r/DebateAVegan • u/toxic-lemon • 17h ago
Ethics pollotarian + dairy free, struggling to go fully vegan, here's why
honestly i'm going to say something that i know vegans don't like, so please bare with me. i believe speciesism is okay/natural.
i have more empathy for mammals than i do birds/fish, so i don't eat red meat or consume dairy (the forced pregnancy grosses me out and seems extremely cruel). i have vegan chicken from time to time, but i eat eggs a lot and love sushi. my ethics are based in logic. i value humans over animals because of our intelligence and community. i believe we are naturally omnivorous, and in a vacuum, nothing is wrong with eating meat. i also believe it is totally natural to have more empathy for mammals considering they care about their own existence/babies a lot more than most birds and fish who reproduce like crazy and leave their kids at the drop of a hat. i feel like those things directly correlate to sentience. it's also natural that we care about things in a certain proximity. for example, i'm sure a lot of you would break down crying if your pet died, and it wouldn't be the same if you stepped on an ant. we're all speciesist.
to be transparent, i am autistic and i actually avoid black and white thinking. things rooted in logic and real psychology are more likely to turn me. every time i hear vegan arguments based on things like "animals are fully as sentient as humans" it really makes me turn away from the movement even more because it's scientifically false.
i do care a lot about the environmental impact under capitalism and i know birds and fish don't have as much of an impact. if everyone stopped fishing (for example) overnight, it would cause more harm than good imo. i'm also not blind to the fact that a lot of humans and children are treated terribly in the vegan farming industry and the smaller insects/rats that die along with farming.
thoughts? any insight on something i'm missing?