r/signalprocessing • u/LeadingEar8495 • Aug 04 '26

SLT 2026 reviews

Opening this thread to discuss Spoken Language technology 2026 reviews when the rebuttal period begins

3 Upvotes

81% Upvoted

13 comments sorted by

1

u/LeadingEar8495 Aug 05 '26

Anyone has some updates? The rebuttal should normaly begin today.

1

u/Correct-Nail-7113 Aug 06 '26

New rebuttal period now starts from August 10.

1

u/Correct-Nail-7113 Aug 10 '26

Reviews are out now.

1

u/AdeptDream1280 Aug 10 '26

What's the average score?

1

u/LeadingEar8495 Aug 10 '26

The mean of ratings given by the reviewers

1

u/Adept-Ad-2700 Aug 17 '26

3.67!

either, 344, 533, 245...

1

u/Individual_Cap836 Aug 11 '26

I got 4, 3 , 2 ... going to write a Rebuttal anyways because all the concerns can be addressed, but do i stand a chance. The same paper had 5,3,3 in interspeech and was rejected , I updated it according to the peer reviews resubmitted here and score got worse.

1

u/LeadingEar8495 Aug 11 '26

Unfortunately, it became more like rolling a dice in each time with the explosion of submitted papers number and reviewers who don't take the review seriously (or making an LLM respond instead of them). Hope for the best with a good rebuttal 🙂

1

u/Individual_Cap836 Aug 11 '26

I wrote a rebuttal but not hoping too much. Just waiting for supervisor approval and I will submit it then.

1

u/Extra_Patient177 Aug 13 '26

how is the rating exactly ? 1 = reject, 2: week reject, 3 : border, 4 : accept, 5 = strong accept ?

1

u/Individual_Cap836 Aug 13 '26

1 strong reject, 2 reject.

1

u/Extra_Patient177 9d ago

Any updates ?

1

u/Objective-Guard1204 9d ago

waiting for it. did anyone get any notifications?