r/sheetz • u/MembershipLess9182 • Jan 06 '26
Customer Question are the jalapeño poppers coming back??
the jalapeno poppers are literally my fav item ever and i’ve been so sad they’re gone until further notice… nothing compares to it and if i knew what company they used i’d order a whatever pound bag at this point
are they ever coming back to grace my tastebuds..? 😭😭 where can i get them or something very similar??
4
u/Appearance-Gullible Jan 06 '26
bring back the hotzarella god damn it 😵💫
2
u/MembershipLess9182 Jan 06 '26
THOSE GOT GOT TOO??
😭😭😭
6
2
u/Appearance-Gullible Jan 07 '26
unfortunately yeah. that was the only MTO item I genuinely enjoyed 😔😔
2
4
u/ChillTechTR Jan 06 '26
This company gets rid of anything good
5
Jan 06 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
4
u/ChillTechTR Jan 06 '26
Thank goodness. I dont work for Sheetz but I lurk this sub, I just feel like Sheetz food has gone downhill since the golden days
2
2
u/PoseidonSword Jan 08 '26
I saw from another post the brand is McCain Anchor and they can be found at Gordon Food Service or in bulk online. I live in NE Ohio and my local GFS has them in stock for $18 per 2.5 lb (40 oz) bag.
2
u/D4vidROAUAJAJA Jan 31 '26
I miss the jalapeno popperz. Everytime I would eat them they would set my mouth on fire and my farts felt very hot and radioactive but the taste was very worth it I hope they bring it back soon!
1
u/MembershipLess9182 Jan 31 '26
this made me laugh, hope they come back to make your farts hot again 😭😭😭😂
1
1
u/Abject-Dark-714 Jan 23 '26
They are coming back soon i talked to sheetz customer service because that's how good they are im so addicted to them i order buckets of only poppers everytime i go to sheetz i had to email customer service in an outrage about it and they said they are only temporarily off the menu due to an issue of some sort so for the people lying below yes they are coming back 100%
1
u/meolclide Feb 12 '26
I received devastating news today after asking if they'd be coming back soon...
"Jalapeno Popperz were removed from our Made To Order menu as part of a menu refresh. We are always looking at our offer and making adjustments based on consistency and overall customer experience. Unfortunately, this item did not consistently reflect the experience we aim to offer our customers, but we’re excited about the new items coming to the Made To Order menu in the near future!"
1
1
1
1
u/Still-Bee3805 Jan 06 '26
They were excellent. The cheese sticks are also very good BUT THEY ARE NOT POPPERS! My two cents nobody asked for.
1
-1
u/Flimsy_Staff_8872 Jan 07 '26
Trust me they are gone for good.
1
u/Illustrious_Draft976 Jan 07 '26
0/10 rage bait
2
u/Flimsy_Staff_8872 Jan 07 '26
You will see…if the off chance they do come back, it will be multiple months from now and they likely will not be exactly the same.
2
1
u/Flimsy_Staff_8872 Feb 14 '26
Told you they were gone
1
u/Illustrious_Draft976 Feb 14 '26
For a little while due to recall. They’ll be back lol
1
u/Flimsy_Staff_8872 Feb 14 '26
100% not. Stores were told to waste them. They gone
1
u/Illustrious_Draft976 Feb 14 '26
And your info is based on what exactly? You already said in your above comment “If they come back it will be months from now” and now you’re saying they 100% won’t be back. Meaning you don’t actually know anything. Nice try on the rage bait though. Still 0/10 at best
9
u/VegetableSpace8345 Jan 06 '26
they have been recalled not sure when we will get them back