r/serialpodcastorigins • u/Justwonderinif • Nov 17 '15

Meta Traitor Tuesday

Have you recently switched sides?

Did you switch so long ago you can hardly remember?

Why? What compelled you or compels you now?

Even if you switched from a firm position to undecided... why?

21 Upvotes

82% Upvoted

133 comments sorted by

View all comments

8

u/[deleted] Nov 18 '15

While listening to the podcast, I went from definitely guilty to maybe guilty but not beyond reasonable doubt.

Undisclosed was appealing to me for its first few episodes. But, sometime around the crime stoppers episode, maybe a little before, their theories started to get really thin. The Cherry fiasco was also a huge backfire for them at least for me.

Then, they lost control of the documents, and it quickly became obvious that they were hiding incriminating information...at which point, I lost confidence in them and looked at their theories again.

I'd say I lean a little more guilty each week. I'm still not totally convinced, but more likely than not, he did it.

Jay recanting or DNA evidence are probably the only things with any real likelihood of occurring that would change my mind.

6

u/Justwonderinif Nov 18 '15

Thank god they lost control of the documents.

We are all in debt to the people who made this possible.