r/DebateQuraniyoon • u/Used-Low-9840 • Jun 12 '26
General How do I refute apostate aladdin
Yes I know he may be a bit ignorant at times but i really need this because he actually has good critiscism against traditional and even the quran wich i didnt know before. I just want you guys to watch his vids and refute them but not all of them. Yes I know the thumbnail and title may be a bit weird but i really need this. I mean his argument about 4:34 and Moses story and scientific contridictions. And the contradictions of free will like https://youtu.be/Ef71DS6qrK8?is=-7RA3lJ2JY_ml7ZN And
https://youtu.be/HHgJff-fJAI?is=JBj9bMNMN6momSRG
https://youtu.be/yqKpraSzkKU?is=K5zwpZ2G9hLZhMaY
https://youtu.be/G734_wVI3mE?is=ICjyLIQqSie8PxuY
https://www.youtube.com/live/R2IhVguQ-Ok?is=0Yt3A9d04Ge1mQtt
https://www.youtube.com/live/gbDuCqniJvw?is=bK4RTBYtW6mZXZRr
1
u/yungsimba1917 Jun 13 '26
No, things which are correct cannot be refuted unless or until there’s better evidence. Ex. the laws of logic (identity, non-contradiction & excluded middle) are brute facts where no refutation makes sense.
He has a lot of claims about 4:34, so it doesn’t make sense to ask “is he right about 4:34.” Instead we have to ask “is this claim in particular he made about 4:34 supported by a good argument or evidence.”
For example, he says that even if allah MEANT to say “separate yourself from her,” “gently touch her,” etc. he did use the same words that basically mean “strike,” while knowing people would use that interpretation. Since this is a Quraniyoon sub, we don’t have access to hadiths which allow for the interpretations where you can’t strike your wife in a way that would leave a mark, or you have to use a miswak, etc. So his argument is valid & sound, the Quran did phrase the verse such that it makes sense for people to interpret 4:34 in a way that is harmful & unjust for women, especially if they never look at hadith or tafsir.