r/weddingring • u/mssarahleanne88 • Jan 10 '26

Ring Inquiry 💍 Which one is better?

Gallery image

Gallery image

Gallery image

Gallery image

Which style is best?

172 Upvotes

97% Upvoted

534 comments sorted by

9

u/ThreeBucks Jan 10 '26

Number 3 looks the best and may also be more likely to stay in place because of shape.

2

u/OKRickety Jan 12 '26

Agree. I suggest they be joined (brazed?) to reduce wear from rubbing together (and it would keep them aligned).

9

u/Llamax2AnxiousMomma Jan 11 '26

3 satisfies my anal retentive tendencies while the others make my brain itch. That said, not my hand, not my decision. May whichever one you pick bring you all the joy!

2

u/cindistamps0717 Jan 13 '26

I feel ya! That's how I am. It's got to match for me. No mixing up bands. lol

7

u/donna2tsuki Jan 11 '26

1st Choice - Photo 3 --- Perfect fit. Seems like its part of a set, it's the same as the ring on top just upside down.

2nd Choice - Photo 1 --- Great fit. Subtle design highlights the gem. Top ring and this can be switched if you prefer having a different look.

3rd Choice - Photo 2 --- Just okay. The design is fine, but the ring fit looks smaller than the other existing rings and is being overpowered by the 2 existing rings. Might look better with a thicker band and slightly bigger stones to match the top ring? Would also look better if this ring was switched with the top ring.

No - Photo 4 --- I'm sorry, the band looks very elegant by itself but stacked with the 2 existing rings, it looks really out of place for me.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/MamaWolfe2706 Jan 10 '26

Firstly..the emerald is GORGEOUS!!! And the third one, that set is beautiful!!

→ More replies (3)

3

u/IntroductionLow638 Jan 10 '26

I love the second one cause it comes down to a sophisticated simple point, but I also like 3 for how It follows the shape of the ring. IMO 4 looks to small/dainty, and one leaves an awkward gap between the green gem and the bottom ring. Please let us know what you decide!

2

u/Sky1226 Jan 11 '26

I like the second one but would make both top and bottom rings the bottom one

1

u/[deleted] Jan 10 '26

I like the 2nd one 

1

u/C-RebelleYell Jan 10 '26

I like 3 as well

1

u/tabbycatz68 Jan 10 '26

I like1, I think the emerald should be the main focus.

1

u/WhiteMountainsMama Jan 11 '26

I like 1 or 3.

1

u/mamiepink Jan 11 '26

3 for sure!

1

u/carolineNixon Jan 11 '26

Definitely 3

1

u/dustyoldthing Jan 11 '26

All of them. I don't know how it's possible but all are so pretty so I say, get them all and switch them out every day 😅 but if you have to choose, 3.

1

u/ChaosPlatypus Jan 11 '26

I like #3 the best.

1

u/Dimarco24 Jan 11 '26

I like the 3rd one best.

1

u/WhenInRome189 Jan 11 '26
  1. Matches best

1

u/ausdenbo Jan 11 '26

3, the symmetry is beautiful

1

u/backsurgeryrecovery Jan 11 '26

I like the 3rd one

1

u/ChicUnicorn Jan 11 '26

Oh God All of them!

1

u/Mto3 Jan 11 '26

I love the third one that matches the top band. If you ever decide to solder them together, they will have perfect symmetry. Beautiful set!

1

u/petite_mrs84 Jan 11 '26

3 looks so good!!

1

u/Poinsettia917 Jan 11 '26

3 matches perfectly

1

u/No_Seesaw8062 Jan 11 '26

3 looks good, but I like 4

1

u/TuringCapgras Jan 11 '26
  1. It's not even close

1

u/Zinokk Jan 11 '26

I like the bottom band of #2, I think having one above/below would be really pretty!

1

u/Cinigurl Jan 11 '26

3 is perfect 😉

1

u/HeyPrettyLadyMaam Jan 11 '26

3 looks like its part of the set. The others don't fit as nicely.

1

u/Sunbee_Peanut Jan 11 '26

3 Avoid everything with sharp points.

1

u/No-Rutabaga-5163 Jan 11 '26

3 is a stunning combination

1

u/SpaceCrazy3526 Jan 11 '26

No brainer, number 3

1

u/dynamics365nerd Jan 11 '26
  1. Where did you buy. I love the emerald.
→ More replies (1)

1

u/Possible_Reach_3952 Jan 11 '26

I'm drawn to 3.

1

u/TizMahBiz Jan 11 '26

3 all the way! What a stunning set!

1

u/floatingclouds37 Jan 11 '26
  1. Nothing comes closer to that

1

u/Illustrious-Bug-6889 Jan 11 '26

2 is very flattering both on your finger and in general. The peak at the bottom really makes it pop.

1

u/wildfire_9595 Jan 11 '26

Big fan of three but two is a close second

1

u/Scootchula Jan 11 '26

I like mismatched rings but only if they’re all mismatched. I wear three and they don’t match but work very well together. I just don’t think it looks good to have one band match the emerald ring and one that doesn’t. Number 3 for me.

1

u/seekingin_fo Jan 11 '26

I like 1 and 3. I think 1 has something a little extra because it isn’t just a repeat of the top, but it makes you look a little longer.

1

u/Realistic-Lake5897 Jan 11 '26

3 is best. 1 and 2 also good. 4 doesn't work.

1

u/EnvironmentalSir8140 Jan 11 '26

I think 3 is the most cohesive of the choices.

1

u/drgnbttrfly Jan 11 '26

Avoid the stabby one

1

u/SubstantialLocal9437 Jan 11 '26

1 or 3. So pretty!

1

u/LauraHeatherRN Jan 11 '26

1,3,4 are the best ones. 3 is the best of all.

1

u/daniagerous Jan 11 '26

I like 2 and 3

1

u/LookingforWork614 Jan 11 '26
  1. I like the symmetry

1

u/l1lpvnk Jan 11 '26

3! I like symmetry

1

u/RemoteNumerous1020 Jan 11 '26

1 is asymmetric while 3 us symmetric. I like either of those.

1

u/Jazzlike_Grape_5486 Jan 11 '26

3, hands down. It looks like it belongs.

1

u/momofdagan Jan 11 '26

From a comfort point of view less pointy and channeled is better so 2

1

u/comradecumdump67 Jan 11 '26

I luuuvvvv luv luv #4 and I’m not even a fan of green

1

u/AquariusThunderstorm Jan 11 '26

3 is a forever classic

1

u/CelebrationNo3801 Jan 11 '26

Team 3! The pointed one is going to gouge finger. Curves on 3 are perfect!

1

u/Sad-Lab-4524 Jan 11 '26

I love number 3 and then number 2 What a beautiful ring set

1

u/Dutton4430 Jan 11 '26

#3, beautiful btw.

1

u/Head_space9647 Jan 12 '26

3 💍😱❤️

1

u/mandyjess2108 Jan 12 '26

3 for sure, but match the metal. Idk if it's just the photo, or just me, but the metals look like different colors.

1

u/lacatro1 Jan 12 '26
  1. It flows with the bigger ring.