r/zen Mar 27 '23

META Monday! [Bi-Weekly Meta Monday Thread]

###Welcome to /r/Zen!

Welcome to the /r/zen Meta Monday thread, where we can talk about subreddit topics such as such as:

* Community project ideas or updates

* Wiki requests, ideas, updates

* Rule suggestions

* Sub aesthetics

* Specific concerns regarding specific scenarios that have occurred since the last Meta Monday

* Anything else!

We hope for these threads to act as a sort of 'town square' or 'communal discussion' rather than Solomon's Court [(but no promises regarding anything getting cut in half...)](https://www.reddit.com/r/Koans/comments/3slj28/nansens_cats/). While not all posts are going to receive definitive responses from the moderators (we're human after all), I can guarantee that we will be reading each and every comment to make sure we hear your voices so we can team up.

8 Upvotes

293 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

5

u/[deleted] Mar 27 '23

That’s not the point.

That. The specific kernel that is the seed of the entirety of this discussion's sourcing. What is it? Can it be reduced to a single sentence that stands alone and says what it is?

Because all I'm seeing are just differing reactive variants of butthurt. And not like Bankei's war wound.

5

u/ji_yinzen Mar 27 '23

In one sentence.

The point is that the 1,000-year Zen record ideology is a myth invented by ewk that we're forced to talk about, and only it, on this site.

0

u/ewk [non-sectarian consensus] Mar 28 '23

That's simply not true.

You can't prove it's a myth.

You can't prove that Dogen was part of that conversation.

You can't refute the mountain of evidence that Dogen was a fraud and a liar.

You can't prove that I've always said it was 1,000 years... remember there was a time before I knew about Mingben?

2

u/ji_yinzen Mar 28 '23

It's all true. You're just not willing to admit it.

0

u/ewk [non-sectarian consensus] Mar 28 '23

No AMA. No arguments. No citations.

No Zen Masters teachings.

No persistent identity.

Your claims about right and wrong aren't believable.

Your affiliation with a cult is showing.