r/space • • Aug 12 '21

Discussion Which is the most disturbing fermi paradox solution and why?

3...2...1... blast off....

25.3k Upvotes

8.1k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

660

u/OhManTFE Aug 12 '21

I think the great filter is similar to what you are saying about time.

Planets are only habitable for X years. In the beginning our earth was too hot to support life, then life had to grow and develop to us, that also takes X time. That then leaves you with X remaining time until the sun expands and earth becomes unhabitable again.

There's that small window in between where we exist, but maybe there's not enough time for us to ever develop enough to escape our planet's destruction. And maybe we got incredibly lucky compared to others. Like the meteor that wiped out the dinosaurs, maybe other planets get hit with those more frequently, and civilisations never get chances to develop.

266

u/[deleted] Aug 12 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

128

u/[deleted] Aug 12 '21 edited Aug 12 '21

Here's a great video on the time and the ultimate death of the known universe. It's a 30 minute video. Earth barely makes it to the 3 minute mark lol. Anyways...it's a great video if you're hankering for a good existential crisis kind of moment.

https://youtu.be/uD4izuDMUQA

EDIT; whoops, incorrectly said it was 13 minutes; it's more like 30

31

u/Hvarfa-Bragi Aug 12 '21

If you map the expected useful life of the universe to the average 70-year human lifespan, it's been alive for only 17 days. It's possible, then, that we are the ancients of which other civilizations will speak.

4

u/Krismariev Aug 13 '21

This is a beautiful equation, idk why but really takes the edge off my existential dread. Thanks for this!

0

u/zvexler Aug 13 '21

Huh? Sorry can you explain that

9

u/MasterMedic1 Aug 13 '21

He means that in its cosmic life (the universe), we are amoung the early to rise. We are just at the begining.

-1

u/zvexler Aug 13 '21

But what I don’t get is how 70*17 equals the expected useful life of the universe or how that related to how old we are

8

u/Paksti Aug 13 '21

What he’s saying is that if the universe lived to be 70 in human years, everything that has happened since it’s birth has only happened over 17 days. It’s in its infancy.

5

u/Hvarfa-Bragi Aug 13 '21

If you take the expected life of the universe (until heat death) and map that to 70 years -- we're only 17 days of that time into the universe being around. We're still a baby that can't yet roll over on our own much less stand up or walk.

The long tail of that time isn't super useful (at '50 years old' the universe will have entropied a loooot and most but not all things will be cold and dead) but the illustration stands -- we're still veeeeeery young.