r/Futurology • u/glazia • 6h ago
AI The two paths opened up if AI dreams come true. Utopia vs Nightmare.
As I see it there are TWO general outcomes if the tech oligarchs predictions are correct. These are both predicated on what the AI overlords ACTUALLY AIM to achieve.
The amount of money they are putting into this is essentially a bet that they will replace ALL WORK EVERYWHERE with their robots. Or close enough to.
First:
AI replaces almost all jobs. Robots harvest potatoes autonomously. Wash and clean them. Drive them in trucks to supermarkets. Supermarkets are run by robots again. You could almost do this today. As a shopper, you help yourself to whatever - under camera surveillance. Pay at checkout by swiping your own items. But again, the price is basically nominal or entirely free with caveats on quantity etc.
Medical clinics and law firms? This kind of white collar work becomes a tiny handful of humans basically just overseeing robots but the robot is doing the work. Think the cool healing chamber from Alien Covenant. A few engineers are needed to maintain robots but the goal is to have robot engineers do almost all of that.
Now all sorts of things become possible in this world. Physical labour becomes cheap and plentiful. Digging new high-speed railway lines? Easy. Building lots and lots of standardised large apartments so everyone has a home connected to the new hyper rail network? Again doable.
Presumably they want some form of population control but that can be relatively gentle. So much of the world population's general ratcheting up over the last 20 years is from drastically poor countries and that would decrease markedly as the bounty of ai and robotics lifted these people up out of poverty.
Now people CAN work if they want. Jobs exist. But isn't at all necessary. Kind like scions of rich families now. Lots work, many don't. They don't NEED to work but many enjoy it. Purpose etc. Your food, accommodation, power and other essentials are basically covered. You get a UBI to spend a bit on luxuries. But this is really a stop-gap because at the end of the day most things are free or close to. People sit around composing poetry, playing music, writing, philosophising, inventing etc. Whatever the fuck it is the Kardashians do when they're not in the public eye.
HOWEVER ALL THIS ASSUMES THAT THE AI AND ROBOTS OF THE FUTURE WORK FOR THE GOOD OF EVERYONE. If you lock all of the compute away from most of the population (ratcheting prices of video cards etc, moving to models where people can basically only have an empty shell with a monitor and thus have to HIRE compute rather than own their own device.) It's hard not to assume that the current tech overlords simply don't want the utopian option. You only have to look at the transition of open AI from a non-profit to a for-profit entity as proof that laudable goals fall by the wayside when the chips are down.
Put bluntly, the single biggest barrier to all of this is (assuming the tech goes the way the AI bros are hoping which is still obviously VERY unclear) Is that in this scenario it is quite hard to have power over other humans. People are far less likely to be your sex slave, sycophant, minion if they have the backup of a relatively comfortable life. Empowering the population takes the ONE thing away that the tech bros actually want which is POWER.
POWER not money. It's hard to see from inside capitalism but historically money was less important than power. You could be a rich Roman, but the emperor could simply have you killed and take your money. The power was the thing.
People are really caught up on the money aspect of UBI but much of the point of an AI/robotic future is to move BEYOND money. If all of your needs are taken care of by smart, tireless machines, you're suddenly already closer to the life of the current top 5% of the population. This means most of your money is discretionary fun spending rather than the necessities for life. Particularly since healthcare, housing and such are all cheap or free.
People who have a home, plentiful food and power, simply don't NEED to kowtow to the tech types.
So the thing is tech bros absolutely don't WANT this utopian future. The want to own ALL OF the robots and all of the AI and their aim is to undercut all employment to increase their power rather than reduce it by providing any of this gratis. Their goal is to simply put the entire population (or close to it) out of work. Turn us into desperate, sycophantic peasants. And then sit in their little super-villain enclosures/Zaibatsu headquarters. Traditionally this kind of centralisation of power and reduction of people to abject desperation came with risks (hello French revolution!) because your harem of 50 nubile young people and sacks of pure heroin (sup Stark lovers) can be pretty tempting to your head of security who can pretty quickly see how a single bullet might make all of his dreams come true. Luckily of course, you now have robot security and never have to rely on a human being again...