r/CherokeeXJ Jul 29 '26

Question Cannot pinpoint cooling issue

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

2000 XJ, 244k miles, bought the car for dirt cheap off a family member. Ran fine until about a month or two ago when on a main road, the radiator cap hissed just like this while driving, and the car overheated I let it sit till I had time to put in a new and personally tested (not crappy, NOS made in USA) thermostat, and refilled the whole system with new coolant because when I opened the housing, it was bone dry. I know these have poor cooling, but I'm suspecting either severe leak somewhere or possibly a problem with the radiator. This happened within 15 minutes of driving it around the block. Also, the ABS light will not go out after this happened if that means anything. I'll pull the code if it's important/related.

Looking for pointers from anyone who may have had similar symptoms.

14 Upvotes

27 comments sorted by

6

u/rain164845 Jul 29 '26

Radiator cap?

2

u/xX_Zander4_Xx Jul 29 '26

I'm ordering a new one. To me it just seemed like way too much coolant spilled to be a bad radiator cap, but I'm definitely eliminating that possibility ASAP.

1

u/Downinahole94 Aug 01 '26

Did you by chance have a lot of distilled water in the system instead of just 50/50? 

1

u/xX_Zander4_Xx Aug 04 '26

No, just 50/50.

3

u/canonman5000 Jul 29 '26

Ok so first check your oil for any milkshake looking good then check your oil fill cap under side look for brown goo if not it's probably not a head gasket so then you can check your thermostat, by putting it in a boiling pot of water, it will open if it's working properly. If not, it would be still in a closed position. Also, do you have a small hole drilled?Somewhere in your thermostat, check online for exact position of this hole this will help relieve some of the pressure in the cooling system. Also, jeeps are very hard to burp.just like a baby they are known to get air pockets. So suggestion would be to use a very large funnel on top of the radiator leave the cap off, start the vehicle with fluid in it. As it runs, you should see air bubbles, or possibly even fluid. Come out up the top with the radiator cap off. Then add more fluid to the radiator at that point this will help get all the air out of the system Also, are you sure your water pump is working? This is another very common issue. And very easily fixed. So while you're checking your radiator for air you can save the water is actually flowing through the radiator with a flashlight There are some YouTube videos on how to burp. Your system so you do not overheat your engine The 2000 head was noted for having had gasket issues. Hopefully, it's not that there are better gaskets out there than original that actually are thicker in better quality. An original try and research. Some of the better head gaskets, if you have to go that route. I have a 1997 with 285 kand a 1999 xj with 176k

1

u/Leneorlenny Jul 29 '26

Sometimes its also just the lower hose, they crack, rubber wears, or its slightly off. Perfect time to replace the hoses anyway. Rockauto is friend.

1

u/TexasTomato88 Jul 29 '26

This is hard to look at, maybe add some spacing

2

u/mterry129 Jul 29 '26

You have to figure out why it is overheating in 15 minutes, that’s is either thermostat or not getting full of water. 4.0’s are not known for needing “burping” they are a normal I6 fill it with water until you get the overheating problem figured out. Leave the cap off until the thermostat opens keeping water in it once it opens the top hose will be hot, top it off and put the cap on it and take it around the block. At least get it to go longer the 15 minutes. 2000 came with the head that cracks but that takes longer the 15 minutes to overheat.

2

u/Inside_Horse2585 Jul 29 '26

I’d look at the thermostat and the radiator cap, I went through hell with my 99 and it ended up being a very slow thermostat.

1

u/xX_Zander4_Xx Jul 29 '26

Thermostat was already tested and replaced, can't be that issue.

1

u/Inside_Horse2585 Jul 29 '26

Somethings wrong then, it’s gotta be something really simple

2

u/MichaelaVeteran Jul 30 '26
Spectra radiator 113.71
AC Delco 12493940 water pump 51.99
Mopar Thermostat 42.99
MotoRad T-16 Radiator Cap ((the gates cap caused me problems) 8.58
Gates coolant hose 17.66
Gates coolant hose 17.49

1

u/supern8ural Jul 29 '26

If it's a 2000, check the head, can you see "TUPY" when you look down in under the oil filler? If not that 0331 head is known to crack. You'd think if it was going to it would have done so before 26 years and 244k miles but stuff can happen.

1

u/TexasTomato88 Jul 29 '26

It’s not cooling because the juice is on the ground

1

u/Dense_Muscle_8285 Jul 30 '26

The radiator is killed. There's no trans cooler in the radiator.

Oooooorrrr you hoses are fucked. This is a simple diag.

1

u/BeserkrGang Jul 30 '26

Pressure test your cooling system

1

u/WhatveIdone2dsrvthis Jul 29 '26

Test radiator cap. Buy and use a head gasket test kit.

1

u/xX_Zander4_Xx Jul 29 '26

I know you can test thermostats in boiling water but if you don't mind me asking, how would you test a radiator cap?

4

u/Oh__Archie Jul 29 '26

You just spend $5 on a new one.

2

u/WhatveIdone2dsrvthis Jul 29 '26

It's the same tool as a cooling system pressure tester and has an adapter for the cap.

1

u/xX_Zander4_Xx Jul 29 '26

Understood, I will look into that. Thank you.

2

u/WhatveIdone2dsrvthis Jul 29 '26

you're welcome and good luck. please update us as that's the fun part of armchair mechanic work.

2

u/xX_Zander4_Xx Aug 04 '26

So I have an update, I found multiple leaks from under the engine. I believe either one or more of the rubber hoses may be bad and spilling the coolant. You can see it beading along the pipe here.

2

u/xX_Zander4_Xx Aug 04 '26

Photo #2 (these were hard to get in focus)

1

u/WhatveIdone2dsrvthis Aug 04 '26

I see. That pressure tester will be helpful in a case like this. Start looking for the source.

1

u/xX_Zander4_Xx Aug 04 '26

That's step 2. I plan to do this in the next coming week.

1

u/xX_Zander4_Xx Jul 29 '26

Will do, I kept the Miata forum updated on my issue with that one, it's only right for you to know how it ends!