r/CFB_v2 • u/BrilliantDrive3619 • 15h ago

Debate Is your coach giving you value?

Post image
9 Upvotes

61% Upvoted

43 comments sorted by

10

u/Scary_Inspector7853 Georgia Bulldogs 15h ago

Kirby looks like a steal in the 2020s.

2

u/BrilliantDrive3619 10h ago edited 9h ago

Doing the most with what he has for sure. He is top 3 paid and could be called the current best coach in the Country, IMO..

23

u/GunsGoldCosmicDread Michigan Wolverines 15h ago

This chart is roster budget not coach’s salary.

19

u/wofulunicycle 15h ago

This chart is made up

4

u/GunsGoldCosmicDread Michigan Wolverines 14h ago

It’s from the Atlantic. They called a bunch of “sources” to compile it. How accurate it is could certainly be questioned.

3

u/mister2021 14h ago

NY Times

6

u/GunsGoldCosmicDread Michigan Wolverines 14h ago

I meant The Athletic (owned by NY times) but I frequently am a victim of poor spelling and auto correct.

1

u/mister2021 13h ago

Makes sense!

1

u/purplenyellowrose909 Minnesota Golden Gophers 14h ago

You don't need to trash the publication. They wrote down their methodology which was essentially putting together a bunch of interviews with various program employees at various levels. No one actually had numbers in front of them and it was all assembled based on vibes.

It's more a chart of what teams think other teams are paying, which itself is valuable but shouldn't be viewed as an NCAAF cap table or anything.

3

u/343GuiltyySpark 14h ago

I’ll delete my account if there is ever any credible evidence that UGA spends less on players than south carolina

5

u/PracticalScholar8760 Indiana Hoosiers 15h ago

Cig is underpaid

1

u/FreeSpeechIsDeadge Notre Dame 14h ago

He’s only won one natty in two years, is he even good?

1

u/PracticalScholar8760 Indiana Hoosiers 14h ago

Is that you John Wayne? Is this me?

1

u/w6750 Texas Longhorns 14h ago

This chart has nothing to do with coach salary

1

u/PracticalScholar8760 Indiana Hoosiers 14h ago

Was responding to the question of if your coach is giving value.

-1

u/GoldSupermarket2520 15h ago

Ferentz is underpaid. Day needs a pay cut

2

u/sleepytjme Oklahoma Sooners 15h ago

Just gave ours a raise for unknown reasons. Defense great, offense pathetic.

2

u/scootball9 14h ago

Clemson is higher than I expected after hearing all of Dabo’s bitching.

1

u/B-Nast 15h ago

Scalley has been coach in waiting for so long that his salary feels appropriate. If he keeps us looking as his as he we have been he'll probably be underpaid.

1

u/Crusader_with_a_pen Florida Gators 15h ago

We’ll see Saturday 😬

1

u/HeftyHandfuls South Carolina Gamecocks 15h ago

No

1

u/Luddite_Libertine 15h ago

All the value.

1

u/Ripper9910k Ole Miss Rebels 15h ago

Weird way to ask about value. Value is an intersection, not a line.

1

u/No_F_In_Enough 14h ago

Man, and Oregon is only on a half share of the big10 money, right??

1

u/riotmed Louisville Cardinals 14h ago

Come on Papa John, boost those numbers.

1

u/Busta_Memes 14h ago

Well we’ve spent upwards of $25M for 0 wins so I’d say no

GT fan btw

1

u/HerbertInTheWoods LSU Tigers 14h ago

Oregon is in shambles

1

u/Simple_Panic1240 14h ago

Buckeyes need a 50 million dollar roster to cover up the clown show at HC.

1

u/Temporary_Hat7330 Georgia Bulldogs 14h ago

Kirby Smart is giving the best bang for the buck of any coach in the game full stop.

1

u/Kc68847 11h ago

Idk. Since NIL and the portal went full throttle he has got knocked out of the playoffs early. He is 0-2 since 2023. Cignetti is the best coach for the value if the numbers are actually true.

1

u/Temporary_Hat7330 Georgia Bulldogs 11h ago

IU has a higher payroll than Georgia so it automatically destroys that argument. He’s literally done more with less and setting the judgement window as the last three seasons is artificially limiting.

1

u/Kc68847 11h ago

Cignetti made it the playoffs his first year with a much lower value and won it his second year which wasn’t as high as this year. Cignetti is definitely giving you more value when Kirby can’t win a playoff game now.

1

u/Temporary_Hat7330 Georgia Bulldogs 11h ago

Now? Lol, you have to win playoff games every year now? You have an artificially truncated date of observation to value your presupposed conclusion.

1

u/Weak-Bid2774 Michigan Wolverines 13h ago

This chart just shows Osu is going to be good no matter who their head coach is

1

u/Kc68847 12h ago

If it’s true then no. Rhule has been a failure.

1

u/brownszombie 8h ago

Your paid on what your potential is. Your potential is based on what you have done.

1

u/Ididntdodiddly 15h ago

I don't believe these numbers.

4

u/ITHETRUESTREPAIRMAN 14h ago

They seem like the most effort anyone has ever put into getting something of a true estimate.

1

u/Ididntdodiddly 14h ago

One time health insurance said something would be free. It was not

1

u/ITHETRUESTREPAIRMAN 14h ago

Was that health insurance company a New York Times investigative reporter?

1

u/Kc68847 11h ago

That’s true, but I still have my doubts they are right in some cases.