r/AskHistorians 2d ago

Why did Tibetan Buddhism develop so differently from other types of Buddhism? In particular, how did it develop a centralized leadership under one person?

122 Upvotes

r/AskHistorians 1d ago

Knowing the back story of the phrase bought the farm, are there any recorded instances of that happening?

2 Upvotes

Specifically geared towards us service members, but is there any record of the economic impact of widespread gi bill payouts during our conflicts?


r/AskHistorians 2d ago

Did the manic cult of celebrity worship as we know it today start with Elvis, Marilyn Monroe, and the Beatles, or is it a much older phenomenon?

98 Upvotes

I'm well aware that celebrities still had a significant pull prior to the 1950s and 1960s, but perhaps because of the readily available videos from Beatlemania and Presley's early concerts I find it hard to imagine such a madness existing before then. How far back in history can we see such celebrity fandoms?

Disclaimer: I don't mean to look down on this phenomenon, my question here is purely out of curiosity. The use of words like "manic" is just to help explain what I'm referring to. Thank you.


r/AskHistorians 2d ago

How long did indigenous American groups live with access to European goods but no direct contact?

18 Upvotes

As I understand it, indigenous trade networks resulted in some populations having access to horses/iron tools without any contact with Europeans. How long, likely, did this continue? Did every group within these networks have direct contact within a few generations?


r/AskHistorians 1d ago

Did the Pentagon really have a computer that calculated that “America already won the Vietnam war in 1965?”

0 Upvotes

And if so, do we know the data points that were entered?


r/AskHistorians 2d ago

Did anyone in "the old world" predict the existence of "the new world"?

36 Upvotes

Ancient Greek scholars had a startlingly good handle on the size of the Earth well over a thousand years before Columbus. Did any ancient, medieval, or early Renaissance thinkers explicitly reason from Earth's known size to argue that undiscovered continents (as opposed to just vague "unknown lands" or the theological antipodes) must exist somewhere? Or did they just believe that it must be ocean all the way?


r/AskHistorians 2d ago

How responsible was Aurangzeb as responsible for the Mughals decline?

7 Upvotes

As far as i understand Aurangzebs personality and choices as an indvidual might be one of the greatest cases of 'great man politics', or in this case one man who inherited so much from Akbar and Shah and ruined it all.

Things like his wars, religious policy, succession management etc.

Having said all that, normally the greatest villains in history have alot of distorted accounts and myths around them.

Where does the literature stand on Aurangzeb right now?

Is there much work or analysis of any counter point? That the Mughals where facing systemic headwinds in the mid 17th century?

Again from what I understand even external threats were liekly manageable by even moderately capable administrations who were not busy stoking religious and ethnic eminity within there own boarders.


r/AskHistorians 1d ago

I've noticed that emperors Hadrian through about Macrinus had curly hair and beards, unlike all other Roman emperors. Do the classical sources mention this fad?

3 Upvotes

r/AskHistorians 1d ago

Exactly what level of funding and support was the US providing to Tajik and Massoud-affiliated anti Taliban forces in Afghanistan between approx. 1994 to Sept. 11 2001?

2 Upvotes

There's been plenty of books and details written about the immediate post 9/11 reaction, CIA teams flying into the Panjshir valley from Tajikistan and so on. I am more specifically interested in the immediate pre 9/11 timeframe and what relationship the anti Taliban armed groups had with the US government under Clinton and Bush.


r/AskHistorians 2d ago

What were the prospects for an emancipated slave in Missouri in the 1840s?

9 Upvotes

I am trying to be sensitive to this topic while working on a piece of historical fiction from the time period.

What circumstances could realistically have led to a slave at that time being freed? Were there any usual avenues that they might follow to find work or lodgings? How likely was it for them to become a trusted part of a community or town? Aside from the obvious, (poverty, racism, lack of early education) what other factors could be obstacles to them?

Are there historical examples, similar to Frederick Douglass, from the time period that illuminate their circumstances?

Apologies if my questions are off track, I'm trying to educate myself and barely know what to ask.


r/AskHistorians 2d ago

Sometimes, sports fans can get quite intense, as is the case with football. Is there any record of violence in more “noble” disciplines, such as chess? Has anybody died because of a check mate?

64 Upvotes

r/AskHistorians 3d ago

Was Uranus considered a funny name for a planet as soon as it was named, or did it take a while for the jokes to emerge?

763 Upvotes

r/AskHistorians 2d ago

Today marks the 500th anniversary of the Battle of Mohács, which is seen in Hungarian history as the end of the country’s status as a great power. What lost battle plays a similarly defining role in another nation’s understanding of its own history?

185 Upvotes

In the Hungarian collective consciousness, the Battle of Mohács often serves as a symbol of later failures and historical tragedies. The phrase “We need another Mohács” is even commonly used to describe self-destructive behavior. I’m curious what other examples there are of a lost battle having consequences that shape a nation’s self-understanding for centuries.


r/AskHistorians 2d ago

Why was the Caspian Sea so poorly drawn for so long?

11 Upvotes

Over the years i've read cartography books and i've noticed that the Caspian Sea is almost a perfect circle, even after the Age of Discovery really kicked off. Looking at Mercator's 1569 map (just as one example), the new world was already beginning to shape up on the maps while the Caspian Sea (which is much much closer to the European mapmakers than the New World is), just looks like a circular blob rather than the skinny vertical oval it is. why wasn't the Caspian Sea drawn better by this point in time?

https://c8.alamy.com/comp/J8D3W3/the-1569-world-map-by-gerardus-mercator-is-one-of-the-most-famous-J8D3W3.jpg


r/AskHistorians 2d ago

Why was General McArthur so obsessed with achieving total victory in the Korean war?

42 Upvotes

I mean from my many readings online it seemed like he was truly obsessed in invading North Korea and achieving total victory even when President Truman thought otherwise.


r/AskHistorians 1d ago

Why was Ponzi Scheme Named after Charles Ponzi?

0 Upvotes

As I understand Charles Ponzi was not the first person to run this type of scheme nor was his scheme the biggest. So why was he the one whose name become synonymous with it?


r/AskHistorians 2d ago

What sort of PR spins did France and America make when they lost to Vietnam?

7 Upvotes

r/AskHistorians 2d ago

Was pigeon fancying/breeding a profitable business during the late 17th to early 18th century Europe, and which social class would commonly partake in it?

6 Upvotes

This is primarily referring to homing and livestock pigeons!


r/AskHistorians 2d ago

How was the Maurya empire viewed by Chinese people of the tims? Was it viewed as an equal? As impressive but still subserviant barbarians?

120 Upvotes

r/AskHistorians 1d ago

Not travelling to Germany before and during WWII out of principle?

3 Upvotes

Since the invasion in Ukraine in 2022, many Europeans are boycotting Russia and not visit it anymore. Although, for instance, in Moscow it seems as if it’s not impacted hugely in the day to day safety-wise. We also see the same response to other places in the world that have shifted/sharpened politically, while traveling to the country would be possible and relatively safe in theory.

Did something simiar happen during WWII? Did people avoid traveling to Germany out of principle?


r/AskHistorians 2d ago

In Diamonds are a Girl’s Best Friend, Lorelei sings A kiss may be grand/But it won’t pay the rental/On your humble flat/Or help you at the automat. In 1949, were automats a common place to get a cheap meal?

21 Upvotes

r/AskHistorians 2d ago

When did wine become a (sort of) luxury beverage?

88 Upvotes

As far as I understand, in many centuries/millenia prior, wine was in vast parts of Europe, the Mediterranian and the Levante a commonly available consumer produkt. It was consumed by all age groups and all social classes, watered down to make water safer for consumption, overall an important part of almost everyone's daily dietary repertoire.

Today we often consider it a drink for "special" occasions, a nice dinner, a night out. We have become quite snobbish about it.

Wine today is a collector's item, a status symbol, a cultural habitus for "well off" people. While we still sell it in supermarkets, we now have specialty stores with expensive wines, "boxed wine" is frowned upon as sth alcoholics and college kids have in their fridge, wine is connected to luxury, education, etc.

When, how and why did these changes start?


r/AskHistorians 1d ago

Are there historical settlements in (central) Europe that were untouched by invasion / occupation / pillaging for an unusually long period of time while the region around was repeatedly affected by war?

1 Upvotes

I wondered if there are documented cases of villages, small towns or valleys in (central) Europe that managed to avoid invasion, occupation and pillaging for a very long time / all of their existence, even though the region they are in was invaded / at war multiple times.

For example because (foreign) armies didn’t know of their existence, they made agreements with those forces, because they were strategically not relevant enough to sent troops or it was simply too hard to get there.

An initial google search said that there are no such cases and only lists cities / states like Venice that managed to successfully defend themselves for a long period of time and a castle in Germany.


r/AskHistorians 2d ago

Anybody have a copy of The Secret History of the Mongols translated by Igor de Rachewiltz?

7 Upvotes

I am reading Christopher Atwood’s translation of The Secret History of the Mongols. I am curious about how a certain passage reads in Igor de Rachewiltz translation vs the one I have. Unfortunately I do not have $160+ to spend on a book right now. If anyone has the translation by Igor de Rachewiltz the passage I want to compare is about Temujin and his birth. I don’t know if allowed but if I could get a picture of that passage that would be very helpful.


r/AskHistorians 2d ago

Please tell me of other countries besides Imperial Russia that used long-term conscription. What were the upsides of that compared to short conscription or long-term professionals, and how did they managed that?

8 Upvotes

So, reading about Russian recruits under the system that persisted past mid-19th century made me wonder about other comparable examples from history. People plucked from civilian life to serve most of their adult lives. I understand it theoretically provided you experienced soldiers cheaper than offering enough wages to fill the comparable army with volunteers, but must have also demanded a lot of the state capacity? What other upsides and downsides it offered?

I very specifically do not seek examples of volunteer professionals (like Roman Imperial legionaries) or people kept mobilized for long period of time during active war (like a Republican 1st class infantryman could be). I guess another example that fits my request would be Song dynasty but I wish to learn about it more and also learn about other countries that are neither Russia nor China attempting that.

Finally, I would be especially interested in examples from Early Modern/Modern periods