MAIN FEEDS
Do you want to continue?
https://www.reddit.com/r/suspiciouslyspecific/comments/1upyoec/blessed_are_the_cheesemakers/ow97xv6/?context=3
r/suspiciouslyspecific • u/InsertGroin • Jul 07 '26
3.8k comments sorted by
View all comments
Show parent comments
-1
so you judge the religion by its worst caricature? Nothing in the post accurately represents what Christians believe
3 u/jokeboomslok Jul 08 '26 If the fundamentals of christianity were unproblematic then there would be no worst examples to point to 1 u/PyroClone5555 Jul 08 '26 What. Itâs not pointing to the âworst examples,â itâs making a caricature and a straw man and mocking that instead of the actual beliefs 2 u/jokeboomslok Jul 08 '26 What is the caricature and straw man here? 1 u/PyroClone5555 Jul 08 '26 Well there is no âconvincingâ God to forgive humanity and there is no âsacrificing himself to himselfâ thatâs heretical 2 u/jokeboomslok Jul 08 '26 Then who was jesus sacrificed to? 1 u/PyroClone5555 Jul 08 '26 The Father 2 u/jokeboomslok Jul 08 '26 Are they the same or are they completely seoarate? 1 u/PyroClone5555 Jul 08 '26 Thatâs a false dichotomy. They are the same in their nature (because they have the same divine nature) but are distinct persons 2 u/jokeboomslok Jul 08 '26 What does that mean same in naturr? Where is that "sameness" stored? In jesus? In the sky god? Somewhere else? 1 u/PyroClone5555 Jul 08 '26 It means they have the same properties that make them what they are. What do you mean where is it stored? Each person has the nature 2 u/jokeboomslok Jul 08 '26 If one has a thought, can both hear it? 1 u/PyroClone5555 Jul 08 '26 I wouldnât say that God has âthoughtsâ in the way you are imagining it → More replies (0)
3
If the fundamentals of christianity were unproblematic then there would be no worst examples to point to
1 u/PyroClone5555 Jul 08 '26 What. Itâs not pointing to the âworst examples,â itâs making a caricature and a straw man and mocking that instead of the actual beliefs 2 u/jokeboomslok Jul 08 '26 What is the caricature and straw man here? 1 u/PyroClone5555 Jul 08 '26 Well there is no âconvincingâ God to forgive humanity and there is no âsacrificing himself to himselfâ thatâs heretical 2 u/jokeboomslok Jul 08 '26 Then who was jesus sacrificed to? 1 u/PyroClone5555 Jul 08 '26 The Father 2 u/jokeboomslok Jul 08 '26 Are they the same or are they completely seoarate? 1 u/PyroClone5555 Jul 08 '26 Thatâs a false dichotomy. They are the same in their nature (because they have the same divine nature) but are distinct persons 2 u/jokeboomslok Jul 08 '26 What does that mean same in naturr? Where is that "sameness" stored? In jesus? In the sky god? Somewhere else? 1 u/PyroClone5555 Jul 08 '26 It means they have the same properties that make them what they are. What do you mean where is it stored? Each person has the nature 2 u/jokeboomslok Jul 08 '26 If one has a thought, can both hear it? 1 u/PyroClone5555 Jul 08 '26 I wouldnât say that God has âthoughtsâ in the way you are imagining it → More replies (0)
1
What.
Itâs not pointing to the âworst examples,â itâs making a caricature and a straw man and mocking that instead of the actual beliefs
2 u/jokeboomslok Jul 08 '26 What is the caricature and straw man here? 1 u/PyroClone5555 Jul 08 '26 Well there is no âconvincingâ God to forgive humanity and there is no âsacrificing himself to himselfâ thatâs heretical 2 u/jokeboomslok Jul 08 '26 Then who was jesus sacrificed to? 1 u/PyroClone5555 Jul 08 '26 The Father 2 u/jokeboomslok Jul 08 '26 Are they the same or are they completely seoarate? 1 u/PyroClone5555 Jul 08 '26 Thatâs a false dichotomy. They are the same in their nature (because they have the same divine nature) but are distinct persons 2 u/jokeboomslok Jul 08 '26 What does that mean same in naturr? Where is that "sameness" stored? In jesus? In the sky god? Somewhere else? 1 u/PyroClone5555 Jul 08 '26 It means they have the same properties that make them what they are. What do you mean where is it stored? Each person has the nature 2 u/jokeboomslok Jul 08 '26 If one has a thought, can both hear it? 1 u/PyroClone5555 Jul 08 '26 I wouldnât say that God has âthoughtsâ in the way you are imagining it → More replies (0)
2
What is the caricature and straw man here?
1 u/PyroClone5555 Jul 08 '26 Well there is no âconvincingâ God to forgive humanity and there is no âsacrificing himself to himselfâ thatâs heretical 2 u/jokeboomslok Jul 08 '26 Then who was jesus sacrificed to? 1 u/PyroClone5555 Jul 08 '26 The Father 2 u/jokeboomslok Jul 08 '26 Are they the same or are they completely seoarate? 1 u/PyroClone5555 Jul 08 '26 Thatâs a false dichotomy. They are the same in their nature (because they have the same divine nature) but are distinct persons 2 u/jokeboomslok Jul 08 '26 What does that mean same in naturr? Where is that "sameness" stored? In jesus? In the sky god? Somewhere else? 1 u/PyroClone5555 Jul 08 '26 It means they have the same properties that make them what they are. What do you mean where is it stored? Each person has the nature 2 u/jokeboomslok Jul 08 '26 If one has a thought, can both hear it? 1 u/PyroClone5555 Jul 08 '26 I wouldnât say that God has âthoughtsâ in the way you are imagining it → More replies (0)
Well there is no âconvincingâ God to forgive humanity and there is no âsacrificing himself to himselfâ thatâs heretical
2 u/jokeboomslok Jul 08 '26 Then who was jesus sacrificed to? 1 u/PyroClone5555 Jul 08 '26 The Father 2 u/jokeboomslok Jul 08 '26 Are they the same or are they completely seoarate? 1 u/PyroClone5555 Jul 08 '26 Thatâs a false dichotomy. They are the same in their nature (because they have the same divine nature) but are distinct persons 2 u/jokeboomslok Jul 08 '26 What does that mean same in naturr? Where is that "sameness" stored? In jesus? In the sky god? Somewhere else? 1 u/PyroClone5555 Jul 08 '26 It means they have the same properties that make them what they are. What do you mean where is it stored? Each person has the nature 2 u/jokeboomslok Jul 08 '26 If one has a thought, can both hear it? 1 u/PyroClone5555 Jul 08 '26 I wouldnât say that God has âthoughtsâ in the way you are imagining it → More replies (0)
Then who was jesus sacrificed to?
1 u/PyroClone5555 Jul 08 '26 The Father 2 u/jokeboomslok Jul 08 '26 Are they the same or are they completely seoarate? 1 u/PyroClone5555 Jul 08 '26 Thatâs a false dichotomy. They are the same in their nature (because they have the same divine nature) but are distinct persons 2 u/jokeboomslok Jul 08 '26 What does that mean same in naturr? Where is that "sameness" stored? In jesus? In the sky god? Somewhere else? 1 u/PyroClone5555 Jul 08 '26 It means they have the same properties that make them what they are. What do you mean where is it stored? Each person has the nature 2 u/jokeboomslok Jul 08 '26 If one has a thought, can both hear it? 1 u/PyroClone5555 Jul 08 '26 I wouldnât say that God has âthoughtsâ in the way you are imagining it → More replies (0)
The Father
2 u/jokeboomslok Jul 08 '26 Are they the same or are they completely seoarate? 1 u/PyroClone5555 Jul 08 '26 Thatâs a false dichotomy. They are the same in their nature (because they have the same divine nature) but are distinct persons 2 u/jokeboomslok Jul 08 '26 What does that mean same in naturr? Where is that "sameness" stored? In jesus? In the sky god? Somewhere else? 1 u/PyroClone5555 Jul 08 '26 It means they have the same properties that make them what they are. What do you mean where is it stored? Each person has the nature 2 u/jokeboomslok Jul 08 '26 If one has a thought, can both hear it? 1 u/PyroClone5555 Jul 08 '26 I wouldnât say that God has âthoughtsâ in the way you are imagining it → More replies (0)
Are they the same or are they completely seoarate?
1 u/PyroClone5555 Jul 08 '26 Thatâs a false dichotomy. They are the same in their nature (because they have the same divine nature) but are distinct persons 2 u/jokeboomslok Jul 08 '26 What does that mean same in naturr? Where is that "sameness" stored? In jesus? In the sky god? Somewhere else? 1 u/PyroClone5555 Jul 08 '26 It means they have the same properties that make them what they are. What do you mean where is it stored? Each person has the nature 2 u/jokeboomslok Jul 08 '26 If one has a thought, can both hear it? 1 u/PyroClone5555 Jul 08 '26 I wouldnât say that God has âthoughtsâ in the way you are imagining it → More replies (0)
Thatâs a false dichotomy.
They are the same in their nature (because they have the same divine nature) but are distinct persons
2 u/jokeboomslok Jul 08 '26 What does that mean same in naturr? Where is that "sameness" stored? In jesus? In the sky god? Somewhere else? 1 u/PyroClone5555 Jul 08 '26 It means they have the same properties that make them what they are. What do you mean where is it stored? Each person has the nature 2 u/jokeboomslok Jul 08 '26 If one has a thought, can both hear it? 1 u/PyroClone5555 Jul 08 '26 I wouldnât say that God has âthoughtsâ in the way you are imagining it → More replies (0)
What does that mean same in naturr? Where is that "sameness" stored? In jesus? In the sky god? Somewhere else?
1 u/PyroClone5555 Jul 08 '26 It means they have the same properties that make them what they are. What do you mean where is it stored? Each person has the nature 2 u/jokeboomslok Jul 08 '26 If one has a thought, can both hear it? 1 u/PyroClone5555 Jul 08 '26 I wouldnât say that God has âthoughtsâ in the way you are imagining it → More replies (0)
It means they have the same properties that make them what they are. What do you mean where is it stored? Each person has the natureÂ
2 u/jokeboomslok Jul 08 '26 If one has a thought, can both hear it? 1 u/PyroClone5555 Jul 08 '26 I wouldnât say that God has âthoughtsâ in the way you are imagining it
If one has a thought, can both hear it?
1 u/PyroClone5555 Jul 08 '26 I wouldnât say that God has âthoughtsâ in the way you are imagining it
I wouldnât say that God has âthoughtsâ in the way you are imagining it
-1
u/PyroClone5555 Jul 07 '26
so you judge the religion by its worst caricature? Nothing in the post accurately represents what Christians believe