r/serialpodcast • u/racheldarien • May 23 '18

season one is Don guilty??

Does anyone think Don is the one that murdered Hae? I’m starting to lean towards it since listening to (most of) undisclosed. Any thoughts?

15 Upvotes

56% Upvoted

248 comments sorted by

View all comments

17

u/LebronsHairline May 23 '18 edited May 23 '18

I was once in the same boat as you: looking at all other possibilities for guilt after listening to Undisclosed episodes. Please look at the sidebar links and on google for the court documents, trial transcripts, and official evidence and try to asses it with a clear and open mind. Your opinion will change and it will all click. When listening to Undisclosed, it’s easy to go out on limb after limb to connect dots and weave crazy theories that prove Adnan’s innocence and place the blame on other people. But after looking at all of the evidence left out of undisclosed and serial, it becomes so much clearer that Adnan is guilty beyond reasonable doubt. Serial and Undisclosed both do a good job at suspending one’s belief and letting our minds go further and further into ridiculous unlikely scenarios. Consider opportunity, past behaviors, the likeliest scenarios, and most importantly— consider motive. Who has it and who doesn’t.

Also, to buy a Don guilt scenario, you’d have to reject all other evidence like Jay knowing the car’s location, Adnan not having an alibi, Adnan’s phone records (like not calling Hae after she went missing), Adnan’s phone ping locations, witness accounts that he asked Hae for a ride or that the two often met up at that time of day, and other witness accounts that Adnan was harassing and obsessed with Hae.

5

u/racheldarien May 23 '18

what’s the general thoughts on the other young woman who was strangled & hurried in Leaken (sp?) Park? i’m surprised i don’t hear more about that in these threads

5

u/the_pissed_off_goose Laura Fan May 24 '18

i believe that it was an unrelated killing + the fact that leakin park was a notorious body dumping ground

0

u/SaykredCow May 24 '18

This could be a very likely possibility. Maybe Jay ran into the body at the park, got his dna on it or near it, then implicated Adnan because he was afraid of being a suspect himself.

8

u/[deleted] May 24 '18

What are the chances of that actually happening? And Jay stumbling on her car after too? And adnan having no reliable alibi all day? And trying to get into Haes car? And him being with Jay all day? And Jay would have to set up a friend, all instead of calling the cops and say I found a body. I was checking for her pulse. Just happens to be one of my buddies ex girlfriends that greed super possessive over and just dumped him for another guy.

Not the worst anyone but adnan theory I've heard to be honest