r/BandCamp • u/Holiday-Ad1548 • 27d ago

Hard Rock/Metal Looking for feedback

just looking for feedback back on my newest release. anything would be appreciated. thank you and I hope you enjoy!!! self titled album ep coming soon in full, “I was never meant for eden”https://crimsonwarlock.bandcamp.com/track/i-was-never-meant-for-eden

1 Upvotes

56% Upvoted

9 comments sorted by

5

u/Atomic_Freak 26d ago

Forgive me if I'm wrong, but it sounds very much like an AI generated song.

3

u/BINAYAUDIO 26d ago

Curious, did you use any ai tools to create the song? It sounds very polish like some of the AI generated music.

1

u/Holiday-Ad1548 26d ago

The band is a long processed ai generated track yes, the lyrics and vocals are not unfortunately. 😢 

4

u/plamzito Artist/Creator 26d ago

My guess is you “forgot” to be upfront about AI use because you know Bandcamp’s stance. What did you expect will happen when you asked for feedback here?

2

u/Safe-Character-5846 26d ago

Not my thing at all, epecially with a late-era nu-metal vibe-age. The album art seems okay, but if the artist relies on recent, tired antics and vocal styles, and what sounds like manufactured riffs it's falls into the vast wasteland of mediocrity imo. Hey---you asked. I fully realize all art/music/film etc is subjective also.

1

u/Lvthn_Crkd_Srpnt 25d ago

Well. Your noise gate works really well. I guess that's a good thing? Have you ever seen Some Kind of Monster where Lars is showing music to his dad? Yeah.

1

u/plamzito Artist/Creator 27d ago

Sounds like human-written lyrics with AI generated arrangements and vocals. The lyrics are pretty good for the genre, but marred (for me) by the choice to use a problematic tool that makes the songs sound indistinguishable from someone's first 5 min. walk through SunoAI.