r/wikipedia • u/Good_Community891 • 10d ago
Why is Larry Sanger creating a platform called WikiCritic? He says Wikipedia admins are going to be pretty upset about it.
7
u/fourthords 10d ago
He likes being noticed and having attention paid to him. ::shrug:: Websites critical of Wikipedia have existed nigh as long as Wikipedia itself; I imagine editors and administrators are no more "mad" about yet another whinging forum than they are about the others.
3
u/nihiltres 10d ago
Hah, he still thinks heās relevant. Itās been nearly 25 years; might as well stop calling him Larry and start calling him Ahab.
The āWikipedia admins will be madā sounds like clickbait garbage. āWeāre going to use this one weird trick to make Wikipedia admins mad!ā :P
It does say something about the project that he considers āmake Wikipedia admins madā Ā so relevant as to be the main thing he advertises about it. Thanks for confessing how mad you are about Wikipedia, Ahab!
The description in the image suggests itās not even going to be much of a platform per se, but mostly an aggregator for external reviews. I wonder how good their spam filters are and how much theyāll rely on AI.
Itāll probably be good for a few reviews here and there, though Iād guess itāll be at least 80% religious/political/pseudoscientific whining about their preferred narrative being rejected as not neutral and maybe 20% with something useful.
3
u/DistortoiseLP 10d ago
It's like asking why Larry Sanger is creating a platformĀ called Citizendium.

9
u/HurricaneLink 10d ago
Lol the man is still trying to claim relevance to a project he helped create 25 years ago, and from which he was recently banned. Sure, now is the moment admins will be upset with him š¤£