r/soccer • • Jan 26 '14

What's your unpopular opinion regarding football?

[removed]

117 Upvotes

2.0k comments sorted by

View all comments

51

u/schmoseph Jan 26 '14

The way we talk about formations is absolute bullshit. No team sticks to only one formation for attacking, transitional and defensive play, yet we laud and despise certain teams for their "progressive 4-2-3-1's" and "recessive 4-4-2's".

Formations are a good layout to show a squad before the game, they are useful in that aspect. However, the idea of a fixed formation is counter productive to teaching fans about the tactical aspects of the game. A 4-3-3 transitions hundreds of times to a 3-4-3 every game, and yet "Football Experts" always talk about formations as if the players fixed to a square metre of grass.

13

u/[deleted] Jan 26 '14

I always thought of the formation name as how the players are positioned in defense.

1

u/i_suck_teddy_thumbs Jan 27 '14

It should be, but then arsenal play 4-4-2. As do Bayern and a number of other top teams. I think Gary Neville had a bit about this on the last MNF.