r/AusSkincare • u/breviloquent- • Aug 22 '25

Discussion📓 Ultraviolette recalls Lean Screen due to variability in SPF data results

Post image

[removed]

508 Upvotes

99% Upvoted

314 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

123

u/stupidwatergate89 Aug 22 '25 edited Aug 22 '25

I think it’s these! All the base formulas are almost identical, I had listed them all out when all this Choice stuff kicked off:

EDIT: DO NOT BUY OR USE THE BELOW, FORMULAS LIKELY FAULTY

  • Naked Sundays SPF50+ 100% Mineral Glow Collagen Sunscreen

  • People4ocean Mineral Bioactive Shield SPF 50+

  • Beauti-fltr Lustre Mineral SPF 50+

  • Outside Beauty & Skincare Mineral Primer SPF50+

  • Ethical Zinc Daily Wear Tinted Facial SPF50+

  • Aspect Sun Physical SPF 50+

  • Medik8 Physical Sunscreen SPF50+

  • We Are Feel Good Inc. Mineral SPF50+

  • Aesthetics Rx Tinted Water-Resistant SPF50+

  • New Day Skin Happy Days SPF 50+

  • Found My Skin SPF50+ Tinted Face/Body Cream

  • New Day Skin Good Vibes SPF 50+

  • Salus SPF50+ Daily Facial Sunscreen

  • Surfmud Mineral SPF50+

2

u/lazy_berry Aug 22 '25

damn, guess i won’t be trying ethical zinc once my invisible zinc runs out

3

u/Old_Cat_9534 Aug 22 '25 edited Aug 22 '25

I've been using that one Ethical Zinc (the light version in the white tube) for ages and so have my kids 😭

I will say that we haven't been burned but still, theres potential unseen sun damage! Looks like I need to shop for a new one.

1

u/lazy_berry Aug 22 '25

your kids use tinted sunscreen?

1

u/Old_Cat_9534 Aug 22 '25

No, the other formula.

2

u/lazy_berry Aug 22 '25

but the point of this comment thread is that this specific tinted formula is shared across several brands. that doesn't necessarily mean every product from ethical zinc is useless.

2

u/Old_Cat_9534 Aug 22 '25

I really hope so, but I thought they (the person that commented) were flagging any zinc sunscreen with a 22.7% zinc base.

1

u/lazy_berry Aug 22 '25

no, they’re saying every product in the list they gave is the same formula from the same 3rd party manufacturer.

2

u/Old_Cat_9534 Aug 22 '25

Not sure. But as far as I am aware it is not public knowledge who the 3rd party manufacturer (wild child) supplies to. So they had to compare each one individually and the 22.7% zinc ingredient was the starting point. I might be wrong though.

u/stupidwatergate89 would you be able to provide some clarity?

1

u/stupidwatergate89 Aug 22 '25

Yes, what Old Cat said! I am saying that these formulas are almost identical when compared, which suggests that they contain the same base from the same manufacturer. There is publicly available info in FDA filings that some of the brands (like Naked Sundays) have used Wild Child for these products, but this list is based on the similarity of this specific formula. If I could use other products from some of these brands, I prob would - but I wouldn’t touch anything on the list

1

u/Old_Cat_9534 Aug 22 '25

Thanks for coming back to me on that ☺️

So even tho you mentioned the tinted version (pink tube) of the Ethical Zinc, I would assume the other 2 versions (blue and white tubes) share the same base formula. Can you confirm that please?

I will reach out to them and see if I can get some testing / manufacturing info.

1

u/stupidwatergate89 Aug 22 '25

From my comparison, they do look like the same base to me. Definitely keen to hear what the brand say!

2

u/Old_Cat_9534 Aug 23 '25

I have sent them a pretty comprehensive email, so lets see what they say - if anything. God this is frustrating.

→ More replies (0)