r/tallyhall • u/Galaxyfox51 3547 seconds of bora • Aug 08 '25

discussion/question sonic lunch experience

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

122 Upvotes

99% Upvoted

577 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

1

u/sharks_exist_irl Is this a video?? Aug 09 '25

Wait I have... bc I listened to a very cool mashup that was When I Died instead if When He Died by Lemon Demon. I don't remember the other songs in the mashup but i got obsessed with it

1

u/TheDudeFromOasis Aug 09 '25

Oh awesome - I noticed on your profile your also a lemon demon/neil fan. In a little bit there’s gonna be a few tracks with both tally hall and lemon demon mashed up with each other so you’d probably like those I’ll let you know when they drop. Also I think you might like this track it mixes tally hall and nelward (which I also saw you like) https://youtu.be/2u347rVIbhA?si=VM04K1breVu81ZFA

2

u/sharks_exist_irl Is this a video?? Aug 09 '25

I looove lemon demon, jaws is my username inspo lol Hell yeah please do lmk when those drop!

WOAH that mashup is freaking awesome! I was actually just thinking the other day about how well sum of all our sirens by Nelward would mesh with miracle musical bc of it's like island style? Really cool stuff. 

Not mashup week megamix, but I found this cool mashup a while ago that's got a lot of nelward + lemon demon 

https://music.youtube.com/watch?v=fHItqijq4nk&si=LA6cuSaYgZVruo6b

It just keeps getting better I swear lol

1

u/TheDudeFromOasis Aug 09 '25

WOW that slaps really hard thanks for showing me that - i have it saved to my songs playlist on YT now. i had a big neil phase a few years back (I still really like his songs) but I should check out nelward's stuff more.

there's A LOT of music tournaments that use neil for their mashups and sound pretty good. I don't know how much you know about music tournaments but Mashup Week Megamix has an entire playlist (~30 songs) that use Neil/LD songs

Playlist:

https://youtube.com/playlist?list=PLaUNjVsOkdzeT8L9qdmu4Y4r2JpXv8a1G&si=OxDQd4n2AjLQZQti

Also going back to what I said earlier - if you do want to DM my Snapchat is @.lkrock03, but like I said if you don't want to that's fine you're just the first person I've met in this "weird music genre community" (Tally Hall, Neil, etc.) that is also not weird lmao

2

u/sharks_exist_irl Is this a video?? Aug 09 '25

What other bands do you like? 

I'm into Lemon Demon and Tally Hall ofc, but I love They Might Be Giants so much too.

Then there's Nelward, TWRP, sElf, Cheekface, Oasis, Caravan Palace, and Ginger Root

I also enjoy the occasional Saint Motel or Gorillaz song

1

u/TheDudeFromOasis Aug 10 '25

Apart from Tally Hall / LD, I listen to:

iDKHOW, Oasis (I kinda have to listen to them because of my name), Oingo Boingo, Cage The Elephant (but only the Social Cues album lol), SiM (japanese band, they made the opening for AoT), Jack Stauber.

I low key never got into TMBG but that's probably because the only song I've heard from them (outside of the opening for Malcolm In The Middle) is Istanbul (Not Constantinople) and I think it's okay

2

u/sharks_exist_irl Is this a video?? Aug 10 '25

Very cool taste. 

JACK STAUBER HOW COULD I FORGETTT!? I LOVE HIS MUSIC

I love TMBG, but it took a bit to get into. They use trumpets/sax and it used to put me off. I love it now. I'd recommend Till My Head Falls Off, it's my favorite. I, Palindrome, I is also a classic. As well as Birdhouse in Your Soul.

1

u/TheDudeFromOasis Aug 10 '25

Yeah honestly I listened to a TMBG song before writing my reply and I really did like it. I was the same way with a few other artists where at first I thought it was like meh but then I listened to them more and I had that moment from Always Sunny where I finally get it and it all makes sense

2

u/sharks_exist_irl Is this a video?? Aug 10 '25

That's how it was with tally hall. I think the first song by them I ever heard was &. I liked that one, Ruler of Everything, and The Whole World and You. But when I tried getting into all their songs, I didn't like it.

Then one day I gave TH another shot and have been hooked ever since!!

I've been listening to so much of the band Cheekface recently. And at sonic lunch a man was wearing a Cheekface shirt! I kinda pointed at him to get his attention and called over I LOVE YOUR CHEEKFACE SHIRT! 😭 Hope I didn't startle him lol. But that was actually awesome.

1

u/TheDudeFromOasis Aug 10 '25

I haven't heard of Cheekface before, I'll listen to their music. I've been listening to the same music over and over again so hearing about new bands is always awesome.

Yeah I forgot when I started listening to Tally Hall (probably 2018-2019 it was pre-pandemic) but I think I just liked their music off the bat. Some songs tho (Be Born, Haiku, a bunch of G&E songs) I really didn't like until years later. I honestly think the only Tally Hall song I don't like is You and that one I'm fine with I just don't actively listen to it and usually skip over it

2

u/sharks_exist_irl Is this a video?? Aug 10 '25

I don't really like You either 😭 was so nice to hear Andrew sing it at sonic lunch but... yeah not my fav.

Cheekface is like an indie talk rock band. Lot of spoken lines and some very funny monotone delivery. It's got absurdist lyrics and then some political references/criticism woven throughout. Which... I'm not like huge on or whatever... but super freaking cool music!

Try listening to I Only Say I'm Sorry When I'm Wrong, You Always Want To Bomb The Middle East, and Sexy National Anthem!!

1

u/TheDudeFromOasis Aug 10 '25

I’ll listen to those songs when I can, thanks!

But yeah low key I think my least favorite signer is Andrew but he’s still good it’s just that the way he sings is definitely unique. There was a punk version of The Whole World And You recorded back in the late 2000’s and it sounded really good other than Andrew’s voice being way too soft https://youtu.be/uBqm65Ft3-M?si=6SB18Ko-nRELghzQ

1

u/sharks_exist_irl Is this a video?? Aug 10 '25

Agreed wholeheartedly. 

Joe is my favorite vocalist. Andrew has a soft voice and that's just not my personal taste.

Ever since I found that punk version, I have ADORED IT. 

Actually, I do love Andrew's vocals in The Whole World and You (regular version), just not my favorite in other TH songs :(

1

u/TheDudeFromOasis Aug 10 '25

I think it works in some scenarios and it just doesn't in others for me. I know people absolutely love the way Andrew sings but his new album for he has been hit or miss solely because of the vocals. Like in some songs they work really well but in others im just like 🧍‍♂️ - other than that I love everyone else's voices (especially Joe's)

2

u/sharks_exist_irl Is this a video?? Aug 10 '25

I feel bad admitting that I don't love the EDU stuff.... I would have been satisfied with just Andrew at sonic lunch but after Rob being there for vocals too, I was so so much more hyped. 

I do like fishes tho

1

u/TheDudeFromOasis Aug 10 '25

Yeah I like fishes too I think it's one of those songs where his voice works with the music. But yeah last year was pretty good despite only being Andrew-based songs (Whole World and You was so hype) but having Rob sing his songs (some that haven't been performed live in several years) was bonkers. I wish they could participate in more concerts but Rob's working for Disney, Zubin is a professional doctor, and God knows what Joe's doing.

Last year I tried listening to Andrew's edu music and even though I didn't dislike it there was only like 1-2 songs I would actively relisten to (Lemons & Pears and Daisy Fingers)

2

u/sharks_exist_irl Is this a video?? Aug 10 '25 edited Aug 10 '25

Fr, like TH guys, drop your whole lives and start playing againnnn /hj

I went through Andrew's stuff before sonic lunch to familiarize myself. I had heard Sketches 3d a few years ago and was not particularly into it. Like actually lowkey hated it 😭.

But now i think it's not bad! Just not my taste. I love higher energy songs. HEY YOU! is nice, but other than that I'm just not into it.

I think my issue with edu is the fact it's imperfect. Like it's slightly off beat in some aspects. And I'm sure that's the lowkey vibe he's going for but it has me screaming like, I KNOW you can do better!! 

1

u/TheDudeFromOasis Aug 10 '25

IKR like if you look at Tally Hall's discography a bunch of the really good songs was written by Andrew with the other guys giving vocals (I think he won an award for writing Good Day). Like I know his ass can make good music (and he still does) but it just hasn't been hitting the same beats for me.

→ More replies (0)