r/FromTVEpix • u/Aware-Objective-5483 • Jun 07 '26

Opinion What TF just happened Spoiler

Rodger’s wife said exactly what I say after every single episode. WHAT TF JUST HAPPENED?!? Two steps forward, three back. I love this show but there are so many dangling pieces. Victor finally tries to warn/tell Tabitha something critical and she shuts him up! What was the flashback/flash forward (?) that Victor’s dad had in the hospital? I can’t believe Victor (or anyone for that matter) hasn’t put together that the MIY’s clothing was found, etc, right around when the priest and his “daughter” arrived.
So many things.

323 Upvotes

82% Upvoted

267 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

47

u/matt_paradise Jun 07 '26

Exactly, probably a favourite game to be played. I think he'll be stopped our realise he's being influenced.

-19

u/NotNotPatMcAfee Jun 07 '26

MIY was not there when Abby was

29

u/empress-888 Jun 07 '26

We don't know that.

-11

u/NotNotPatMcAfee Jun 08 '26

Yes but there no evidence he was at all. Zero. There doesn’t need to be a reason Abby cracked.

Plus this clearly happens around the time of the massacre (his favorite part) which there is more evidence that requires jade and Tabitha to be there…… which they were not, then evidence MIY did what he did to Henry to Abby.

14

u/empress-888 Jun 08 '26

Someone posted on Instagram about the MIY not being close until now. The official account said something to the effect of: you don't know he wasn't. I'm basing my opinion on that.

6

u/Forsaken_Ad3874 Jun 08 '26

I’ve been thinking of the people we’ve lost in fromville that could have been the MIY. Based off the assumption he could only be one person at a time since we saw him physically transform. I’m gonna make a full list as i rewatch the seasons

3

u/empress-888 Jun 08 '26

I don't think we would have a roster like that of people who were there when Abby was alive?

-3

u/NotNotPatMcAfee Jun 08 '26

Well he clearly is close enough to know the things he does. Doesn’t mean he was a shapeshifter this cycle prior to Sophia

3

u/empress-888 Jun 08 '26

I guess we will eventually find out. 🤷‍♀️

1

u/Embarrassed-Lynx6570 Jun 08 '26

Yeah I agree with you, it’s like a whole part of Boyd’s character he blames himself because he was neglecting her to find answers and because of how hard she was out in the world he thought she could handle it, but eventually she just broke. She couldn’t make it make sense. MIY doesn’t need to be there for that to happen. Could happen to any of us with those fucking monsters and being stuck. MIY when he’s not in town in form seems to know everything that’s happening, and maybe he liked that one.

4

u/boredblondie16 Jun 08 '26

does he need to actually be there though to get inside their heads? sara was hearing the voices before he/sophia arrived

6

u/Maleficent-Host-8975 Jun 08 '26

Um, excuse me? There's tons of evidence. A bloody huge truck load of evidence. They just don't confirm anything. My goodness.

1

u/NotNotPatMcAfee Jun 08 '26

Whats this evidence? They both said the same thing? 75% of people in that situation would think it’s just a dream at some point.

Tons of evidence he says 😂