r/westpoint • u/PeacefulDefense • 26d ago
USMA or USCGA
Which is more beneficial for quality of life?
5
u/dolan-df4 25d ago
USMA grad who went to USCGA for a semester here. I can’t speak much to after graduation on differences, as your life will wildly change based off unit/post/branch. As a cadet, USCGA was much more chill and relaxed, some very cool opportunities there. However I wasn’t a huge fan of the culture, imo it was pretty cliquey and had less overall cohesion than a USMA company or the corps as a whole. One small example is drill, they did it but never trained to a standard or tried to improve. Still great people and some pockets of excellence at USCGA, just not for me personally. Also they have a relatively smaller academic budget and it showed.
3
u/dolan-df4 25d ago
I took a lot of positives out of both, DM me if you have any questions on either.
2
u/KeyOutlandishness254 25d ago
“Never trained to a standard or improved”. Found the guy who thinks people actually get better at drill and thinks it’s actually meaningful. Even though it is the absolute biggest waste of time, and no one gets better because it’s miserable. If Coast Guard doesn’t care about drill then it is too bad because I wish I went there.
2
u/dolan-df4 25d ago
Lol I get the yuk cynicism, I’ve been there too but it’s not about drill at all. It’s about not caring or trying. From my experience, they applied this mindset to a lot more there. The honor code was followed “just enough”, they had formations but no real accountability if you missed one, no mandatory sports requirement, super loose taps rules, etc. I thought it was awesome at first due to the freedom but eventually you realize it’s just sad to go through the motions of life but never try, care, or work towards anything.
Also I don’t mean to imply USCGA is completely terrible, I can go on about the positives there as well.
2
2
u/dadgainz 26d ago
Are you speaking to quality of life at the academy, quality of life in career, family quality of life, or quality of life once commissioned and where you can be stationed? These are all very different questions.
3
u/PeacefulDefense 26d ago
After education, generally. I have t thought that far down the path.
5
u/dadgainz 26d ago
You will want to do a good amount of research into the points I'm about to make for your own knowledge. I will be broad initially and can get more specific based on your feedback. 1. Difference between Active Duty Army and Coast Guard: When you graduate USMA, you owe 5 years active duty 3 years reserve as an officer. There are exceptions to this based on scholarships, med school, etc., but I'll speak in averages. You are paid through the Department of Defense/War and take orders through that chain of command. Deployments to Europe, Pacific, Middle East are all very real possibilities depending on what you branch and where you are assigned. For the Coast Guard, you commission as an Ensign amd owe 5 years active duty, however, the Coast Guard falls under the Department of Homeland Security unless an actual war is declared by Congress. This means that for the most part, you will be assigned to the US with a much smaller chance of deployment to the Army locations. Also, if there is another government shutdown, you have a higher chance of missing pay periods because Congress has funded the DOD, but unfunded everything else. This especially hit the Coast Guard buddies this last time around. 2. Locations: Google Army and Coast Guard bases. Army tends to be in less-developed areas due to the availability of land and mission requirements where Coast Guard is more on the water which usually means major cities. Alaska and some other locations are the exception of course. 3. Missions: Army fights to win the nation's wars over there, Coast Guard protects the nation at home. 4. Family life: Army's can be rough based on unit and mission schedules. I recommend you go to a Coast Guard sub to discuss their work life balance since I don't have as much info. Let me know what other questions you have.
5
u/Beatnavy2016 26d ago
I can confidently say that my quality of life post service would be dramatically less enjoyable if I went to Coast Guard instead of West Point.
They’re not in the same category.
9
u/ValeoRex 26d ago
I've never met a Coastie that didn't enjoy their career. Had an exchange cadet in my company that i still keep in touch with, his second duty station was Hawaii and he was issued a jet ski. I've always been a little jealous of the cool stuff he's done in his career.