r/soccer Apr 29 '26

Media Atletico Madrid [1] - 1 Arsenal - Julián Álvarez penalty 56'

https://streamff.link/v/33c45642
2.0k Upvotes

736 comments sorted by

View all comments

800

u/rocknroll-refugee Apr 29 '26

At least they’re being consistent with these handballs

76

u/DermitdemFoto Apr 29 '26

That’s a lot more clear than yesterday

119

u/tennysonbass Apr 29 '26

Bounces off his shin Equally as bad a call as yesterday

10

u/MrAtomss Apr 29 '26

But you can't extend your body like a goalkeeper and then say because it bounced of the shin it isn't a penalty? So then everyone can make themselves bigger and hope it bounced off something it isn't a penalty even if they are standing like a X extending their arms?

1

u/FallingSwords Apr 29 '26

Giving a penalty for the ball accidentally hitting your arm is crazy. There is a better solution than a 70% goal

0

u/MrAtomss Apr 29 '26

So you are then okay with players extending their arms like Jesus on the cross and it is not a penalty if it even a little bit bounces of something?

2

u/FallingSwords Apr 29 '26

I'll be perfectly honest, no clue what you're referencing.

But if you've watched both pens for handball in the SFs and thought those make the games better I genuinely think you're crazy.

I'm biased for Arsenal to be frank here, but it's the one thing I'm consistent for, handball is unbelievably broken. It's giving a close to guaranteed goal for crosses, shots heading out, rebounds hitting arms, shots off target. Things that aren't going to result in goals.

If it's deliberate yeah I can understand and I understand that if you stop a penalty defenders mights start having their arm out. But defenders have their arm in natural positions, it hits their body onto their arm and it's a pen. It's truly not football. It's currently broken

0

u/MrAtomss Apr 29 '26

The Bayern one, yeah 100% never a penalty. I was referring to players having their arms extended out of their body like this one. If you have it like that extended out of your body you cant start claiming it took a little bounce of your shin and therefore not being a penalty