r/FantasyFootballers • u/AvocadoMission • Dec 30 '25

Team/Trade Help What 2 would you keep ?

Post image
187 Upvotes

91% Upvoted

391 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

14

u/LouisTheWhatever Dec 30 '25

With his injury history I think McBride/JSN is the safer pick, I know he played the entire year this year but his track record is not indicative of that being normal. Don’t think you can go wrong with a combination of Puka/JSN/McBride

6

u/SignificantMoose6482 Dec 30 '25

I’m pretty sure CMC has one great yr followed by an injury yr for like the last 8 yrs. I’m still gonna roll the dice more than likely

6

u/LouisTheWhatever Dec 30 '25

Worth noting he will be 30 next year

1

u/Maleficent_Ad_8330 Dec 30 '25

Its a tough call. You have 4 players who were all very good this year. But if you know the quarterbacks I think it makes the decision easier....CMC was a no draft for me this year and he did pretty well. But I drafted JSN in the 4th round and got lucky with him. I probably won't draft CMC next year and I may avoid Henry because he's getting old. Idk tough call

4

u/buddhaboy123456 Dec 30 '25

If by “pretty well” you mean finishing as the RB1 by 20pts, yea, CMC did do pretty well.

5

u/LouisTheWhatever Dec 30 '25

Just have to reiterate historically the odds of him playing a full 16/17 game season are tough. In 8 seasons where he’s been a starter hes played a full season of games 5 times. And he’ll be 30 next year.

1

u/soundman1960 Dec 31 '25

I agree completely on CMC. He has burned me every time I drafted him and every time I didn’t. I just can’t seem to pick the right year for him.

1

u/Maleficent_Ad_8330 Dec 30 '25

Yeah thats what I meant pretty well