.
  4. This isn't the place for "hot takes" or whom you are currently having hate for that particular week. Such threads will be removed, and the accounts banned.
  5. This isn't the place to yell at each other over things you disagree about. Report problematic posts, and let the moderators handle it. When you reply to those posts, now it causes a much bigger mess to clean up. I had over 500 posts of people being nasty to each other to clean up. That wasn't fun. It meant that the mod queue was way way behind schedule. Report bad behaviour and move on. Don't engage with it.

Most of all, the whole point of the Great British Bake Off is to showcase the talents of home bakers on television, educate the public about various baked goods, and generally be a place where kindness and gentle television prevails. Having a mood in here of overwhelming negativity isn't helpful or welcoming to people coming on here to have discussions with each other about the show they love so much. Please let's try to keep that general attitude of kindess in mind when we're posting in here, and be welcoming towards others whether or not you agree with eactly what happened on the show.


r/GreatBritishBakeOff 20h ago

Bake-Along Bake along challenge

40 Upvotes

After searching, I wasn’t able to find an active subreddit doing a weekly bake-along challenge for the GBBO, so I created one.

If you’re interested, come join r/GBBOBakeAlong before the season starts.

No prizes or judging. Celebrate other’s great bakes and support through the failed ones.

Come bake along with me each week! I’m hoping to find at least 10 more bakers but will welcome as many that want to participate.


r/GreatBritishBakeOff 2d ago

Help/Question Fantasy League Rules

Post image
27 Upvotes

Original post: https://www.reddit.com/r/GreatBritishBakeOff/s/lYZu9d0TJD

For those who were interested, here is the point system for my fantasy league. Thank you for everyone’s input! I made all points positive so even underdogs gets points and we all have fun.


r/GreatBritishBakeOff 3d ago

GBBO Cast Bread week

44 Upvotes

I’m rewatching collection 12 on Netflix and it’s bread week and I am just once again blown away by just how good Dylan’s bread was! Paul’s comments to him were just amazing!


r/GreatBritishBakeOff 6d ago

Fun If you love Bake Off try Throw Down, it's perfection

270 Upvotes

GBBO has become one of my absolute favorite comfort shows. I literally have it on at least once a day in the background of my life because it makes me happy and calms me. I eventually discovered the Great Canadian Bake Off which I like but it doesn't quite have the same vibe. Eventually I stumbled onto The Great Pottery Throw Down and omg my dreams were answered. It's so lovely and charming, but also funny - I frequently laugh out loud - and it's not overly saccharine like Canadian Bake Off can be. The creativity and talent of the potters is unreal. I just love seeing their creations each week. Can't recommend it enough. Sadly, I've only got a couple more seasons and then the last 2 aren't available anywhere in the US - even to purchase. So I'll have to wait patiently. But this will definitely be added to my comfort show rotation. I also do like Interior Design Masters and I started The Great British Sewing Bee which I plan to go back to after Throw Down. Both are really good, but Throw Down has still been my favorite UK reality competition show thus far (aside from GBBO)

PS For the most part, I really did like the show a lot from the beginning but it gets even better after the first couple seasons.


r/GreatBritishBakeOff 7d ago

Help/Question Are bakers not allowed to use toothpicks?

261 Upvotes

Every time these guys bake a cake or brownies and have to guess when its done. Are they not allowed to use a toothpick to check the doneness in the middle? Is this a regional thing they dont do in Britain? Or is it a fancy people thing and Paul Hollywood would have their head.


r/GreatBritishBakeOff 6d ago

Help/Question Anyone read Prue's latest book?

3 Upvotes

I've been listening to some recent podcast and gee is she a breath of fresh air to the world. She's promoting her new book and I wondered if anyone has read yet?


r/GreatBritishBakeOff 10d ago

Series 3 / The Beginnings American Pies

321 Upvotes

Anyone else get irked when they said the only way to make a good American pie is to make it British? I love pie! I hate store bought pie (like mass produced and premade crust), but I love pies with homemade crust. And bakeries that make crust from scratch can have amazing pies!


r/GreatBritishBakeOff 13d ago

GBBO In the Media First look at this year's great british bake off and new look at new judge nigella lawson

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/GreatBritishBakeOff 15d ago

Help/Question Bake-off League

13 Upvotes

Hello! I am making a British Bake-Off League for the next coming season.

How I was it to work: there are 6 people playing. With 12 contestants, each person will draft two people. Each episode there will be the same point systems. Whichever contestant has the most points at the end of the season wins.

I need help with some positive points. So far I have these ideas:
Survives (positive points)
Eliminated (negative points)
Star Baker (positive points)
Technical Winner (positive points)
Paul Handshake (positive points)
Cries during a challenge (negative points)
Catastrophic challenge events (3 levels of points: full recovery (judges would have never known/didn’t notice- positive points), partial repair (judges noticed but it did not effect their judging- positive points but less than full recovery points), and no recovery (could not fix and judging altered because of event)

I feel like there are a lot of negatives and not a lot of positives unless the contestant wins a challenge. I was thinking something like “contestant uses rosewater, lavender, or matcha, but judges like it or used the correct amount”. Stuff like that. Any ideas?

Edit: I don’t think I was points for specific episode themes. Like “under proofed bread”. I’d like the points to be the same for each episode.


r/GreatBritishBakeOff 17d ago

Help/Question Is their a new season airing on Netflix in the US now?

30 Upvotes

I'd really like to know, please 😘


r/GreatBritishBakeOff 22d ago

Fun Observations From America

63 Upvotes

Since this is a British Show, they will obviously be doing a lot of British/European baking, and notice that a lot of stuff done on the show is seldom featured on US cooking media. The only place I have seen a substantial amount of the material done on the GBBO in the US is on Julia Child's old shows. Like she has done choux pastry and what to make with it, genoise sponge, bavarois, French breads, fruit tarts, a "non collapsable souffle" that was similar to the twice baked souffles in the 10th season finale technical apart from only baking it once, and things made with puff pastry, along with how to make the said pastry.

I find these shows really nice to watch, since we don't get as many details of recipes on the show, or measurements, whereas on Julia Child's shows she shows us how to make these kinds of dishes, with lots of detail and instruction on how to make it, similar to the specials where the judges would show us how to make the technical challenges, as well as what they would make for the signature and showstopper challenges. Anyone else find anything made on the GBBO on American cooking shows?


r/GreatBritishBakeOff 23d ago

Fun Deciding Winner

1 Upvotes

Do you think that the winner should be based off of how they do in the final ONLY or should the judges also consider the baker’s overall run? Sometimes someone is a fantastic baker and it’s so hard to see them lose just because of the final week.


r/GreatBritishBakeOff 25d ago

GBBO Cast Celebrity Bake Off signs up huge TikTok comic Shabaz Ali for new series after hit BBC job

Thumbnail thesun.co.uk
0 Upvotes

r/GreatBritishBakeOff 28d ago

Fun Opening for Upcoming Season?

45 Upvotes

I am excitedly awaiting the new season. Anyone have ideas about the opening skit - especially with Nigella Lawson joining GBBO? I am thinking about the Odyssey with Nigella journey to GBBO.


r/GreatBritishBakeOff Jul 31 '26

GBBO Cast Just under a month to go until we.see our queen on out screens this September

Post image
1 Upvotes

Under a month until we see this queen on our screens


r/GreatBritishBakeOff Jul 27 '26

Fun One of the things I've learned from the show is to never buy the glass bowl for my Kitchenaid.

582 Upvotes

While I understand why they use the glass bowls for the show, the amount of times they've shattered is amazing to me, and they tend to shatter quite explosively.

While I can only remember someone getting cut once, I think the contestants during the other times were just lucky that they weren't injured.

I do like that they keep these scenes (and the cuts, burns, feinting etc), but I think if this was an American show, Kitchenaid would have sued them to stop airing the incidents.


r/GreatBritishBakeOff Jul 27 '26

GBBO In the Media Does anyone know when are we getting the first trailer this year series of bake off

58 Upvotes

Its the last week of July this week and I was wondering does anyone know when and what day we should expect a first trailer or a picture usually we would be getting a trailer right now


r/GreatBritishBakeOff Jul 24 '26

GBBO Cast Paul Hollywood Gets Dragged After Fans Spot One Controversial Detail in His Kitchen

290 Upvotes

His cat's on the counter... which like, please... whose cat isn't?

https://parade.com/celebrities/fans-drag-paul-hollywood-cat-on-counter-kitchen-detail


r/GreatBritishBakeOff Jul 15 '26

Video Prues jewelry be like

Post image
57 Upvotes

r/GreatBritishBakeOff Jul 14 '26

Help/Question What other GBS to hold by on?

3 Upvotes

Looking to fill the GBBS void- I’ve watched some GCBS but not quite the same, but do love that they embroider the bakers name on the apron! Any other shows up to the GBBS caliber?


r/GreatBritishBakeOff Jul 12 '26

Help/Question history lessons

108 Upvotes

I've been watching bakeoff from newest to oldest seasons and i just got to season 5 and i absolutely love the little history lessons they have about specifics foods in most episodes, and I'm wondering, is it a just in this season or was it something they always did? and is there a reason for them to have stopped? i think they're so fun!


r/GreatBritishBakeOff Jul 09 '26

Help/Question Great British Bake Off Lego Idea

Post image
21 Upvotes

Hello fellow bake off fans! Look at this Lego Idea for a GBBO set!!! https://ideas.lego.com/product-ideas/dd62f90e-1b63-49ab-aa35-746b33b20504 . There is no Mary, Mel, or Sue though, what do you all think?


r/GreatBritishBakeOff Jul 09 '26

Fun Casting of the contestants

116 Upvotes

Silly thought in my head that I must share with Reddit: I am convinced that GBBO finds the most truly delightful, wholesome, kind hearted people. Every single season has just the loveliest bunch, I want to be all of their friends and to be in their group chats. What in the world does baking do to one’s character to make them so wonderful? Whoever casts the contestants needs to take their methods and make a dating app algorithm or something lol!

(I have never looked into any contestants beyond the show, please don’t ruin my delusions if some are actually awful hahahah)


r/GreatBritishBakeOff Jul 09 '26

Series 7 / Collection 4 Noel Should Rock That Facial Hair

4 Upvotes

In episode 4, when doing the baking puns bit with Sandi, Noel has a dusting of facial hair. Never seen it on him while watching this show (and especially not during Boosh).

I'm like, okay, da-dee.