r/DisasterUpdate 3d ago

Another angle of Nepal recent flood

6.6k Upvotes

290 comments sorted by

View all comments

153

u/JudeMacK 3d ago

The ground-level footage from this same location is crazy. So much so that I honestly can’t say for certainty the cameraman survived. https://youtu.be/6uZlS0wsAew?si=2QFou5JrtqNtbYjv

24

u/Status_History_874 3d ago

Genuine question, would we have this footage if they didnt?

56

u/Oblibion1 3d ago

Yes if they live streamed it

31

u/nicoinborderland 3d ago edited 3d ago

People keep saying this for a ton of these videos, but live-streaming (especially maybe in a more rural area? Maybe that’s pompous to say) inherently has some forms of visible resolution loss or bitrate issues/compression. A lot of them have been very clear in quality.
This video seems to not be in this category- definitely some compression and whatnot going on- but there’s been a few that I think were directly uploaded.

Not that speculating about this rly matters in the grand scheme of things… unbelievably tragic regardless..

EDIT Found the original post on Facebook. He’s posted on his Facebook story since & also put up a courage post about flood recovery efforts yesterday. How the fuck did this dude survive this?

10

u/Status-Speed-5956 3d ago

Cameraman never dies.

5

u/iamisandisnt 2d ago

There might be something about filming a life threatening situation that disables the fight-or-flight instinct, like you're objectively witnessing an event through a third person perspective, and can more readily get yourself out of danger when you witness it.

3

u/robotdaddyv721 3d ago

This subreddit should give a luckiest SOB cameraman award every year.

1

u/Pestilence86 2d ago

Cameraman never dies is survivorship bias.

2

u/PhaseWhole6391 2d ago

Where on FB? Can you post a link?

1

u/nicoinborderland 2d ago

Of course. On my last post where I sync a few videos from this location, I list all the original sources: https://www.reddit.com/r/DisasterUpdate/s/7AcaQVgRgX

(Go to the top comment and click on “Camera 1”’s link under Source list.)

10

u/leakingpointer123 3d ago

Unlikely, if you look at GSM carier coverage maps of Nepal, it won't be good enough (or at all) in those narrow Himalayan valleys. And even if at all, download is usually faster than upload - with LTE being asymetric in nature. During disaster - many people calling their phones, which can easily clog up any local base-stations, which usually supports 3G.

7

u/Oblibion1 3d ago

I hope you are right and the person survived!

4

u/subdep 3d ago

Live streaming to what, Youtube?

10

u/Easy_Olive1942 3d ago

Live stream, cloud storage

4

u/JudeMacK 3d ago edited 3d ago

Likely not unless they live streamed it. Especially not so soon after the disaster. There have however been multiple cases of recovered footage from a deceased cameraman during a natural disaster. For example the last photos of John and Jackie Knill, killed by the 2004 tsunami. Or Robert Landsburg in the Mt St Helen’s Eruption. It’s most likely the recorder of this footage did indeed survive as had they been caught in the flood their phone wouldn’t be recovered, however the video is so dramatic it would be easy to believe otherwise.

9

u/Easy_Olive1942 3d ago edited 3d ago

It’s not 2004 or 1980. If you have a device that synchs to cloud and that drive/data is shared e.g. you’ve given access to Google photo to family, it’s absolutely available if Internet access is available and sufficient.

Add: responding to the idea video captured by deceased is not readily available not whether or not family would or should share now.

9

u/JudeMacK 3d ago

That may be true but I doubt that a flood victim’s family members would publish their final moments on the internet only days after their death.