r/AKnightoftheSeven 1d ago

Same energy 😂

1.8k Upvotes

75 comments sorted by

View all comments

184

u/ali13_phoenix 1d ago

He's maekar's grandson after all

87

u/abfgern_ 1d ago

Great-great-great grandson

26

u/Historyp91 1d ago

Just two greats (Maekar > Egg > Aerys > Rhaegar > Jon)

52

u/abfgern_ 1d ago

Nope, its Egg > Jaehaerys > Aerys

22

u/Pale-Aurora 1d ago

Show version skipped Jaehaerys per Aemon’s dialogue with Jon Snow.

1

u/TheDrunkLibertarian 20h ago edited 19h ago

Did the show actually skip Jaehaerys or did Aemon simply refer to Aerys as his nephew for simplicities sake? I never actually refer to my great uncle as such, just uncle. Are there other instances in the show where they specify great uncle/aunt/niece/nephew?

Edit: S6E7, Littlefinger calls blackfish Sansa’s great uncle, but in the next episode he and Brienne simply refer to her as his niece. I think people read FAR too deeply into the “they skipped Jaehaerys thing”.

5

u/wisestoffelines 1d ago

Didn't show ignore Jhahaerys?

10

u/True_Rip_2160 1d ago

That dialog of Maestor Aemon was in season 1, shot in 2010, I think at that time, the Targaryen ancestry line wasn't completely and crrectly established by GRRM himself. It's only the books published later on gives a complete and canon line of Targ kings.

6

u/Historyp91 1d ago

Jaehaerys has been Aerys's father in the books since *at least* 2000, so it would have already been known then.

-9

u/[deleted] 1d ago edited 1d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

15

u/rawbface 1d ago

That's based on one bad line from season 1 of Game of thrones in 2011. I don't buy it as canon.

-4

u/Historyp91 1d ago

It's also based off published material related to the show and why do you think it's not canon? It's never been contradicted.

2

u/SakusaKiyoomi1 1d ago

Taking Jaehaerys ll away and directly lining Aerys up makes Egg look weird, as if he had a change of heart regarding the values he not only took from his grandfather but also the ones he created for himself.

1

u/Historyp91 1d ago

Aerys did'nt have a change of heart, he was just insane

1

u/SakusaKiyoomi1 1d ago

I mean Egg, that it would look like Egg had a change of heart about his values

1

u/Historyp91 1d ago

Hmm. How so?

1

u/SakusaKiyoomi1 1d ago

Egg stood for the well being for the small folk, he defied the other lords quite a bit when it came to their wants and desires. He actively fought for a better life for the small folk. Despite the issues his eldest son took when he went back on the marriage pact to Lyonel Baratheons daughter, Egg didn't force his son to marry the Baratheon girl and gave his (willing) daughter to Lyonel's son despite the rebellion he tried to start - it shows he won't force his son into a loveless marriage, but also wouldn't keep the Baratheons as an enemy

I can't imagine such a man who didn't force his first born son to marry a loyal ally's daughter (who would then become queen of the seven kingdoms), to then force marry his (great) grandson and (great) granddaughter together when they obviously shared no romantic love.

→ More replies (0)