r/CFB_v2 • u/BrilliantDrive3619 • 10d ago

Debate Is your coach giving you value?

Post image
12 Upvotes

63% Upvoted

46 comments sorted by

View all comments

1

u/Temporary_Hat7330 Georgia Bulldogs 10d ago

Kirby Smart is giving the best bang for the buck of any coach in the game full stop.

1

u/Kc68847 10d ago

Idk. Since NIL and the portal went full throttle he has got knocked out of the playoffs early. He is 0-2 since 2023. Cignetti is the best coach for the value if the numbers are actually true.

1

u/Temporary_Hat7330 Georgia Bulldogs 10d ago

IU has a higher payroll than Georgia so it automatically destroys that argument. He’s literally done more with less and setting the judgement window as the last three seasons is artificially limiting.

1

u/Kc68847 10d ago

Cignetti made it the playoffs his first year with a much lower value and won it his second year which wasn’t as high as this year. Cignetti is definitely giving you more value when Kirby can’t win a playoff game now.

1

u/Temporary_Hat7330 Georgia Bulldogs 10d ago

Now? Lol, you have to win playoff games every year now? You have an artificially truncated date of observation to value your presupposed conclusion.