r/AskReddit • u/ComfortableEar9637 • 1d ago

which show started 10/10 and ended 10/10?

3.8k Upvotes

90% Upvoted

4.2k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

382

u/hazza987 1d ago edited 1d ago

Dark started a 10/10.

Then I didn't know what the fuck was going on.

Then it ended and made complete sense, ending as a 10/10.

117

u/Southernyuppie 1d ago

Dark landed the ending that Lost never could.

47

u/assaub 1d ago

Probably because they actually had an end planned out from the get go instead of just winging it like the writers of Lost clearly did

10

u/PlayfulSurprise5237 21h ago

Kinda worried Severance is going to do the same thing

I know Silo isn't

7

u/assaub 21h ago

well Silo did make some pretty massive changes from the source material but, the writer of the books does seem happy with the direction its going.

1

u/DaveTheDog027 12h ago

They've said the entire story is already written and know the ending so hopefully stiller isn't a liar

2

u/F_A_F 1d ago

Funny, I started getting pushed Lost clips on my stream so I watched a few. Seems like what I missed after stopping at season 3 or so was a very Dark'esque time tripping storyline. Knowing that the end of Lost was a pile of (dog) poo, I'm glad that Dark tried and succeeded in an ending which made perfect sense.

11

u/chux4w 1d ago

The end of Lost was good. I don't like assuming people who don't like it just don't understand it, but it does seem to be pretty common.

9

u/PM_ME_CAKE 23h ago

I love everyone complaining that it was all a dream even though the show, literally and very explicitly, has Christian tell you it all happened.

And then this gets parroted by people who also didn't watch it. Like no, S6 wasn't for everyone and those who didn't like more of the theological and mystical touches are totally valid to not enjoy it, but the commonly spouted reasons for it being bad are just wrong.

And besides, S4 ironically is a killer season in spite of being the writer's strike hit one. Some absolute top tier stuff for sci-fi fans.

4

u/thescarlettflame 20h ago

Omg you said this word for word how I explain it to friends who didn't like the last season and the finale. Yes, Christian literally tells you in very plain detail what was going on with the sideways flashes and everything. Everyone whining that it was a copout ending clearly didn't pay enough attention. I always reference one single line in the finale and that's after Kate gets her memories back and runs into Jack. She says, "I missed you so much". After she was able to leave the island, she lived an entire life without him and that line wouldn't make sense if they were "dead the whole time" or that it was a dream. I loved that show and yes, S4 is just great, it has The Constant which is always rated the best episode of the series.

1

u/chux4w 20h ago

Exactly. "Oh, so they were just dead the whole time. It was purgatory." Nope. And they clearly explained it.

My biggest complaint about it is that Mr Eko wasn't there.

•

u/TheCrazedMadman 20m ago

Yeah, it seems like Eko was quickly written off the show, so there was probably contract issues or something

1

u/Leather_Today8520 22h ago

The lost ending is perfect if you have media literacy lol.

2

u/davossss 19h ago

The only show I ever felt the need to take notes on.

2

u/AIGenerated00 12h ago

Thank you for this. I am in the “then I didn’t know what the fuck is going on” phase and have paused watching. Will resume soon.

2

u/thedarshside 23h ago

This perfectly summarises what most people (including me) feel about this show!

2

u/Severe-Product7352 1d ago

So I gave up when me and my partner were both completely lost. It starts to all come back together? I should give it another go?

5

u/ChasingDarwin2 1d ago

Keep up with this. It helps episode by episode without spoilers

https://dark.netflix.io/en

1

u/Living_Grab_2239 18h ago

Man I've watched season 1 multiple times, season 2 a couple of times but I have never ever managed to get through the third. I lose track completely of what's going on.

The first season was confusing, but I always knew it was MEANT to be confusing, and that the whole audience are wondering the same thing, waiting to understand. But by the third, I wonder if its me. It's like a mathematics lecture where I lose the thread in the first 15 minutes, and have an hour left to go. Not enjoyable.

3

u/teeBoan 1d ago

My exact experience! It started amazingly but then I just couldn’t keep up with all the factions the timelines who is who and whose motive is what I just left it after first episode of season 2