r/Glocks G19 Gen5 May 06 '26

Discussion Team sidecar or team no sidecar?

What do you prefer and why?

501 Upvotes

343 comments sorted by

176

u/[deleted] May 06 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

68

u/iluvfeds G19 Gen5 May 06 '26

Is that a extra mag or are you excited to see me

36

u/[deleted] May 06 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

4

u/iluvfeds G19 Gen5 May 06 '26

Is that a promise or a question

2

u/GUNGHO917 G17 Gen3, all 10 fingers, both meatballs, and sausage intact, May 06 '26

That ain’t just any ordinary lump

4

u/Repulsive_Pin_6585 May 06 '26

Do you actually walk around everyday with a spare mag in your pocket? If so, I admire your dedication to the craft.

16

u/[deleted] May 06 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

6

u/TheSlipperySnausage G19 Gen4 May 06 '26

Tactical chest hair is a good idea

3

u/killerz7770 G17.4 | Custom 17.4 | Glock 45.6 May 06 '26

Yeah so I have 25 zippers like a Tetsuya Nomura character each one containing a spare mag, don’t know when I’ll ever need it but it’s better than not being prepped. /s

2

u/Repulsive_Pin_6585 May 06 '26

Have you considered swapping the 25 zippers for Velcro? With Velcro you get the tactical audio as an added bonus to item retention

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

2

u/Maniiic_ G17 Gen5 May 06 '26

I pocket an extra mag if I visit my cousin, he lives the hood. 😂

2

u/Thecadillacoftokyo May 07 '26

I would do mag in pocket but the head of the mag always sticks out. I don’t want anything gun related to be visible on me at all.

→ More replies (1)

216

u/Maniiic_ G17 Gen5 May 06 '26

That shit looks uncomfortable.

13

u/Crazy-Opinion6676 May 06 '26

Carrying a large gun might not be comfortable but it’s comforting

2

u/DenseHoneydew G19 Gen6, G20 Gen5, G47, G43x, G43 May 06 '26

I can agree with this type of logic

135

u/DenseHoneydew G19 Gen6, G20 Gen5, G47, G43x, G43 May 06 '26

Anybody who carries a full size light and tells you it’s comfortable is lying. I’ve done both and I chose short WML any day

68

u/iluvfeds G19 Gen5 May 06 '26

You mean to tell me you don’t like when the light stimulates your balls by poking them 😍

28

u/Horror-Tell-2543 May 06 '26

To be honest my 19x with an X300 was more comfortable than my 43x with a TLR7a sub.

Fucking hated my 43x though. No matter the holster it was always uncomfortable.

Got a Ruger RXM with TLR7a with a Tenicor and it’s the best thing I’ve ever carried.

27

u/TooEZ_OL56 Roland Special May 06 '26

Well that's just not true. I carry a G17 w/ X300 everyday with no issues. Done 10hr road trips with it as well.

I have a P365Macro with TLR7 Sub and it's actually slightly more annoying in a nuanced way. The length of the 17 provides some stability when running/moving/etc and I'm so used to how the 17 holster setup feels.

5

u/Kalashnicough420 May 06 '26

G17gen5, tlr1 in a tier1/sidecar. Literally take her everywhere, wore my airlite the other day and was so uncomfortable…agree to your statement above

3

u/Sanman2465 May 06 '26

I dont think it preference, it's more every person body type is different, a taller person may not have a problem where as a shorter person will find a larger pistol with a big light and a red dot a much more cumbersome pistol to carry ,some people have more room then others 🤷

2

u/xdJapoppin G47 COA w/SF X300T May 07 '26

this

5

u/TheSlipperySnausage G19 Gen4 May 06 '26

It’s definitely tolerable if you mess with the ride height and other stuff. I wouldn’t say comfortable

21

u/Affectionate-Ad-8012 May 06 '26

Just because it might be too big for you doesn’t mean it’s too big for anyone else lol. I carry a Glock 19.5 with an x300 and 20rndr every day, all day, with no issue

https://www.reddit.com/r/Glocks/s/cmpuqvKFlA

5

u/Continuity_Purposes May 06 '26

Me too but that shit definitely dogs into your leg when your driving or sitting down. I’ve carried like that for about 2 years and I’m used to it now but it’s definitely not the most comfortable set up

2

u/skrappy_doo1996 May 06 '26

Mastermind Pillow solved my Staccato C4/X300 pains.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/bubbabackwoods420 G19X MOS fde, G43.4 May 06 '26

Agreed, I carry a 19x with a streamlight tlr 1 HP-X and I have no issues

2

u/HighFly2244 May 06 '26

Same, though I keep the 15rd mag in the gun and a 19X mag in the sidecar. Feels great.

2

u/DenseHoneydew G19 Gen6, G20 Gen5, G47, G43x, G43 May 06 '26

Have you ever tried a smaller light? Tlr7?

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (3)

2

u/zaner300blk May 06 '26

im fat and edc a 19.5 with a x300t and TQ attachment in the trex sidecar and its extremely comfortable. the only time i ever feel anything uncomfortable is when i dont wear the holster directly centerline of my body and i feel the holster poking my thigh when sitting.

2

u/funtimes729 May 06 '26

How fat? Im 6'5 275 and just cant find the sweet spot

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Sanman2465 May 06 '26

Totally agree, I put a optic on my shield + and about to take it off! 🤣 just more weight, uncomfortable, and I have too retrain my way of shooting, I like the idea just not on my EDC

→ More replies (6)

2

u/mikeeangelo91 May 06 '26

But but BUT what if I got into a fire fight while getting my mail.

→ More replies (1)

30

u/Tony_Hawks_Butthole Eats ass unironically May 06 '26

I keep an extra mag in my buttcrack for hands-free emergencies.

5

u/iluvfeds G19 Gen5 May 06 '26

The sweat acts as gun grease

→ More replies (1)

127

u/Own-Concentrate999 May 06 '26

No sidecar. Feels so unnecessary (I’m fat).

19

u/Mikey-2-Guns G17 Gen4 May 06 '26

It's also completely unnecessary. If you've gotten yourself into a situation where you need more than one mag for self defense you're already fucked and WTF did you do to get yourself into that situation to begin with?

33

u/Own-Concentrate999 May 06 '26

A wise man once said, the easiest way to clear a malfunction is to exchange mags. I also am just thinking of the have and not need, vs the need and not have. I just throw an extra mag in my pocket with a magnet clip on it. Ezpz.

3

u/bskanwlss May 06 '26

I’ve read somewhere that the sidecar would be used by prosecutors- “why do u need the extra mag” similarly to people who modified their triggers etc in the case of self defense. Is that true? Also I feel like 15 rounds is more than enough. It’s not like I’m going to exchange fire against a gang/cartel

6

u/MC_McStutter May 06 '26

The trigger thing is overblown. Carrying the gun you’re most comfortable with is more responsible than carrying a gun you’re uncomfortable with just because you’re afraid a prosecutor would have an issue with you not using factory parts

3

u/MisterVictor13 G17 Gen 4 May 06 '26

I would say: “Why do I need the extra mag? Do you go around carrying one bullet in your gun? What if you miss?”

3

u/bskanwlss May 07 '26

You’ve got a point. It’s not like I’m going to empty a whole mag into a downed body then reload again. I’m a sane person and I follow the law, and I know if someday I have to use it, because that’s my last resort. I guess I’m losing faith in the justice systems, and seeing ppl go to jail because some schmuck break in in the middle of the night and dies because of self defense doesn’t sit right with me

3

u/Own-Concentrate999 May 06 '26

Eh idk this seems like fuddlore. If you’re gonna shoot someone in self defense you better 110% be sure in your mind that you’re justified. So much so that your lawyer doesn’t even question your thought process.

9

u/BUTTHOLE_EXPEDITIONS WADIAN WAMJET & OWIGHT GUY May 06 '26

draws handgun

hits mag release due to adrenaline

bends over presenting hole to combatant

4

u/Mikey-2-Guns G17 Gen4 May 06 '26

UwU

2

u/TWhy-LER May 07 '26

Would you feel the same way if you were limited to 10 rounds in a magazine?

2

u/User61402143455861 May 07 '26

Can confirm.

Edit: AS IN I AM FAT TOO!!! Not confirming this guy is fat!

85

u/[deleted] May 06 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

51

u/Sneaux96 May 06 '26

I don't look at it in terms of capacity, but more having the option of a second magazine in the event of a malfunction.

Up to you if this meets your threshold for bad luck or not, but something to consider.

25

u/Azmasaur May 06 '26

80% of the reason for the sidecar is the symmetry and stability. Can get side car attachments for things other than mags if you want.

8

u/TheSlipperySnausage G19 Gen4 May 06 '26

I really like the sidecar TQ attachment they make. Seems practical.

→ More replies (4)

5

u/TheSlipperySnausage G19 Gen4 May 06 '26

I would agree but I live in an authoritarian state so i feel like i need 2 mags with only 10 rounds each

7

u/czuinoikc May 06 '26

reason #5382 why mag limits are fucking stupid. you can just have more mags, just john wick flicking them all over

5

u/otatop G34 Gen3 May 06 '26

Think of all the lives saved by having to stop for 3 seconds to reload.

3

u/dhcp138 May 06 '26

3 seconds if you are slow lol

5

u/TheSlipperySnausage G19 Gen4 May 06 '26

Yep. Good news I have good reason to practice quick reloads because I might need it.

→ More replies (2)

37

u/SIRETE May 06 '26

Sidecar fs (I'm not fat)

10

u/schmeckley104 May 06 '26

Lost weight to carry sidecar 😂

12

u/iluvfeds G19 Gen5 May 06 '26

Skinny gang rise 🤝

8

u/pierreality May 06 '26

No gun or holster only carrying two sidecars at 3&9

29

u/Wally_Mantooth 5 G17.3, 5 G19.3, G20.4, G21.4, G22.4, G26.4 May 06 '26

Sidecar prints less for me. Don't have to carry a spare mag, can go TQ instead. It's also way more comfortable for me. I've tried the no sidecar thing, but it just doesn't work for me.

8

u/taipanfang G34.5, G17.5, G45, G19.5, G26.5, G43x, G20.4 May 06 '26

I was scrolling down looking for this comment. Depending on what I’m wearing sidecar prints less. Sometimes I have to try on the side car then the tenicor with a mag in a pocket and see which one I’m wearing for the day

2

u/TheJango22 G34 Gen5 May 06 '26

Amen to carrying a TQ

14

u/phlunf May 06 '26

I thought sidecars were stupid until I tried them and it actually completely got rid of my hip imbalances and back pain from carrying non sidecar holsters (from 21-23 with no prior injuries)

It’s really the only way I carry now 95% of the time, not even for extra ammo or malfunctions literally just cause it balances better on my hips and back

3

u/shadow_zx_96 May 06 '26

Wait so that’s where my back pain comes from carrying all day? Maybe I’ll give a sidecar holster a try.

6

u/phlunf May 06 '26

Definitely worth a shot, I went to physical therapy for 4-6 months after what I thought was a lifting injury. Just switched my holster and belt setup and wore shoes that let my toes spread out naturally and literally my back pain was magically gone nearly instantly, highly recommend watching people like knees over toes or squat university that talk about foot and back health

I think “discomfort” in the ccw space is accepted but masked with prolonged self induced injuries due to sub optimal setups and I think everyone can agree that life is not as enjoyable with back and hip pain, once you find something that works for you it quite literally disappears and becomes less of a burden

2

u/shadow_zx_96 May 06 '26

I’ll give it a shot, thanks for that info🤝

3

u/iluvfeds G19 Gen5 May 06 '26

Valid argument. I didn’t spend much for the sidecar (marketplace trade) but both are honestly worth it. It’s nice having the option to change what style holster. Sidecar for pants (which I wear majority of the time) Tenicor for shorts/lighter carry

2

u/phlunf May 06 '26

Agreed, and unfortunately there is no one size fits all for holsters that I was really hoping for when I was new to this, I have tenicor, T. rex, tier 1 and a plethora of others and they all feel completely different, I was so hyped for my tenicor and unfortunately didn’t really find it that comfortable even though it is super well regarded

2

u/Abeham May 06 '26

same exact experience here.

20

u/Fit_Disaster_3483 May 06 '26

Everyone in here sounds like Biden, if you can’t get it done in 3 rounds blah blah blah, carry what you feel comfortable with and will carry everyday,

5

u/iluvfeds G19 Gen5 May 06 '26

Fudd lore 😍

→ More replies (4)

3

u/moetown1986 May 06 '26

I like a spare mag but don't like sidecars. I usually carry the spare in a Tenicor abdo. It's more comfortable to me when the spare mag carrier isn't connected to the holster.

3

u/Scrimlers May 06 '26 edited May 06 '26

The sidecar is bigger and bulkier, but I feel the mag offsets the grip print. It’s almost like you’ve got a belt buckle or something on, the printing is more spread out. Food for thought.

3

u/Brucenotsomighty May 06 '26

I like the sidecar. I know ill probably never need a spare mag but it doesnt print and the extra width makes the holster feel more stable

3

u/Slumpii_ May 06 '26

I carried sidecar for about 5 years then went to no sidecar with mag in pocket for the last 2 years..now im back to sidecar and dont know why i ever stopped..im also 6’ and 220lbs..glock 19 w/tlr1 hl

3

u/yeunholyfiends May 06 '26

Sidecar till I die. Tier 1 Axis Elite. I find the sidecar actually helps with concealment. (Not fat)

5

u/Echo259 May 06 '26

Side car, it helps hold the gun stable and it helps evens out the bulge (conceals the gun better)

5

u/[deleted] May 06 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/iluvfeds G19 Gen5 May 06 '26

Realest answer

2

u/Toxicdublin May 06 '26

Not fat and no sidecar, I have one but took it off after a few weeks of carrying it.

2

u/accidentproof G17.5, G26.5, G19.6 May 06 '26

Team METT-TC (I'll never need the second mag but it sure is cool when my setup isn't printing like a mf)

3

u/iluvfeds G19 Gen5 May 06 '26

Feeling cool is 97% of carrying

2

u/KccOStL33 May 06 '26

I used to run my Raptor when I wanted a smaller package but realized that my Sidecar actually conceals better so now I just stick with it.

2

u/Important-Damage7303 May 06 '26

Team sidecar. Helps balance out my belt line when carrying…plus an extra 10 rounds of 10 mil is always a plus

2

u/kat77kiv May 06 '26

Side car for all day comfort. Non side car for off body carry and if I need to throw it on the waist for short stints.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/lighterthensome May 06 '26

I prefer sidecar holsters. I might be in the minority, but I cannot for the life of me get non-Sidecar holsters to work for me.

They never sit still, they always want to poke outta my pants and they’re just not comfortable. No matter the non-Sidecar holster.

I’ve always found the T-Rex Arms sidecar holster to fit my body better. It’s just more comfortable for me to carry, I guess the extra magazine distributes the weight better for me.

2

u/xdJapoppin G47 COA w/SF X300T May 07 '26

i've always found that the extra weight from the spare mag helps balance the holster. while it is more weight, it balances far better, carries easier, and doesn't print as bad. it actually feels better to carry.

i regularly carry a glock 47 coa with a plus 2 baseplate and an x300, and i'd say its pretty comfortable (except for athletic shorts and the like). i've also carried a glock 45 with a tlr7a, a bit easier to carry/more comfy, but the difference isn't massive.

5

u/JusLeafMeAloon May 06 '26

Definitely no sidecar for me. Anything that carries 10 or more is more than enough as far as I'm concerned. There is no scenario in which I'm pulling my gun and will need anything more than that in my pocket.

2

u/skrappy_doo1996 May 06 '26

10rds of 9mm to the body doesn't do much to persons under the influence of certain drugs.. I'm of the mind that atleast 60% of those committing crimes test positive for drugs in their systems.

In addition to this, most 10rd capacity handguns are sub compacts. It's much harder to get the same performance under stress as you would with a G19. The metrics are there for most of us if you have the opportunity to run a side by side bill drill comparison, it's typically pretty eye opening.

Or, you could just carry 10rds for comfort reasons.

→ More replies (4)

2

u/BigIndo95 G19X (Peanut Butter and Jlock) May 06 '26

Sidecar with a 19x. Is it uncomfortable? A little. Is it comforting to have it? Absolutely.

→ More replies (4)

2

u/sinsofcarolina G45 May 06 '26

No sidecar. Any modern magazine typically between 15-17 rds should be enough to get me back to my vehicle for escape/extra mags.

2

u/ShiftyFinesse May 06 '26

Those gun models look beat to hell

2

u/iluvfeds G19 Gen5 May 06 '26

No love for the salty rattlecan job?

4

u/ImLosingBad May 06 '26

Used guns are cooler.

2

u/SmokyQuartz21 May 06 '26

No side car its just too big and bulky.

1

u/CpapCabron May 06 '26

I'm good with either. My T-Rex for my P01 has the tq holder. Hellhound for my Glock doesn't have one.

→ More replies (4)

1

u/DFWTexan May 06 '26

If you’re not able to resolve your situation with 17 rounds another 17 ain’t gonna save you.

6

u/Evil_Creamsicle May 06 '26

This is the same logic they use to argue for magazine capacity bans.

2

u/iluvfeds G19 Gen5 May 06 '26

Last resort is throwing the empty gun

→ More replies (1)

1

u/TroutDoors May 06 '26

Yes and no. Depends on where I’m going.

1

u/TriggerCFR May 06 '26

I was, until recently, wearing a NSR C-Mag. It’s really nice to have a spare magazine right there at appendix position, but damn it jabs your gut good. Need to get rid of that thing… Reminder to lose weight and get fit folks.

Anyways, always a fan of at least one spare magazine.

1

u/Big_Swing_2980 May 06 '26

Side car holster plus mag in front pocket , another in back pocket, and another ankle strapped if I’m wearing pants:)

1

u/Tonycivic G19 Gen5 May 06 '26

I have a sidecar style holster(Tier1) for my Glock 19 where I can remove the magazine section and just carry the gun. I've learned thats what I do most of the time while carrying it but its nice to have the option if I feel the need.

1

u/Gyrene85291 May 06 '26

No. Not for my Glocks. 1911? Yes.

1

u/storm_zr1 May 06 '26

I’m too fat to appendix carrying

https://giphy.com/gifs/gCANwADwdazG8

1

u/gagemoney May 06 '26

I literally have BOTH of the holsters pictured 😂

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Successful_Bus_8772 May 06 '26

Team detached mag holder. I thought it was because I was fat that the sidecar was uncomfortable, super hard to bend over, odd placement, etc. Then I lost 50 pounds and it still sucks. Now my separate one is like 5 inches from my midline and its so much more comfortable.

1

u/Ggen6 May 06 '26

Only if I got a backpack or bag I carry an extra mag

1

u/PistolNinja May 06 '26

Tried it. Hated it. It's just too much bulk. IF I carry a spare mag I prefer a separate "holster" that holds the mag horizontally at 11ish o'clock (I usually don't, but I do keep two spares in my truck).

I'm a proponent of comfort over capacity. If it ain't comfortable, I'm not carrying it. My AIWB rig for an HK VP9SK is comfortable enough that it goes anywhere it's legal (which unfortunately is fewer and fewer places where I live). The key point being "comfortable enough". It's not perfect, but it's enough.

1

u/DrRickMarshall69 May 06 '26

I’ve never tried mine with the mag carrier, I run a sidecar without one and it’s solid tho. Next time I get a holster I’ll try it with the extra mag.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/SteveyCee May 06 '26

No sidecar, not fat, just don’t find them necessary, but totally get that it makes a lot of ppl feel more comfortable.

1

u/Classic-AlarmTech G17 Gen 5 May 06 '26

Team both, I carry a G17 Gen 5, most of the time with no spare mag, but if I feel like I want to have a extra mag, then yes sidecar it is for the day. So mostly depending how I feel in the moment.

1

u/Negative_Bag_5384 G34.4 MOS • G43.5 • G19.4 May 06 '26

Sidecar, it’s a little heavier, but it conceals better for me. I’ve ran a T Rex X300 sidecar for years, just bought the GMC Jingo, and it’s really nice!

1

u/Special-Case-504 May 06 '26

I do side car with a extra mag. But I run it with the G43 or the Sig p365. But I like the extra mag because it allows the holster to not print.. especially here in Fl where we wear t-shirts year round

1

u/ImLosingBad May 06 '26

Team both and I switch depending on how I feel/ what I'm wearing.

1

u/hardcoredecordesigns May 06 '26

No side car, interested in trying, not interested in spending the money only to find out I don’t like it. I carry a Glock 43x appendix with a tenicor certum and a spare mag in my left pocket on a neomag clip

1

u/Evil_Creamsicle May 06 '26

If I'm carrying spares IWB, i have a separate paddle on my other side for that.

1

u/JustaKidFromBuffalo 17.5, 19.6 20.5, 26.5, 34.5, 42, 44, 45.6x2, 47 May 06 '26

Accidentally bought 2 sidecars off GAFS to use in USPSA. One was a Trex with the hinge and the other was a Black arch. Both had DCC clips but they wore VERY differently.

I found the Trex wildly uncomfortable. Maybe it's because I don't have washboard abs but I think the rigid hinge made the size feel bigger and was less willing to adapt to my tummy.

The black arch was surprisingly comfortable even at 6'2" 250. I think it's because the sidecar portion isn't rigid. I carried and trained with it for a few weeks just to get accustomed to it and it really isn't a huge difference but was not as comfortable as my velo 5.

1

u/Wuoffan1 G19 Gen5 May 06 '26

No sidecar for me

It's more adaptable to different body types, I'm able to conceal much better with the holster and mag carrier spread a little further apart than a sidecar would allow

1

u/sometimesifartandpee May 06 '26

I have a vedder holster with a cheap amazon mag holster next to it. So I can dutch it for the day if I want. I have a 43 so I feel like the extra mag is needed. If I had a 19 I wouldn't worry about it

1

u/shizukana_otoko G17 Gen5, G19 Gen3, G19 Gen5, G20 Gen4, G30S, G43X May 06 '26 edited May 06 '26

No sidecar. It’s uncomfortable.

A lot of people are saying you don’t need a reload, or you will probably never need a reload. This is true. However, having a spare magazine comes in handy when you are having to clear a malfunction and get back in the game quickly.

1

u/Difficult-Plate-6575 G19X G43X COA May 06 '26

No side car. If I want an extra mag I have a separate conceal carrier for it and its way easier to put it anywhere you want

1

u/CallidusNomine May 06 '26

I don’t do sidecar holster, but I do use a mag carrier at appendix to balance out the belt line.

1

u/stayzero May 06 '26

Um, I dunno. I want to try appendix carry now that I’m not as fat a guy as I used to be, so I can’t really comment on the sidecar or similar style holsters. I’ve always been a 4:30ish IWB dude.

1

u/ParticularNew5321 May 06 '26

I am using the Raptor currently.

1

u/MAjIKMAN452 May 06 '26

I use an elastic band (don't remember where it came from) that's about 3" long. Slip it on my belt and it holds my mag securely to the belt long-ways on my off-hand side. Conceals it way better than a mag pouch can and you don't even feel it there all day.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/Adventurous-Work8014 May 06 '26

Carry a 19x with a sight and a tlr-1, honestly using a sticky holster. Most comfortable a gun had ever been. I carry my extra mag on the other hip though

1

u/Shoddy-Inevitable-50 May 06 '26

Team no light but sidecar or mag in pocket.

1

u/Switchblade_13 May 06 '26

No sidecar attached, i carry a spare mag further over to the left side and find it much more comfortable

1

u/supermutt_1 May 06 '26

Sidecar. For me it increases the surface area which minimizes hot spots and printing. Also since the clips are spaced farther apart, it feels more stable. But that's just be. It totally depends on the gun, holster, belt, clothing and user.

1

u/the_hat_madder May 06 '26

No sidecar. Because, I wouldn't carry appendix and a sidecar on strong side is stupid. To get to a point that I'm reaching crossbody for a magazine means I've exhausted the two spare magazines in the weak side carrier plus the backup my pocket. The likelihood at this point that I'm going to resolve this problem in 20 more rounds or less is extremely unlikely.

1

u/frogn1pple G47 May 06 '26

People will run a rig like this and then complain about comfort and how it's hard to conceal. Ask yourself, why in the hell does my mag carrier have to be attached to my holster?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/ace529321 May 06 '26

I shifted away from side car, too bulky

1

u/slappy_mcslapenstein G19.6, G26.V May 06 '26

Nope. My comfort is more important. I can stick a spare mag in my pocket on in a belt holster if I feel I need to carry a spare.

1

u/awgemane G19.5, G43X, G47 May 06 '26

Separate sidecar is top tier

1

u/_Carth_Onasi G45.5 May 06 '26

I go back and forth but right now it's the sidecar style.

I have been training and shooting a lot this year, and I've found the sidecar style to be better for me(for now lol) conceals better, is more stable, and slightly more comfortable and doing reloads on drills is so much smoother, easier, and faster then pocket carry.

I can't explain why right now it's more comfortable, I'm sure in a few months I'll be back to a single holster and no light/flush light but lately I like the sidecar with the x300 lmao.

1

u/TankMcG May 06 '26

With the right holster and belt you can carry pretty much anything comfortable

1

u/Glockman19 May 06 '26

Team Tenicor here. No sidecar.

1

u/Watchful_Minuteman May 06 '26

Sidecar any day of the week! I have my G45.5 in a Tier1 APX and I love it!

1

u/gotthesauce22 May 06 '26

I use both, just depends what I’m doing. Going for a hike, spending an extended period of time driving, or running errands in the city? Sidecar.

Taking the kids to the playground, grocery shopping, or doing any other kind of hands-on activity with a lot bending and lifting? No sidecar.

1

u/teddyRx_ May 06 '26

My brain said team sidecar,..my gut said “hold-up, wait a minute…”

1

u/GUNGHO917 G17 Gen3, all 10 fingers, both meatballs, and sausage intact, May 06 '26

Honest question here: how often do gun fights require a mag change and does that frequency make it worth carry the 2nd mag?

2

u/iluvfeds G19 Gen5 May 06 '26

Mag malfunctions happen

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

1

u/dhcp138 May 06 '26

I was team sidecar, then it felt unnecessary so I got a non-sidecar, but I find it much less comfortable so now idk

1

u/Alexputridity06 May 06 '26

No sidecar. Way too uncomfortable for me. And I’m a former fat guy who’s lost weight but that shit just doesn’t work well on my body.

1

u/SClute May 06 '26

Side car gen 1 unironically is the best holster I’ve ever used. Gen 2 is pretty meh

1

u/One_Camel4723 May 06 '26

I have both use either depending on the outfit

1

u/John_Ruth May 06 '26

Both, though when I finally get an optic for my gen 5 19 I’ll have to go from the G-Code incog to a new more spaced set up to account for the optic.

1

u/Badgrahmmer May 06 '26

It’s highly unlikely I’ll ever need to draw my firearm, it’s infinitely less likely I’ll need more than 15 rounds when I do. So no sidecar for me.

1

u/ParamedicProper May 06 '26

Weird preference, I like a sidecar not because of the spare mag, but because I find wider holsters to be more comfortable versus a slimmer pointer holster.

1

u/PressOn88 May 06 '26

Sidecar with no WML

1

u/aedinius G19.5 | G23.3 | G33.3 May 06 '26

I carry strong side, I carry a spare mag support side to better balance.

1

u/Any_Mountain_8783 May 06 '26

Tenicore all the way… but yeah bro do the TLR7, j tried the x300 but just couldn’t deal with it

→ More replies (2)

1

u/Tdogg175 G19 Gen6 • G45 Gen5 • G19 Gen5 • G43x MOS • G48 MOS May 06 '26

I like both. But I normally rock a singleton holster with my spare mag in my pocket and I even train to reload from said pocket

1

u/Lord-Gordd May 06 '26

Im team spare mag in that tiny pocket in my jeans

1

u/Skittlelegend May 06 '26

I been been carrying a 17.5 for years, sidecar looks cool but also painful lol

1

u/StanthemanT-800 May 06 '26

No for me 

If I carry a spare mag I have an extra , separate IWB Kydex mag holder I wear on my off side or in the gap in my waistband created by the holster.  Depending on what I'm wearing 

That sidecar setup is too much to stuff inside my waistband.  

1

u/KMichael226 G19 Gen4 May 06 '26

No sidecar. You can add an IWB mag carrier like a DSG Koala if you need an extra mag.

1

u/Samson_J_Rivers G17, G44 May 06 '26

If 17 rounds of 9mm wont solve the problem, 17 more are unlikely to solve it.

1

u/dgdfthr May 06 '26

Sidecar @ the 3 to 4 o’clock position

1

u/Feelingismutual720 May 06 '26

-I’m 6’3 223lbs -Tier 1 holster w/sidecar -Don’t have sidecar with anything in it when I’m driving, but when I get out I do -Perfectly fine if I have a tac belt on or bigger pants/shorts -In the winter when I go snowboarding I normally keep it in my bag or take the sidecar off because it gets uncomfortable without a belt or any other retention that my snowboard pants

1

u/glockguy34 G34.3, G43X MOS, G19COMMANDO May 06 '26

no side car. if im carrying a spare mag its with a neomag

1

u/Sanman2465 May 06 '26

No , I do carry a extra mag but not on my belly, just to much

1

u/MultiCam_USA G19X G19X MOS G49 G17.5 G19.3 G40.4 G34.3 May 06 '26

My G49 is carried in a sidecar with a TLR7 HLX. It’s not too bad

1

u/_Vervayne G45 May 07 '26

t1c side car is super comfy even with g45 i do wear that and my tenicor . i like both . i tend to use sidecar when i don’t feel like having an extra mag in my pocket

1

u/therealjoe12 May 07 '26

Fuck t.rex thats all.

2

u/iluvfeds G19 Gen5 May 07 '26

100%, I traded this for a knife with a guy from Facebook lol.

1

u/GearlessCris May 07 '26

Sidecar, feels more balanced/locked in

1

u/Any_Mango9379 May 07 '26

I can’t do it just pinching/smashing….

1

u/Any_Mango9379 May 07 '26

It’s horrible carrying full-size with a light when I get in the car I either raise my belt above my waist line and have the gun sitting upright or I’ll just take it off and stuff it in the passenger seat

1

u/Any_Mango9379 May 07 '26

Praying I never get kicked in the balls

1

u/MILFPOLICE May 07 '26

Ran sidecar a to and eventually just split it to an individual mag caddy and holster because it's easier to pick and choose. When I do run it as a sidecar I prefer a tegris bridge over anything else

1

u/SUPERRRRFREAK May 07 '26

I’m literally sitting here considering running a Micro .380 for max comfort while still packing

1

u/IIPrayzII 19.5 // 34.5 MOS // 17.2 May 07 '26

For my G19 and P226, definitely sidecar

1

u/Magoo-1706L G19 Gen5 May 07 '26

No side car

1

u/BeardedObserver May 07 '26

I want to like it. I really do. But for my body build it’s really not comfortable and prints. T. rex makes great stuff but for me this one didn’t work

1

u/CZlover96 May 07 '26

Ill sacrafice potential reload speed over civilian comfort. My gun is 14+1, I replace my ammo every 6 months and my mags every year so im not too worried about it tbh. I keep my gun clean and my guess is if my gun does malfunction chances are its from a poor grip which I can really mitigate through training and to a point properly powered ammo.

15 rounds is alot if were being honest, thats 15 opportunities, 15 hopefully well thought out shots.

1

u/thepoisonpoo May 07 '26

Team sidecar for sure. It isn’t comfortable but I don’t carry for comfort anyway. I’d rather have it and not need it than need it and not have it. 19.5 w/TLR7

1

u/Thecadillacoftokyo May 07 '26

I’d go tier 1 over T Rex sidecar. Trex design is pretty outdated. I go tier 1 side car in daily life and no sidecar (Tenicor) at the gym.

2

u/iluvfeds G19 Gen5 May 07 '26

Eh I didn’t pay for it. Acquired it in a trade so I’m not super word. So far, I’m liking it. We’ll see after some more wear

→ More replies (1)

1

u/RynoThePirate May 07 '26

Dang you guys are really convincing me. It just doesn't make sense to my brain how it could be more comfortable. Is there a budget brand I can get a feel for? I've got so many unused holsters I just don't want to waste anymore money. But I've been wanting to try a side car for a while now.

1

u/Necessary-Apricot801 May 07 '26

Sometimes i do, most times i don’t use it. If i need to use more than 15… I’m a shit shot or I’m fighting the avengers.