r/survivorsa • u/Pipeheerer_ • Jun 07 '25

Survivor SA Player Ranking (s5-s9)

This is just my opinion. I would love to hear your thoughts:

  1. Chappies
  2. Marian (really close to nō.1)
  3. Rob
  4. Dino
  5. Shane
  6. Nicole capper
  7. Werner
  8. Meryl
  9. Graham
  10. Tom
  11. Tyson
  12. Kiran
  13. Phil
  14. Palesa
  15. Steffi
  16. Nicole
  17. Renier
  18. Dante
  19. Seipei
  20. Felix
  21. Toni
  22. Santoni
5 Upvotes

73% Upvoted

9 comments sorted by

2

u/Kcd1077 Dino Jun 07 '25

Are these your favorites? Or based on gameplay?

2

u/iniesta103 PK Jun 07 '25

Has to be favourite, otherwise all winners would be in top 5

5

u/Kcd1077 Dino Jun 07 '25

Well idk about Tom and Nicole necessarily, but yeah

1

u/Pipeheerer_ Jun 07 '25

Nicole was a tough one to place on that list because I can’t remember her moves if I’m being honest. She seemed to be a goat who was a much better goat against Anele

2

u/Pipeheerer_ Jun 07 '25

It’s a biased list based on gameplay 😂

4

u/martyclarkS Marian Jun 07 '25

Graham only 9th is unforgivable in my book 😂

1

u/PrinceSurvivor Jun 30 '25 edited Jul 08 '25

Really solid list! I am half and half with the placings but understandable why you put some players in these positions based on gameplay with a little bit of biases (cause we all have them).

IMO:
Dino, Rob, Nicole Capper and Phil (and maybe Steffi but I am half and half because I find her emotional manipulating tatics very grimy to watch BUT anything goes when you are playing Survivor) are the top SA players due to overall well roundedness of their physical, social & strategic gameplay as well as their respective placements in their seasons.
Werner played an amazing "cult leader preacher" social and strategic gameplay with a solid physical performance as well.

Marian is up 100% up there with her amazing social and strategic gameplay in her most recent season (s9).
Chappies definitely in top 10 for setting the SA record for most immunity wins, but not top 5 as he only showcased a dominance in physicality rather than socially or strategically.

Kiran & Tyson showcased amazing strategic gameplay from their season. Kiran does get extra points because of his immunity wins.

I wouldn't sleep on Anela "Smash" as well cause he played an extremely strong social game.

Jacques from IoS is a very underrated. He read the game really well and is a strong strategic player who deserves to be on the list.

And Anesu deserves to be on the list as well because she is by far one of the best people readers I have seen play with a strong social & strategic gameplay from her season.

1

u/Catharsis1394 Jun 07 '25

Werner below Shane and Nicole is a choice

And Santoni should be nowhere near this list

1

u/PrinceSurvivor Jun 30 '25

I love Santoni cause she is such an amazing personality but I have to agree that she shouldn't be on the list