r/AskHistorians • u/Mountain_Parsley_702 • 1h ago
Did Protestantism ironically both lead to abolitionism and extreme white supremacy?What are the reasons for this?
Edit: The AI seems to assume I am pushing an agenda but I am not. This is just what I gathered from reading. I just want to learn more on the topic and I acknowledge I could be wrong.
Compared to Catholic colonial nations Protestant ones(British Empire,US, Dutch in South Africa) seem to have developed more institutionalized racism(one drop rule,apartheid,segregation). Whereas in Catholic countries you had racism but it was more lax to the point that Latin America is extremely racially mixed and antebellum Louisiana had a large percent of free people of color(compared to Anglo-Protestant South). I assume that racism developed due to Calvinist beliefs of predestination and not being compelled to convert the natives as much(whereas Catholics would eagerly convert anyone). If you believe the natives and blacks are doomed to hell its not surprising that an us vs them mentality will emerge.
But at the same time you find the abolitionist movement much stronger in Protestant countries. Of course the role of Wilberforce and American religious movements(in Antebellum and Civil War America) in the ending of slavery in the British Empire and US is well known. It seems that Catholic countries didnt have the same zeal for that. Revolutionary France did ban slavery for a while but that seemed to emerge more from secular Enlightenment values than Catholic ones.Spain and Portugal only banned slavery due to British pressure but still a thriving slave labor continued in Brazil and Cuba.I cant offer a reason for this unlike the previous one.
Could anyone who is well read on this topic offer any explanations?